StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu
  • Home
  • Subjects
  • Philosophy
  • Does the (apparently) Value-Laden Nature of Science give us Reason to Doubt the Objectivity and Reliability of Science

Does the (apparently) Value-Laden Nature of Science give us Reason to Doubt the Objectivity and Reliability of Science - Essay Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
Does the (apparently) Value-Laden Nature of Science give us Reason to Doubt the Objectivity and Reliability of Science

In the paragraphs that follow I try to identify salient arguments put forward by leading scientists representative of the epistemology under review. Science may be defined as the human endeavour to explore, investigate and understand the physical universe. Scientific method used to gain knowledge of natural phenomena includes observation, forming hypotheses or theories, conducting experiments to test hypotheses, and drawing conclusions in accepting, modifying, or rejecting hypotheses. In antiquity, philosophy encompassed all knowledge. In modern times, science has become the repository of almost all knowledge, completely epistemic and objective. Physics, from Newton’s Laws, to Einstein’s Theory of Relativity led to many technological advances, and continues to be the paradigmatic science given exact mathematical expression. Until quite recently, scientists believed that they were engaging in a value-free, positivistic and Cartesian enterprise untainted by nonepistemic values. Gregory Mikkelson introduces the subject of ‘Values in Ecology’ by pointing to the historical link between modern science and colonialism, an unlikely outcome given the much vaunted scientific criterion of impartial objectivity. To enhance the objectives of cultural and biological diversity he advocates ‘value-frankness’ instead of the outdated ideal of ‘value- freedom’. He identifies the links between ethics and science and critiques the trend towards ascribing monetary value to ecosystems. He also argues for a ‘foundational concept in ecology – that of an ecological community’ echoing other contributors to the debate. He views ethics as a branch of science examining what is ‘good’ and what is ‘right’ and also the relation between the two concepts. Ethics is about objective properties like ‘richness, diversity and harmony’ and not merely our subjective opinions of them. Even the old ideal of a value-free science was founded on ethical-subjectivist notions promoting that ideal. By openly announcing the ethical foundations of scientific inquiry, it allows for better critical assessment of its conclusions. He shows how the attempt to free ecology from values has resulted in privileging the rich with adverse effects on conservation. Next, Mark Sagoff critiques the current trend to place an economic value on ecosystem services. He says that nature has no economic value. Wind, soil, water, and the pollination services of insects are provided free, but their economic ‘non-value’ has no bearing on their intrinsic value to human beings. He even places timber in this category. Biodiversity cannot be defended on economic grounds as some economists have done in putting the cost of future environmental pollution in monetary terms. Advances in technology have compensated ‘more than adequately’ for the depletion of natural stocks. Biotechnology continues to produce better products and helps lower prices. An example cited is transgenic trees with ‘fast growth, cold-hardness, uniform and predictable quality, disease resistance, etc.’ He asserts that ‘price does not correlate with value, benefit or utility.’ He wants us not to ‘regard nature as a resource to exploit’ but ‘a heritage and an endowment to maintain’. Sagoff makes a clear value statement in defence of new thinking in ecology. I now come to Elliott and McKaughan’ ...Show more

Summary

Philosophy of Science: Does the (apparently) value-laden nature of science give us reason to doubt the objectivity and reliability of science? In this essay I argue, presenting evidence from required reading, that science is indeed value-laden, which contrary to historically entrenched beliefs and expectations, serves to enhance the objectivity, reliability and validity of scientific enterprise…
Author : pasquale84
Does the (apparently) Value-Laden Nature of Science give us Reason to Doubt the Objectivity and Reliability of Science essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Does the (apparently) Value-Laden Nature of Science give us Reason to Doubt the Objectivity and Reliability of Science"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

The Nature of Descartes' Program of Radical Doubt and the Reason He Engages in This Program
necessity of undertaking once in my life to rid myself of all the opinions I had adopted, and of commencing anew the work of building from the foundation, if I desired to establish a firm and abiding superstructure in the sciences … Today, since I have opportunely freed my mind from all cares, and since I am in the secure possession of leisure in a peaceable retirement, I will at length apply myself earnestly and freely to the general overthrow of all my former opinions.” Descartes initiates his program thus in an approach typical of an ordinary scholar under critical doubt, capable of suspending beliefs of previous academic learning.
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Science Is Value Neutral
The last group would say that science is “value neutral” that it is neither good nor bad, but neutral in its inherent ethics. The last group is correct for several reasons, but a discussion of one particular aspect of science, its ability to enhance human abilities, can demonstrate very clearly that science is certainly value neutral Science, at its most elemental and basic form, is simply a way of understanding the universe.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Does Science Threaten Religion
Over the past years, there has been debate about science being threat to the religion. Several scholars, religious hopefuls, evolutionists and the scientists have been on the forefront trying to defend themselves on this question. Science and Religion represents two different walks of life.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Science
Intechnology,scientific knowledge is put to practical ends. This knowledge comes chiefly from mathematics and the physical sciences, and it is used in designing machinery, materials, and industrial processes. In general, this work is known as engineering, a word dating back to the early days of the Industrial Revolution, when an 'engine' was any kind of machine.
10 pages (2500 words) Essay
Human Nature natural science essay
Cultural influences can have a considerable impact on the ways in which humans interact with the world. The influences that impact the footprints which humans leave on the world during the course of their respective lives can forever change the
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Science and nature
an approach with more knowledge and depth, for example knowing that the sky is blue due to refracted light; does not take away from the beauty of a blue sky but rather adds to one’s overall appreciation of its simple beauty as well as a knowledge of why it is blue. The
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Science and nature
However, it is vital that the teacher takes part in the entire process by constant intervention in the learners’ activities. In an attempt to
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Science
It is worth noting that this paper strives to give an insight into some alternative ,methods of generation of power as opposed to the one generated by water means. In simple
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Denver Museum of Nature & Science
Currently, the museum has over 1.4million specimens that are used for research; others are preserved for future generations to show the past present and the future of the community. Some of the specimens are
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Denver Museum of Nature & Science
In addition, the change of the color to black can be attributed to the use of preservatives used to store the skeleton within the Museum Premises. Remains of ancient creatures, like Dinosaurs, Jurassics
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation