Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you! Try us!

Philosophy on Justice - Essay Example

Only on StudentShare
College
Author : jayme90
Essay
Philosophy
Pages 5 (1255 words)

Summary

In book I of Plato's Republic, Thrasymachus challenges Socrates with a very specific definition of Justice. What is this definition, and how does he defend it? What analogies do Socrates and Thrasymachus use to support their respective claims? How is Thrasymachus' position finally defeated?…

Extract of sample
Philosophy on Justice

This phenomenon is reflected in the dialogue between Socrates and Thrasymachus, as the dialogue has been incorporated in book I of Plato’s Republic. The view of Socrates on justice is in opposition with that of Thrasymachus, as revealed through the arguments developed by each of them. The evaluation of these arguments leads to the assumption that Socrates’ thoughts on justice are based on fairness and equality, a fact that ensures justice, in all its aspects. On the other hand, the view of Thrasymachus on justice follows a different direction, being able to result to social conflicts. It is probably for this reason that, at the end, Thrasymachus recognize the value of Socrates’ view on justice and accept his failure in understanding the actual role of individuals within the society, including their role in the promotion of justice. In accordance with Thrasymachus, ‘justice is nothing else but the interest of the most powerful’ (338c Plato’s Republic I). Thrasymachus defends the above definition by developing a series of arguments, as described below. At the first level, Thrasymachus states that the types of polities globally are many. There are countries based on monarchy, others are based on aristocracy and others are based on democracy (338d). ...
Download paper

Related Essays

Philosophy of Justice
Socrates was a mysterious personality, attributed as one of the originator of Western philosophy. He was a firm believer that justice is good, this could be attained through self-knowledge. It is imperative to understand what is good i.e. justice and what is injustice or evil. According to Socrates, natural needs are good. Good is always desired. The desire or the requirement to be satisfied varies with a person's nature called the daimon. It is exclusive to every person. Thus, in this scenario, it is the individual's knowledge that plays a vital role in deciding the good and taking the…
3 pages (753 words)
Philosophy - Social Justice
This is because the definitions vary basing on a variety of factors, like political factors, religion, and the social philosophy. From a postmodernist point of view, one can get a definition that is only a concept that may never be practical anywhere in life. In general, Boylan (p. 91) writes that social justice is more of equal justice, not only in the judicial system, but in all other aspects of the society. From this concept, we can say that social justice demands equal rights and opportunities for everyone regardless of the social status. Therefore, we can sum up by saying that social…
4 pages (1004 words)
Philosophy Essay
It is therefore there could not be any possibility of comparing the level of deprivations between the two culturally and economically pole-apart zones of the globe. The rich nations, according to the author, spend millions of dollars in feeding their pets, while they are unable to realize the bitter fact that by doing so, they are adding their share in respect of depriving the millions of humans of adequate food and proper nutrition. Although, the animals should not be deprived of the food, yet humans must be considered at first stance in order to make the world healthy, productive and…
4 pages (1004 words)
Thrasymachus and Justice in Plato's Political Philosophy
Distinguished sophist of ancient Greece Thrasymachus has elucidated the term justice while entering into discussion on the same topic with great philosopher Socrates, which has been elaborated by Socrates’ renowned disciple Plato in his Republic. Book I of the Republic encompasses the debate between Thrasymachus and Socrates, where the former makes two assertions about justice. At first, he declares the notion as mere the ‘advantage of the strong over the weak’; and secondly he views justice as ‘submitting to the prevailing statutes of the state law.’ (Hourani, 111) The powerful…
6 pages (1506 words)
The power of non violence
Men are unique beings capable of moral reasoning. Due to this, people should strive to ensure that they use this capability to come up with solutions for problems which might arise. Violence is an extreme form of problem solving. Violence has led to destruction in the world with issues which could be solved in a respectable manner being solved by violent means. People should strive to ensure that violence is not used in any situation. Many people see violence as important in problem solving This is due to the notion that forcing people into compliance is the best and fastest method of getting…
3 pages (753 words)
Philosophy and Social Justice
Money is such an important thing nowadays no matter what bad things people would say against it. Nevertheless, what makes money more difficult is the selfishness among people. The gap between the rich and the poor is growing wider and wider because of such selfishness, I believe. Therefore, it is not only a society with people who are financially stable that I envision but one with people who share their wealth with each other. The just society is also a society where domestic violence is either nonexistent or not an issue at all. Moreover, it is a society where the employment rate is at a…
3 pages (753 words)
Justice in Greek Philosophy
Plato, one of the Greek's ancient philosophers, ideally believed that sense-gained knowledge remains impure and confused, and that only the soul that contemplates and turns away from thinking carnally can receive true knowledge. He also believed that only the soul can know real essences of things, acquire knowledge of forms since the world as seen by the eye is nothing short of an imperfect copy (Bakalis, 2005).…
6 pages (1506 words)