Robert Nozick's Postition on Ethics - Essay Example

Only on StudentShare

Extract of sample
Robert Nozick's Postition on Ethics

Thus, the main rule or the formula in terms of Mill’s utilitarian thesis is that we ought to act and make decisions on the basis that the greatest good for the greatest number is achieved. Conversely, the basic tenets of Nozick’s position on decision theory, runs as follows: Nozick argues that our decisions ought to pass a test which states that one should only will for themselves that which they were willing to have everyone else do. Phrased in other terms, we ought not to lie because we would not be living in a society where lying was manifest universally. This notion is the categorical imperative, and it is central in terms of the philosophical background for the problem of incommensurability. More importantly, it is a shift in emphasis that maintains that it is the consequences and not the intentions that matter. It will be argued that Nozick's position is incommesurable with utilitarianism on the grounds that his focus is on the consequences, and this is an extension of what he see's as the limitations of focusing on the 'intentions' of actions. Considering the consequences and the intentions of an ethical decision is incommensurable, and this is the core of Nozick's critique of utilitarianism. ...Show more

Summary

The following will demonstrate how incommensurable, Robert Nozick's position on ethics is with utilitarianism. This paper will look at Nozick, and in turn, present a critique of his position. To understand the basis for in-commensurability, is to understand the two key philosophical approaches to moral decisions, namely, utilitarianism and Nozick's more ‘deontological’ oriented decision theory…
Author : boganlarry
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Robert Nozick's Postition on Ethics"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

Readings are from Robert Nozick's The Examined Life
Nozick bases his happiness philosophy on two thought experiments that are the direction of happiness and the experience machine. Nozick’s first thought experience is the direction of happiness thought. Nozick is of the opinion that people care more than the amount of happiness they experience in their lives.
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Ethics
This conflict of ethical perspectives originates in the conflict of cultures, norms, beliefs, values, trends and traditions. Our perceptions of ethics and our definition of good and bad is fundamentally influenced by our cultural traditions and learning. This paper provides a comprehensive insight into my perceptions about the different aspects of ethics including the most convincing system of ethics, ethics’ principles, definition of good life, source of ethics, definition of ethically bad life, judgment in the realm of ethics, value of ethical decisions beyond immediate outcomes, and its implications on humans.
6 pages (1500 words) Assignment
Ethics
The main objective of the essay is to analyze the situations of both the scientists, as well as the consequences rendered by these situations in the light of deontology and consequentialism. The essay will first explain the situation of scientist A and discuss the ethical aspects involved in the case with the help of supporting sources and then it will do the same in the second case.
12 pages (3000 words) Essay
Ethics
They attempt to place emphasis on morality through analyzing the secular and rational mindset as perceived by human welling or happiness. Philosophical approach is not authoritarian, irrational or arbitrary (William 23). The religious and legal laws are subjective.
7 pages (1750 words) Research Paper
Ethics
With regards to this particular theory, every principle is valid according to specific cultural practices and beliefs. Another theory of ethics is the theory of divine command. This theory makes the argument that God alone is the one who makes decisions on moral standards since he knows everything.
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Ethics
It requires people to consider if their actions are right or wrong. It also asks people how the components that help them succeed, for example, compassion, integrity, faithfulness, and honesty are relevant in everyday life. Ethics looks at the fundamental principles and basic concepts of human behavior.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Preview 8 Hayek, The Road to Serfdom
In the book The Road to Serfdom, the author points out at pertinent issues which need to be addressed as far as acquisition of happiness and humankind peace are concerned. To make the issues come out clearly, he examines certain attitudes as usually displayed by man regarding man’s efforts to have peace and live in happiness.in regard to this, he points out that “Planning is the grand panacea of our age.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Ethics
This was the Kantian ethics and it required individuals to act according to their duties, which were of moral law. For all people to act morally they had to follow categorical imperative, which ensured that everyone acted according to the same duty irrespective of their desires or interests.
8 pages (2000 words) Essay
What Is Morality? DB Unit 5
Moreover, the boss also imposed restriction on researching and hence, it became his duty too. (Reily, Sirgy & Gorman, 2012) No 2. Teleological or Consequence-based perspective
1 pages (250 words) Assignment
Philosophy Principles of sound reasoning
This discussion will focus on tautologies; tautologies are described as redundant repetition of words or repletion of words to exhibit logic of certain issues. Moreover, the discussion will attempt to evaluate whether some of these tautologies are contradictory or not; a
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Rousseanu
For Locke, marriage is not just utilitarian; there is a factor of love to it. The same way a dad’s power over his kids is not absolute, a man’s power over his spouse is not absolute also. He even advocates for divorce if the woman and man
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Find out how much would it cost
to get a custom paper written by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT