Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you! Try us!

Concept of Justice in Plato's Republic - Essay Example

Only on StudentShare
Author : erdmanmaximilli

Summary

Name Instructor Subject Date Concept of Justice in Plato’s Republic Introduction The concept of justice is morally inclined by modern standards, but Thrasymachus’ Socrates and the rest of the best of men seem to suggest that this inclination does not suffice…

Extract of sample
Concept of Justice in Plato's Republic

This argument is presented to Socrates in an accusatory fashion, and with Thrasymachus’ replies to what Socrates seeks in clarification in support of his argument, it seems evident that Thrasymachus’ himself did not completely understand the depth of the position he just took. This becomes apparent when Socrates designs his retorts to explore the argument further, dedicating the rest of the Book I to seeking clarification of the argument Thrasymachus’ had just presented. Socrates aims to make it apparent that a concept of justice such as this must develop in a coherent fashion towards one final definition of justice presented by Thrasymachus’, but as the argument continues, it is seen that Thrasymachus’ himself is slightly skewed in his approach and ends up presenting more than one definition of justice, with both consistencies and inconsistencies between the two. ...
Download paper

Related Essays

Plato's 'Republic': The Philosophical Tenets of Justice
Critical philosophical study of the issue alongside irrefutable proof leads to the conclusion that justice has an absolute reality as well as its own benevolence and should be pursued regardless of the consequences. Through an objective study of Plato’s “Republic” this philosophical position can be defended adequately. …
6 pages (1506 words)
Plato's Republic Philosophy Essay
In other words, the Republic by Plato is primarily a treatise about the formation of man. It is a political work not in the conventional sense, but in the sense as Socrates makes it understandable. However, the huge educational truth, which is clearly represented in the Republic - is a strong correlation of the image of man and space where the person is placed. It is not only an artistic principle, but it is also a moral law. The main thesis is that a perfect man can be formed only in a perfect state, and vice versa: the creation of the perfect state is the problem of a man forming. This is…
5 pages (1255 words)
Plato’s Republic
Socrates was outspoken in criticizing the new government and after the Democrats took hold of power, Socrates’ relationship with the oligarchic set up made his enemies to find appropriate reasons to make him face trial. They charged him with corrupting the youth of Athens through immoral ways and in spite of his articulately expressed defense, Socrates was held guilty and condemned to death. In his Apology, Plato has recorded the last days of Socates’ life. Socrates continued to remain staunch and true to his belief system and was unwilling to go back on his past statements. He even…
4 pages (1004 words)
Thrasymachus and Justice in Plato's Political Philosophy
Distinguished sophist of ancient Greece Thrasymachus has elucidated the term justice while entering into discussion on the same topic with great philosopher Socrates, which has been elaborated by Socrates’ renowned disciple Plato in his Republic. Book I of the Republic encompasses the debate between Thrasymachus and Socrates, where the former makes two assertions about justice. At first, he declares the notion as mere the ‘advantage of the strong over the weak’; and secondly he views justice as ‘submitting to the prevailing statutes of the state law.’ (Hourani, 111) The powerful…
6 pages (1506 words)
plato's Republic
In his book, “the Republic” Plato states that oligarchy and timocracy are favorable to democracy and that anarchy or totalitarianism is a less preferable system of government. Plato was an enemy of democracy because according to him, he identified deficiencies in the Athenian democracy. Plato in his book, the republic asserted that the Athenian democracy promoted inherent class tension and it did not focus on promoting equality and liberty of all the people (Plato 295). According to Plato, inherent class tensions were evident in the disunity between the Athenian classes that lacked…
3 pages (753 words)
Ideal society in the Republic of Plato
A few more, as it were, ‘interlocutions’ are necessary here. Such as, are their any inherent socio-contextual, epistemological and thematic limitations of logic in the Republic? Why democracy should be regarded as the best form of political system? Is it proper to criticise Plato, as attempted by Karl Popper, for something fundamentally outside the structure of his work? Plato’s Republic is, indeed, a masterly work of philosophy. It is “…a dramatised philosophy of human life”. It does not mean that it is an embodiment of perfection. …
6 pages (1506 words)