StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu
  • Home
  • Subjects
  • Philosophy
  • Exposit both Sartre's account of freedom and Kant's. Which of the two is the most cogent (compelling or convincing) or is th

Exposit both Sartre's account of freedom and Kant's. Which of the two is the most cogent (compelling or convincing) or is th - Essay Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
Exposit both Sartre's account of freedom and Kant's. Which of the two is the most cogent (compelling or convincing) or is th

Nevertheless, looking at the universal aspects of morality and rationality, Kantian “freedom” is more cogent to get it and further put in action. First off, the existentialistic ideas proposed by Sartre follow the idea of absurd and determinism. To be precise, Sartre is likely to suggest a free will when he talks on freedom able to override people’s rationality (Palmer 283). In other words, he pinpoints that a man is allowed to do what he/she wants to notwithstanding possible negative outcomes after possessing such a freedom. Obviously, Sartre highlights the concept of freedom in keeping with the best tradition of the existentialism. As opposed to Kant’s interpretation, Sartre underpins the idea of freedom by the idea of values people get thereafter: “Sartre has radicalized Kant’s view that the source of value is always the human being, and he has prioritized freedom over rationality” (Palmer 292). Henceforth, Sartre does not rely on the omnipotence and power of reason. Regardless of it, he shows up the pleasure of freedom as if behind the social life. In turn, Kant would oppose this characterization by giving more grounds to freedom which is a result of a man’s rationality. Immanuel Kant worked out his own vision of the moral philosophy when highlighting the need for freedom. However, he suggests lots of arguments to make his vision out. Thereupon, Kant outlines the meaning of autonomy going hand in hand with what he claims to be freedom. Although Sartre is likely to denote the authorship of a man in what he/she does, Kant is driven by giving some contrast to justify morality and freedom. Thus, he points out morality as a contradiction between duty and inclination and freedom as a controversy between autonomy and heteronomy (Sandel 117). The latter is an opposition to being autonomous, as might be seen. In this vein, Kantian philosophy states that freedom and justice go hand in hand. That is, a person subject to the law is one to accept freedom in its core values. Ostensibly, such evaluation of freedom goes apart with Sartre’s understanding thereof. In fact, Kant’s philosophic treatment of people’s actions can be simply narrowed down to his well-known categorical imperative which is all about mutuality in actions people commit toward one another. Kant’s claims are possible through his close attention to living within the society and complying with the rules and norms of social life. His moral position touches upon the “intelligible” realm when he remarks: “…we transfer ourselves into the intelligible world as members and recognize the autonomy of the will together with its consequence - morality” (Sandel 128). Membership comes first as a prerequisite of sharing similar ideals and values between individuals. Societal constraints like the law and its execution serve to strike a balance within the society leading toward freedom. In the European tradition, it is all about the democracy as a weighed sum of people’s wants and needs so that to make all of them free and autonomous as well. When Sartre is quite straight-forward paying much attention to the freedom of action despite of the legal limits shared within the society, Kant just traces back to the basic rules of a civilized social life so that to construct the most applicable and unrepugnant concept of freedom. The difference is that Kant is more obliged to the norms of the society seeing a human being as a biosocial creature equally dependant on the natural ...Show more

Summary

The concept of freedom is one of the main for different peoples and communities in order to get the best they can and to have peaceful relationships, therefore. However, an entirely difficult meaning of freedom differs for various persons and even whole nations…
Author : muellershad
Exposit both Sartres account of freedom and Kants. Which of the two is the most cogent (compelling or convincing) or is th essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Exposit both Sartre's account of freedom and Kant's. Which of the two is the most cogent (compelling or convincing) or is th"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

Today, two of the most compelling issues facing B2B marketers today is how to not only reach buyers but how to get buyers engage
The issue becomes more complicated if the target customers are other businesses. The situation arises since customers who are business people are conversant with market trends and variations in commodity prices. This paper assesses ways in which B2B marketers maintain their buyers through effective marketing strategies.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Sartre's Philosophy of Life
Existentialism makes a man miserable and forlorn in the world and since man is not the creator of this universe, he is unable to understand the consequences of making decisions. Sartre's philosophy is that existentialism is close to humanism and as a child smiles with no worries in his inner consciousness or subconsciousness, so is the man who must lead his life as closer to nature as possible in order to attain true satisfaction (Walter 1988, p.
9 pages (2250 words) Essay
Is Sartre's Existentialist account of morality more preferable than that based on the existence of God
In order to grasp the core arguments of morality and virtue, we must first understand why they are so difficult to define for all of humanity, since so many different philosophies and religions exist today.
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Both Kant and Smith write about universities, yet they have different views of what a University must do. Explain their views. Give an account of how their th
Kant is more famous for his work on morality and the philosophy which governs human interaction while Smith is known as the father of modern economics. Both of them spent a large part of their lives in universities and were
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Assess Kant's ethics of duty and freedom
He rejected the supposedly objective accounts of the good for man –proposed by the perfectionist positions associated with Plato, Aristotle and much Christian ethics–, as well as the subjective conceptions
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Freedom, Our Public and Private Interests, and Kant's Questions
There are many similarities between Kant and the earlier arguments of Aquinas, which have both proved important in developing ethical theory and international relations theory. However, whilst there are similarities, Kant and
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Which of the following theoretical approaches offers the most convincing account of the power of the EU as an international actor: Realism; Liberalism or Constructivism
The two world wars and the cold war resulted due to existence of certain phenomena like war, diplomacy, the balance of power, the several
10 pages (2500 words) Essay
Which of the following theoretical approaches offers the most convincing account of the power of the EU as an international actor: Realism; Liberalism or Constructivism
The two world wars and the cold war resulted due to existence of certain phenomena like war, diplomacy, the balance of power, the several
10 pages (2500 words) Essay
What are the most convincing models that account for the way citizens make electoral choices in Britain today
y in being given space in a job alongside the availability of time for one to involve himself or herself in electoral process (Brynin, and Newton 2010, 23). Citizen engagement in political processes has become an issue of debate in Britain. Since 1964, the numbers of people who
12 pages (3000 words) Essay
Two Paths to Freedom
Both leaders were fighting for better treatment of the Black man. Although Martin fought for African American liberation without the use of violence, Martin
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation