StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Does the Problem of Evil Provide a Defeater for the Existence of God - Essay Example

Extract of sample
Does the Problem of Evil Provide a Defeater for the Existence of God

One of the major functions of religious belief has been to give human beings a structure and a set of codes to help them minimize their exposure to this evil, by concentrating on God and keeping themselves pure and well away from temptations and sins. This paper traces some of the main arguments that have been used throughout history to explain the problem of evil and concludes that it can never be fully explained due to the difference between human and divine ability to understand things.
In the simplest terms there is a basic contradiction in the fact that both God and evil exist. We can accept that it is not possible to know where God came from, since he is eternal, having existed always, existing now, and going on to exist for ever into the future. But what about evil? It seems unlikely that a God who is absolutely good would actually create evil. Similarly, if he came across evil arising out of what he created, then it seems logical that a God who is good would eliminate evil from the world, or would prevent it from occurring in the first place. How can a good God stand by and watch terrible injustices, suffering of innocents, or indeed be the cause of these evils? This is a big moral and logical problem which has been tacked from several different angles.
From an atheist perspective the answer is quite straightforward: the absence of intervention to stop evil from happening proves that there is no such thing as an absolutely powerful and absolutely good God, as defined in the Judaeo Christian tradition. One solution to the apparent contradiction between the existence of evil and the existence of God, is to argue that God and evil are two separate and different things, and that evil is in some mysterious way the “opposite” of God. This line of reasoning preserves the absolute goodness of God, and means he is not contaminated by the bad things that happen in the world. From this position it can be argued that that evil is a necessary thing because without it, we would not be able to understand the goodness of God. An analogy from the physical world would be the relationship between light and darkness. It is possible to conceive of absolute light, and absolute darkness, but in these two extreme situations we would be blind, and not able to appreciate anything in the middle of them properly. This is quite a promising line of argument, because it places the problem in the limited, physical nature of man, rather than the realm of logic or ideas. The physical world, unlike the world of pure ideas, is not an absolute situation, and it exists between the extremes of good and evil, in such a way that they set up a contrast, allowing us to operate in the grey area in the middle, an by implication make choices to orient ourselves towards the one or the other extreme. In the history of Christianity this kind of thinking was put forward as a suggestion but quickly condemned, and it is since known as the “Manichean heresy.” The problem with this line of argument is that it waters down the essential nature of the divine being, in order to explain away the problem of evil. This solution also implies either that evil was co-existent with God from the beginning, so that good and evil define the nature of God, or that God in some way relinquished some of his omnipotence when he created the earth, and allowed evil to take on existence ...Show more


Theologians have noted also that the scriptures of this religious tradition also speak in quite strong terms of the existence of evil. Philosophers and some theologians have also pointed out that there is much that happens in the world, including wars, diseases, natural disasters and all kinds of pain and suffering which either are evil in themselves…
Author : grahamelecta
Does the Problem of Evil Provide a Defeater for the Existence of God essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Does the Problem of Evil Provide a Defeater for the Existence of God"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Check these samples - they also fit your topic

Present the argument from evil against the existence of god,and explain the major objections to the argument, and the major resp
Even as many God concepts exist, it’s possible to examine a number of general objections and responses to the problem of evil and the existence of God. Argument In considering the problem of evil and God one of the major considerations is the nature of God as a supreme and moral being.
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Benevolent God and Problem of Evil
“Does God Exist?” This is one of the most important questions that each one of us has asked ourselves at one point or another. Theists and atheists, philosophers and theologians, scientists and logicians have all tried to answer this question.
7 pages (1750 words) Essay
Problem of Evil
The Logical Argument Logical problem consists in the consideration that the existence of evil human beings experience questions the existence of the perfect God (Michael 320). This is because some people ask why God permits various bad and horrible things to happen.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
The problem of evil
This paper explores the concept of the problem of evil. The problem of evil arises from the scope of nature that identifies conflicting theories in existence of evil. This is because a consideration of the nature of God and His power should not allow evil to prevail, or should at least be able to eliminate evil.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
The problem of evil
It is therefore particularly difficult to understand the existence of evil, a rebellious force against God’s plans, and His creation, in an environment in which God’s power is believed to be supreme. It is for example expected that as light drives away darkness, God’s power eliminate evil.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
The existence of god
Anselm’s ontological approach supports the concept that there is a perfect being i.e. God. However, criticisms have arose against Anselm’s approach, the prominent being Gaunilo of Marmoutiers’ Perfect-Island Concept. This paper discusses the logic that God does exist through focusing on the criticisms that Gaunilo, Kant, and Hume’s criticisms to Anselm’s theory.
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Existence of God
en a God that had created it; teleological, which is when people believe that God exist because of an order and the details of a creation, such as human lives; and the moral argument, which states that there could be no morality without God. Out of these four arguments, the one
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Does the Problem of Evil Provide a Defeater for the Existence of God
According to the report the Judaeo-Christian tradition the existence of a personal God who is absolutely good is a central tenet. He is absolutely powerful, and the first cause of everything that exists because he created the world out of nothing. Theologians noted that the scriptures of this religious tradition speak in quite strong terms of the existence of evil.
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Decarts and existence of evil
Descartes argument for the existence of God cannot be stretched to apply to another argument regarding the existence of an Evil Demon. This is because Descartes establishes a clear line of thought that is specific to
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
The evil-god challenge
As a matter of fact good and evil are two different worlds which cannot exist without each other. If there were no evil people would ever know what is good and if there were no good they would never know what
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Hire a pro to write
a paper under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment
Contact Us