StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Reformed Epistemology Insulates Religious Faith from Scientific Scrutiny - Essay Example

Extract of sample
Reformed Epistemology Insulates Religious Faith from Scientific Scrutiny

It speaks to one’s political beliefs, one’s heritage and history, and it helps people define themselves in terms of cultural groups. We form traditions, we develop a relationship with God, and we follow certain doctrines which dictate to us how to treat other human beings. Religion also attempts to answer life’s existential questions in comforting, understandable ways. But does this all mean that religion is so mysterious in its nature that it must never be questioned, and that its doctrines take precedence over the laws by which we choose to be governed? This is the territory Leiter explores in his paper - at least, he explores it to the extent that religion brushes up against secular laws. It is an interesting point of view. We all know people whose religious affiliations have exempted them, from time to time, from duties or obligations that, had they not claimed a particular religious affiliation, they would have been expected to fulfill. And we, for the most part, in the name of freedom of religion, tolerate these exemptions. But why? Why are religious individuals accorded this toleration? And if we cannot answer this question, should we continue, in fact, to tolerate their exemptions, even in the face of no reasonable evidence? Any person who has taken an American history class or studied for his or her citizenship exam is well-acquainted with the Amendment concerning freedom of religion – but perhaps it is now time to re-evaluate the concept. Leiter would have us believe that the re-evaluation is long overdue. He even goes so far as to delineate a difference between toleration and respect. (Incidentally, this writer finds it ironic that the mere publication of Leiter’s work would not be possible without the toleration he seeks to eliminate, but that is a topic for another paper.) So is Leiter justified in his premise? This paper will explore his logic, analyze some of his examples and draw a conclusion as to whether or not he has successfully made his case with regard to tolerating religion. In order to properly examine the above premise regarding “reformed epistemology”, it is necessary first to define a few terms. Epistemology, according to Webster’s dictionary is “a branch of philosophy that investigates the origin, nature, methods and limits of human knowledge.” The word “culpable” as it is used in this context appears to mean deserving blame or disapproval. Leiter’s primary objection to religion is that it does not hold up well at all under scientific scrutiny. Its evidence is scanty, its proofs non-existent, and there is no scientific explanation proving the existence of any sort of deity who could be the supposed source for religion’s categorical requirements and commandments. That said, Leiter believes that religious faith has been accorded a protection of sorts from the laws which apply to our society in all other aspects, and that he cannot find any compelling evidence for religion to deserve that kind of exception. This paper will show that, in fact, he has a valid point regarding the fact that religion should not be tolerated. He cites as his example the Canadian Supreme Court case, Multani, “[which affirms] the right of a Sikh child to carry his ceremonial knife, the kirpan, in school, in accordance ...Show more
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Reformed Epistemology Insulates Religious Faith from Scientific Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.net/philosophy/52442-topic-chosen-by-writer
(Reformed Epistemology Insulates Religious Faith from Scientific Essay)
https://studentshare.net/philosophy/52442-topic-chosen-by-writer.
“Reformed Epistemology Insulates Religious Faith from Scientific Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.net/philosophy/52442-topic-chosen-by-writer.
  • Cited: 0 times

Summary

Reformed Epistemology Insulates Religious Faith from Scientific Scrutiny “I am going to assume-uncontroversially among most philosophers but controversially among reformed epistemologists-that “reformed epistemology” is nothing more than an effort to insulate religious faith from ordinary standards of reasons and evidence in common sense and the sciences, and thus religious belief is a culpable form of unwarranted belief given those ordinary epistemic standards…
Author : wisozkjoaquin
Download 1
Reformed Epistemology Insulates Religious Faith from Scientific Scrutiny
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Reformed Epistemology Insulates Religious Faith from Scientific Scrutiny"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Check these samples - they also fit your topic

Faith
The Apostle Paul has written a letter to the Romans concerning an upcoming visit. He has touched on this theme as a central reason for his visit. Various theological sources will be cited throughout the paper as faith is both defined and related to Paul’s impending visit.
7 pages (1750 words) Essay
Epistemology
Yet, when asked about what we know about the mind, either we do not have the slightest idea or our idea of it is too general to mean anything. Perhaps, the most practical thing to say about the mind and its states is they are “in the head,” but the moment we try to be more specific about what we mean by it we find ourselves in a muddle.
7 pages (1750 words) Essay
Epistemology
The variety of goods and services involved necessitates proper arrangement of factors within the retail market to achieve the business aspirations. Retail management calls for departmental organization to bring the customers in to the store/ outlet and fulfilling their buying needs.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Epistemology
GameStop is committed to delivering user-friendly videos games that meet individual needs to all its customers. Knowledge and its significance Knowledge can be acquired through various means because there exist numerous ways to attain on a certain subject or about something (Nonaka and Nishiguchi, 2001).
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Epistemology
J. Ayer, 1975). The conception has been advanced and propounded by a large number of writers in a number of theses taking a variety of forms: (1) definitional (a definition of epistemology itself), (2) definitional again (a definition of knowledge), (3) genetic (a thesis about the conditions under which epistemology and all its problems arise), (4) semantic (a thesis about a necessary condition of a question's making sense), (5) historical (theses about the founder of epistemology and the period of its founding), (6) scopic (a thesis about the scope of epistemology), and (7) existential (a thesis about the existence of general skeptics).
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Faith
It had rewards for every thing that is considered to be good morally and ethically. Basically faith means to believe in ALLAH, HIS messengers, HIS books, the last day and the divine ruling both good and bad. You give some one a glass of water you will be rewarded, you help someone to cross the road GOD will bless you, even Islam says that if you decided to perform any good act (and had not done it practically, but have just thought to do so), it will be noted by angels and you will be rewarded for that on the day of judgment.
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Scientific Models and Religious Myths
It is the comparison between scientific models and religious myths, which is the concern of this discussion. Specifically, for purposes of this paper, the scientific models presented here are naturalism, evolutionary theory, and traditionalism. The ideas in defense of religion, on the other hand, are argument from causation and argument from values.
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Compare Scientific Models and Religious Myths
It is the comparison between scientific models and religious myths, which is the concern of this discussion. Specifically, for purposes of this paper, the scientific models presented here are naturalism, evolutionary
8 pages (2000 words) Essay
Epistemology
Retail management calls for departmental organization to bring the customers in to the store/ outlet and fulfilling their buying needs.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Epistemology
Epistemology is concerned regarding the problems involved in the formation and distribution of knowledge in specific parts of the Inquisition. There are many different types of knowledge; having knowledge regarding a specific person, having knowledge regarding how to do a specific thing and having knowledge about a city or a particular area.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment
Let us find you another Essay on topic Reformed Epistemology Insulates Religious Faith from Scientific Scrutiny for FREE!
Contact us:
+16312120006
Contact Us Now
FREE Mobile Apps:
  • About StudentShare
  • Testimonials
  • FAQ
  • Blog
  • Free Essays
  • New Essays
  • Essays
  • The Newest Essay Topics
  • Index samples by all dates
Join us:
Contact Us