StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

James Argument on the Belief in God in The Will to Believe and Pascal's Wager - Essay Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
James Argument on the Belief in God in The Will to Believe and Pascal's Wager

Therefore, Pascal concludes that any rational being has a duty to believe in God to attain the infinite happiness. However, this argument by Wager raises many critics from philosophers who view the argument as lacking probability in the life of humanity and more so related to belief. Pascal’s argument is viewed as an extraordinary power. The proponents of this argument explain that even though Wager’s argument might be taken as false and a probability taken on this argument, on at the end we might be wrong and the argument might be true after all. Therefore, no matter how small the probability, Pascal’s argument should be accepted as true according to this argument. However, William James is a serious critic of this argument by Pascal and tries to discredit the hypothesis and the conclusion by Pascal regarding believing in God. For James, belief involves a will to choose among possible options and such an option has to have concrete evidence and our faith in most cases is responsible for shaping future outcomes. Rather than taking forced options that might end up being false, James stresses on being indifferent. The assertion by James is therefore more skeptical one that does not offer concrete proofs as compared to Pascal’s. ...
Interestingly James postulates that wherever there is an option where losing the truth away and save ourselves at any rate of believing falsehood by not making up our minds till objective evidence has come, such an option would be worthwhile compared to believing the falsehoods in such circumstances (James, 5). This contradicts Pascal’s argument that it is the nature and obligation of any credible humanity to believe in God, since whether or not God exists would have a greater degree of happiness for such an individual. Consider the postulation below by Pascal. God exists God does not exist Believe in God infinity f1 Do not believe in God f2 f3 Therefore, according to the above table, if God exists and you believe, such an individual has an infinitely happy life to gain. On the other hand if God doe not exist or you do not believe then your utility level in such cases as indicated by f1, f2, f3 is finite (Tabarrok, 123). Therefore, one who believes in God according to Pascal has more to gain in both cases as compared to those who do not believe in God. Taking James postulation, the second case would apply; where if truly God exists the individual would have to lose everything as the chance of gaining the truth is thrown away in fear of believing in falsehoods (James, 5). It would follow that Pascal’s postulation is more concrete and accurate compared to the postulation by James on the subject of believing in God. The critics of James to Pascal’s work can also be applied to criticize his own work. James explains that humans are recorders and not the makers of truth. In addition James explains that facts are facts and independent of our believing or not (James, ...Show more

Summary

Name: Class: Date: James Argument on the Belief in God in the Will to Believe and Pascal's Wager Pascal Wager is among philosophers of theology with most famous arguments relating to belief in God. Wager puts forward a strong argument on theoretical grounds for belief in God…
Author : knolan
James Argument on the Belief in God in The Will to Believe and Pascals Wager essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"James Argument on the Belief in God in The Will to Believe and Pascal's Wager"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

Belief in God but not Religion
There is no doubt that human belief need to be on God and not religion because there are several distinct religions in the world with each religion having its own customs and rituals. Religion can be described as a precise primary set of beliefs and practices that are accepted and respected by number of individuals or sects.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Pascal's Wager
This wager has been referenced by scholars, philosophers and theologians ever since Pascal first introduced this particular logic. As such, this particular essay will work to analyze Pascal’s wager from a rational point of view to determine if it is a sound belief system or whether it should be disregarded entirely.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Argument for God using the Design argument
As a result, several theories have been advanced to explain the origin of the world, our purpose and the existence of God. One of the bases for the argument of the existence of God is the teleological argument that God exists based on the design of the world.
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Essay on belief: does God exist
My family gave me a moral code by which to live by which included the potential outcomes from a judgmental God. This vision of a more wrathful God led me to pursue new explanations because my personal faith would not allow me to see a supreme being in just one light.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
William James, The Will to Believe
In the context of religion, for example, he asserts that faith is a genuine option. More specifically, he states that, The notion of an option, a choice to be made between two alternatives, is qualified very carefully. James is not using the term, option, generally; quite the contrary, he is using this term very deliberately and very specifically.
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Pascal's Wager
Hacking (1975) adds that the wager was the "the first well-understood "the first well-understood contribution to decision theory." This treatise is brought about by Pascal dissatisfaction with the prevailing arguments for the justification of the existence of God.
2 pages (500 words) Essay
William James, The Will to Believe Essay
Because religion is based on faith it cannot be demonstrated as proven to exist in a rational manner. James is exhorting the students to follow their faith in the hope that the students of Brown and Yale students will open their minds to the possibilities of religion more so than the students at Harvard.
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Why do Israelites believe in a Monotheistic God And Why do Egyptians believe in Polytheistic God
2007. Available from internet, http://www.4to40.com/history/index.asp?id=71. accessed 25 April 2008. Ugo Volli: Polytheism and Monotheism. Accepting Diversity: An
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
God exists OR God doesn't exist OR We should believe in God OR We shouldn't believe in God
The existence of God provides the most compelling explanation for the existence of the universe, the order of creation and the presence of creatures, both living and non-living, on the planet. If
2 pages (500 words) Essay
How does Plantinga argue for the claim that belief in God might be properly basic Do you think his argument is good Do you think that the conclusion of his argument is true
The philosophers belonging to the classical and traditional schools of thoughts have explained in detail their arguments about the existence of God and the rationality of individual’s belief in it. These thoughts are accepted as well
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation