Compare and contrast the ethical theories of Aristotle and Immanuel Kant

Compare and contrast the ethical theories of Aristotle and Immanuel Kant Essay example
College
Essay
Philosophy
Pages 4 (1004 words)
Download 0
(student's name) (professor's name) (date of submission) Compare and contrast the ethical theories of Aristotle and Immanuel Kant as outlined in chapter 9. What are the strengths and weaknesses of each of thespositions? Which one do you believe is the most likely to be correct?…

Introduction

Man should be oriented by entities in his or her environment of the definition of what is morally good or not. However, if one should ask, what makes an ethical person? What are the characteristics that make him a good person? Aristotle and Kant’s ethical theories have laid out arguments claiming man’s ethics. However, there are significant ideas that make one theory triumph over the other. Aristotle and Kant speak of the highest good that man can do to society and his own – one that is not to be done just for the sake of being called ethical, getting material possessions or pleasing comments in exchange for it. It is done because it is “good in itself” (Johnson). Both also speak of happiness as ends of being virtuous. However, according to Aristotle, a virtuous life leading to happiness is not achieved without the possession of additional goods as well. A life perceived to be perfect by many, a life with wealth, power, acquaintances, and a physique highly appreciated by everyone. With this life also comes good upbringing, and good habits. Without these things, man will have the difficulty of reaching a virtuous status. Aristotle insists that it is necessary to have these desirable things to be able to reach happiness. In a negative light, this is unfair for those who are born without much fortune. ...
Download paper
Not exactly what you need?

Related papers

Immanuel Kant
He has also influenced many other great thinkers of modern times. It was because of the wholeness of Kant’s work that many people from different professional backgrounds identify with him. Kant wrote extensively on political philosophy, moral philosophy, perception, and categories of the faculty of understanding. In this paper we will attempt to outline the main ideas of Kant and then an…
Aristotle and Kant: Comparative Analysis of Ethical Philosophy
Aristotle, a Greek philosopher, has formulated his ethical thought during the Greek period that became one of the foundations of the contemporary philosophical thought. Kant, on the other hand, has worked out his philosophy during the period of Enlightenment wherein there is already an advancement of knowledge system. Firstly, what is the most common between the two philosophers? It is mainly the…
Plato and Aristotle Theories
For example, when we look at an orange, we analyze the particular orange and a universal form of an orange. Moreover, when we place the orange near a plate, we speak of both of them been next to each other. Furthermore, he also argued the existence of “unistantiated universals”. These are universal forms that do not relate to a particular thing. When we speak that there is a particular good in…
Compare And Contrast The Theories Advanced By Mill And Kant By Applying Them To A Specific Situation.
Considering the brutality of this punishment it has been abandoned in most countries of the world. Today some American countries are still practicing this punishment. Undoubtedly, it won't be wrong to say that the death penalty is the harshest form of punishment that persists in the world. Today the easiest way to execute this punishment is by inducing the lethal injections. Capital punishment has…
Jeremy Bentham and Immanuel Kant on Suicide
Whether this number of suicide cases is reasonable or not, it is assumed that when the act was committed and even only at that point, an individual had considered suicide as the most reasonable means of surviving the situation, and that the number of people who accept such an idea may in fact be increasing. The 18th century philosophers Jeremy Bentham and Immanuel Kant constructed ethical…
Immanuel Kant - Universalizability Test
The maxim in question is considered as a universal law when it is established whether it has contradictions. The test checks for the contradiction of the maxim in either concept or in will. Contradiction in concept involves the fact that the maxim is unable to meet the threshold of being regarded as a universal law without it presenting a contradiction while contradiction in will involves a…
Kantian Moral Theory
In order to achieve the above task the paper has been divided in four parts. Firstly it is important to identify the methods of justification used by Kant in Groundwork of Metaphysics of Moral. A general overview is also made regarding the value of Kant's work for the researchers in the area of moral philosophy. From that the second part of this essay refers to the theories of justification used…