StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Concept of Justice in Plato's Republic - Essay Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
Concept of Justice in Plato's Republic

This argument is presented to Socrates in an accusatory fashion, and with Thrasymachus’ replies to what Socrates seeks in clarification in support of his argument, it seems evident that Thrasymachus’ himself did not completely understand the depth of the position he just took. This becomes apparent when Socrates designs his retorts to explore the argument further, dedicating the rest of the Book I to seeking clarification of the argument Thrasymachus’ had just presented. Socrates aims to make it apparent that a concept of justice such as this must develop in a coherent fashion towards one final definition of justice presented by Thrasymachus’, but as the argument continues, it is seen that Thrasymachus’ himself is slightly skewed in his approach and ends up presenting more than one definition of justice, with both consistencies and inconsistencies between the two. Discussion between Thrasymachus, Socrates and Cleitophon Thrasymachus, who originally seemed like an avid listener, enters into the discussion of justice by interrupting Socrates in a seemingly demeaning manner at 336b, positioning himself first as an aggressive philosopher who was staunch in his understanding of the dialogue at hand, ready to move forward and express his displeasure with the same, “But when we paused … he could no longer keep quiet; hunched up like a wild beast, he flung himself at us as if to tear us to pieces.” (336b). Moreover, he exclaims to the recipient, “What if I could show you another answer about justice besides all these and better than they are? What punishment do you think you would deserve to suffer?” (337d). Clearly, Thrasymachus is about to make a sweeping statement regarding the concept of justice. When Thrasymachus delivers his version of what he believes justice encompasses, “nothing other than the advantage of the stronger party” (338c), Socrates approaches the man with a determined outlook to seek clarification. In response to his appeal, Thrasymachus presents clarifying examples, describing at first instance the various systems of governance that permeate societies of modern age, specifically, tyranny, democracy, and aristocracy. In all three of these variants, governments seek to design laws that not only uplift their own desires but also make it unlawful to act against them, passing laws with a view to their own advantage (338e). Justice is then designed to be the responsibility of the government, who would pertinently seek to protect their own wishes before they protect anyone else’s, making it clear that in “every city, the same thing is just, the advantage of the established ruling body” (339a). Thus, Thrasymachus applies that a reasonable man would necessarily conclude that the advantage of the ruling elite becomes justice in the land that he governs. In doing so, he supplies us with the first interpretation of his sweeping ideology of justice, that it is what is to the advantage of the stronger party; the strongest of the land take charge, make their own laws, and in doing so, define what is just and what is not. It follows that a person who acts in compliance with the wishes of his government is definitely just. To the above utterance, Plato, speaking via his teacher Socrates, begins to identify possible loopholes. According to him, there is a distinct lack of adherence in Thrasymachus’ ...Show more

Summary

Name Instructor Subject Date Concept of Justice in Plato’s Republic Introduction The concept of justice is morally inclined by modern standards, but Thrasymachus’ Socrates and the rest of the best of men seem to suggest that this inclination does not suffice…
Author : erdmanmaximilli
Concept of Justice in Platos Republic essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Concept of Justice in Plato's Republic"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

Plato's 'Republic': The Philosophical Tenets of Justice
Critical philosophical study of the issue alongside irrefutable proof leads to the conclusion that justice has an absolute reality as well as its own benevolence and should be pursued regardless of the consequences. Through an objective study of Plato’s “Republic” this philosophical position can be defended adequately.
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Philosophy - Plato's Republic and Aristotle's Nicomachean Ethics
Plato’s criticism of democracy is of the direct and unchecked democracy of Ancient Athens (557a-564a). Plato fears that democracy leads to an excess of freedom, which refers to the carefree state of doing whatever one likes. This kind of conception undermines the authority and purpose of the state, which is to limit the freedom of individuals with respect to what they can and cannot do.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Plato's Republic - Does this mean that Plato's view of human nature had no influence on his conception of just and good politica
Indeed, the understanding of human nature could help towards the understanding of the political and social life of a particular society. It is implied that the responses of individuals towards various political and social events indicates their views on the political and social rules of their era.
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Plato's Republic
Plato emphasizes the need to value and uphold the rule of law. It is also significant to note that Plato tries to explicate the primary belief of political and societal justice and the importance of individual justice in a society. Plato made it clear that he disliked democratic system of government of Greece.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Platos the Republic: Justice
Plato uses two ways to define the essence of justice as serving the interest of different parts of the “soul” and that of the parts of the “state” (Bhandari). It is evident that the soul is subdivided into three unique portions, which include the appetitive, spirited, and the rational.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Platos Republic
The central ideology of Plato's philosophical interpretation was primarily based on his use of dialectics, a mode of arguments concerning the profound reflections of nature of reality as well as using cognitive optimism, a principle believing in the ability of the human mind in order to accomplish truth and to use this truth for fulfilling the objective predominantly based on rational choice to act on human affairs set with virtuous ordering.
20 pages (5000 words) Essay
Plato's The Republic Essay
as well as any and all key issues which are related to this subject of issue. The aim of this paper is to discuss all of this, in order to pose a more intellectual and critical understanding and viewpoint on this issue. This is what will be dissertated in the following.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Plato's republic
With his book Plato also explains how to draw an analogy of the operation that a society is as a whole society and the life of an individual in that very same society. Book IV Plato explains through Socrates the guardians the ruling class as we know them. From that perspective and this angle this essay is going to discuss this theory
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Plato's Republic
among these other noble characteristics, it is no surprise how much importance Plato, Aristotle, Socrates, and others ascribed to justice in the formation of a complete system of morality and an Ideal State. Plato, in fact, identifies justice not simply as something related to
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Plato's REPUBLIC
The public in Athens was doubtful about democracy being an effective form of governance and in this perspective, Socrates, who appeared to be a strong critic of democracy, was defended by many who interpreted his trial as being an
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation