Plato versus Nehamas & Kant versus Hume - Essay Example

Free

Extract of sample
Plato versus Nehamas & Kant versus Hume

Majority of critics in art and literature have not only been enthralled by Plato’s views on the ‘Republic’ but also questioned on the validity of mimesis in art. Other critics have opted to understand the reliability of Plato’s mimesis by criticizing his works. In his work on ‘Republic’, part three, Plato banishes some of the imitations used by Aristotle but agrees to their use in other ways of imitation of good men in the society. Contradictory, in ‘Republic 10’ he agrees to Socrates banishment of imitation of the ideal society.
Nehamas believes that Plato is unable to take a general stand on inclusion of mimesis in his works. At times, Plato is seen to imitate actions of people, sounds, dramatic events, and looks of people to bring out his messages and at times, he criticizes mimesis. Nehamas does not believe in imitation adding value to an ideal city. He argues that Plato may have lifted ideas of what he saw in pictures and translated these pictures. He gives an example of a settee which may be actual or just a fallacy.
Nehamas idea of mimesis as just a misleading notion of getting readers to study various works of art holds much evidence. Mimesis may not really be valid and reliable way of conveying themes in the society. ...Show more

Summary

In his work of the ‘Republic’, Plato is renowned for his extensive use of mimesis. His works have elicited a lot of controversial discussions on the validity and importance of mimesis in works of art…
Author : faustino53
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write a custom essay on your topic
"Plato versus Nehamas & Kant versus Hume"
with a personal 20% discount.
Find out more

Related Essays

Moral Philosophy
"Even in applied ethics, awareness is often missing. The tone of much writing suggests that John Stuart Mill is still alive and that none of the twentieth centuries has happened. (‘Never such innocence again' has not been applied to ethics.) [Glover hopes] to help change this by encouraging an idea of ethics as a more empirical subject."
10 pages (2500 words) Essay
Kant and Hume on Morality
Kant’s “Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals” is an attempt in this direction while Hume’s “An Enquiry Concerning the Principles of Morals” justifies his views. Both pieces of work are contrasted below. Kant’s concepts are discussed first followed by Hume’s concepts.
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Kant vs. Hume on Moral Reasoning
Kant preached the categorical imperative, in which he stated that the principles of Universality and Reversibility (both of which will be discussed ahead in the paper) should guide human reasoning and behavior. On the other hand Hume gave precedence to human feelings over any abstract relations of rules of Universality and Reversibility as the guiding principles of human actions.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Hume
He was a huge advocate of desire and passion and considered these two elements as the centre force through which the humans made decisions consciously and sub consciously. It was a hallmark discovery by Hume which lead to a lot of scepticism in the philosopher community but later on he came to be known as one of the most popular as well as idealistic philosopher of his time.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Badiou's Versus Levina's Works
The works of both the two philosophers seek to represent different perceptions on the subject of ethics but there is no way does Badiou’s work advance our understanding of ethics beyond the works of Levina or vice – versa. In my view, both the two thinkers present two different sides of the same coin and their philosophies still end up explaining the same phenomena (Barker 64).
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Preservation of Justice as the Power to Rightness
Anselm positions God at the center of being, without whom anything exists. Freedom and will are much connected in Anselm’s argument. Anselm portrays freedom as the power to act in the right reason, which may be construed to mean having the right intention in committing any act.
9 pages (2250 words) Essay
Utilitarian versus Retributivist Views
Justification may also refer to the validity of the punishment that is being exacted on the offender as necessary and commensurate with the extent of the offense. Because of the seriousness of the concept of punishment, moral philosophy has attempted to rationalize punishment and justification, with two main theories being the most dominant: utilitarian and retributive theory.
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
What are the ultimate principles of morals for both Hume and Kant?
Immanuel Kant considers old philosophical problems using new methods. Kant defends morality from reduction to self-interest, empirical fact, or feelings. Rather, he bases his supreme moral principle on reason. Kant attempts to uncover common sense morality’s principles.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Outline and critique the subjective interpretation of probability
In mathematics, it is often applied in measuring the real or what others infer as physical inclination to something to happen, additionally, it might infer the degree to which an individual might believe something will occur, or even both of this. This is the philosophical inclination while the mathematical analysis of probability was attributed to observations regarding the behaviour of game mostly when people engaged in rolling of dices and cards.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Aesthetic relativism versus aesthetic objectivism.
The notion of anesthetic was introduced in the eighteenth century,and the term aesthetic has now become used to designate things like,kind of object,kind of experience,kind of judgment as well as a kind of value.In general,theories of aesthetic have divided over queries specific to forms of designations:whether works of arts are necessarily aesthetic objects and how to square the purportedly basis of judgments of aesthetic with the fact that reason is given in support.In addition,what is the best way to capture the elusive difference between an aesthetic attitude as well as a practical one,or whether to define an aesthetic experience in relation to representational content, and how to compreh
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Cynthia Cooper and WorldCom
On one hand, there is the option of taking the right action and whistle blowing these findings while risking retaliation from fellow employees. On the other hand, Cynthia has a choice of taking no action and risking her career
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Find out how much would it cost
to get a custom paper written by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT