StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Libertarian Use of Punishment to Show Free Will - Essay Example

Nobody downloaded yet

Extract of sample
Libertarian Use of Punishment to Show Free Will

Libertarianism is the view that we have free will. Free will is an act based on a reason that an agent takes to choose an action from a range of alternatives (O’Connor, 2011). How choices transpire made at times of differing motives might agree with the increase of quantum indeterminism in individuals’ brains. Following my first premise, libertarians deem that we may hold individuals morally accountable only if they exercise free will, a person can freely choose to take an action, making them responsible, morally. This makes that person free and ethically responsible because they have taken a choice that is undetermined. Regardless of the undetermined choices they put forward, few libertarians will assert to offer an episteme justification that persons did take that kind of choices.  Libertarians decide the degree of harshness that is assigned to a individual whose moral responsibility has been established to the acceptable standards of the society. However, they to agree that assigning those difficult characteristic of moral responsibility to individuals who does not believe in libertarian free will is to take action wrongly. Hence justifying my premise that punishment bestowed by free willed libertarian can only be done to a believer of the same, in order to be deemed right. The second premise argues that that majority of libertarians deem that we should hold individuals morally responsible. Holding an individual morally responsible take account of a range of behaviours; that may be either positive or negative. Examples include: verbal accusation, praise and blame and retributive penalty. Libertarians differ among themselves over deciding how much of that assortment moral responsibility comprise. However, due to the fact that even the smallest of undesirable behaviour harms people, libertarians use the obligation of moral responsibility as a justification to turns otherwise immoral behaviour into punishable action (Double). Some libertarians however have more to their thoughts on punishment. Mark Balaguer (1999) argues that there is enough grounds for believing alternative are undetermined as we do for supposing they are determined. He argues that nobody knows exactly how the human brain works. But his argument fails to give reason to establish that brains make undermined choices gives room to believe we do make choices based our free will. Robert Kane (1996, 1999) takes an alternative view other libertarians stating that Kanian free choosers may only have partial control over their choices. His implies that they are only, to some degree, morally responsible for their deeds. Because Kane’s theory makes indeterministic choices rely upon a indeterminate quantum actions, he concede that Kanian free individuals lack control over what they choose. Kane’s view would not be shared by traditional libertarians precisely because his argument of having less control over actions taken fails to support the responsibility that libertarians wish to assign. Doing this would make it difficult to give emphasize on the importance to libertarians of mitigating the practices of making a person responsible morally for his deeds.  The strongest argument raised against libertarian argument to use punishment to show free will is the proportionality rule. The proportionality rule gives us how much penalty a claimant may exact to a wrong doer, and no more; ...Show more


Name Instructor Task Date Libertarian Use of Punishment to Show Free Will In this paper, I will examine the libertarian argument from punishment used as a justification for the claim that we have free will. This paper will follow two premises: The first premise will be to argue that libertarians deem that we may hold individuals morally accountable only if they exercise free will…
Author : tavarescrooks
Libertarian Use of Punishment to Show Free Will essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Libertarian Use of Punishment to Show Free Will"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Check these samples - they also fit your topic

Why is Corporal Punishment Still Use in Africa What are the Alternatives
In a research conducted in Uganda (Naker 2005) over 1400 children and almost 1100 adults were surveyed about their experiences with violence, punishment and discipline. It was revealed that physical punishment was a most common practice in all over the country.
21 pages (5250 words) Essay
What is the best free digital content we use today
What is the best free digital content we use today? Microsoft PowerPoint has long been famous both among students and mentors for making presentations. Both of them use it for their own respective purposes. Mentors deliver lectures on PowerPoint and students deliver assignments therein.
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Use of Rewards and Punishment as Motivations
Use of rewards and punishment in order to motivate other members of the organization People in powerful positions in organisations must use rewards and punishment in order to motivate other members of the organization Across various organisations it has been long recognised that motivation is critical for members of an organisation to work cooperatively and to align their personal goals with those of the organisation.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Morality of punishment
Crimes can arise from that which is considered a mean character as opposed to other crimes that arise from a violent character. Punishment is very distinct from that of natural punishment; punishment of the self is thought of as natural and not guided or regulated by legislators.
9 pages (2250 words) Essay
Parent's Use of Physical Punishment Increases Violent Behavior
Some psychologists consider physical punishments to be harmful while others consider it to be harmless. Research has shown that severe physical punishments can lead to aggressive and violent behavior among children particularly if they are spanked or hit before the age of one.
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
The Implication of Legalization or Reduction of Punishment Severity for Drug Use and Drug-Related Offenses
Furthermore, some are eager to quantitatively determine this, even though apparently most have aspired greatly for rhetorical goals, and none present more than the most shallow or obvious explanation of the support of their estimate (MacCoun & Reuter, 2001). Even the most
10 pages (2500 words) Essay
Is Libertarian Paternalism a good idea
The concept of Libertarian Paternalism argues on constructively controlling the subconscious aspect of decision making. It argues that people usually end up making decision which is not based on rational and logical facts. Therefore it is the duty of
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Big Brother revolves around a group of individuals live together in a house for a period of 100 days. During that time, the participants are assigned various challenges; which they must fulfill in order to avoid eviction. The concept of the
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Capital Punishment
Supporters of capital punishment are of the view that in the absence of capital punishment, people may engage in more criminal activities. In their opinion, crime rates cannot be controlled without strong
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Is corporal punishment an effective discipline technique for families or does the evidence show it does more harm than good to cihildren discuss
In this paper, I will seek to analyze and give evidences of instances where corporal punishment is effective, and then analyze its long-term effects on a child. Corporal punishment has short-term effect of eliciting immediate
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Hire a pro to write
a paper under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment
Contact Us