Consent: A Philosophical Dilemma - Essay Example

Only on StudentShare

Extract of sample
Consent: A Philosophical Dilemma

In this article, I provide reasons to support O’Neill’s argument regarding the validity of consent as the fundamental principle in dealing with others. First, I evaluate the moral dimensions of treating others as they would like. Secondly, I address the validity of consent in justifying the way others are treated, thirdly I address the issue of hypothetical consent and moral actions, fourth, I address the issues of Kantian alternative and the Formula of the end principle, and finally how these ideas are applicable in job and relationship issues The moral ideals of treating others as persons is not primarily a matter of treating people as they want or would want to be treated. Though O’Neill (253) argues that involved employers treat employees as persons, first, there would be a need for cognitive maturity in making decisions regarding the best treatment approach, regardless of the employee’s views. For example, an employee may not want to be involved in a certain project due to lack of knowledge or information. The cognitive ability of the employer to know the benefits of such program to employees may overrule what the employee actually wants in implementing it. ...
Download paper

Summary

Name: Course: Date: Consent: A Philosophical Dilemma The debate regarding morality and rightness of actions based on individual’s consent may be considered as a dilemma in ethical practices. In his philosophical arguments, Kant noted that the basic moral principle to treat people is by respecting and recognizing the right to decent or consent to any possibilities…
Author : lindjoanie

Related Essays

Philosophical Prepositions by Fichte
1963). Clearly, his prepositions are the basis of life. They help human beings to make decisions even the scientists who only believe in facts that can be proved. One of the prepositions is the ego as an aspect of identity. It indicates the originality of the human nature. Fichte argues that the ego is what comes first in decision-making. It controls the choices made by human beings in their daily life. This preposition is significant in that it brings out the aspect of individuality. Human beings need to be themselves. They need to make decisions in all categories of life rather than...
4 pages (1004 words) Essay
John Locke and the Tacit Consent Theory.
John Locke’s Theory of Tacit Consent is actually necessary but should not be the only basis of the legitimacy of a government. According to John Locke, the so-called Tacit Consent Theory refers to the notion that “one can only become a full member of society by an act of express consent” (Tuckness), which may translate as “simply by walking along the highways of a country a person gives tact consent to the government and agree to obey it while living in its territory” (Tuckness). This is, in fact, a rather self-explanatory definition of tacit consent. The point of Locke then is that...
8 pages (2008 words) Essay
Medical Ethics and Informed Consent
Researchers argued that the experimentation was to help develop an immunization for hepatitis B. The ethical challenges at hand are that yes, it is evident that research needed to be done on hepatitis at that time. However, children with mental retardation already have problems enough in their lives. This is like saying that their life has no value. In some cases, the parents did not consent. Depending on the level of mental retardation, a child can thrive but to deliberately expose them to hepatitis could greatly diminish their already lowered quality of life and the children have no say in...
3 pages (753 words) Assignment
Philosophical Thoughts and Issues
Development of a person’s philosophy is a remarkably rewarding experience in anyone’s life. Personal philosophy helps people to understand who they really are. My personal philosophy guides me to make the right choices in life. It also encourages me to make sound judgments about different scenarios. My philosophy is that of metaphysics and it encompasses open-mindedness as well as flexibility. Metaphysics is a belief that there is existence of things beyond what we see. There are four schools of thought in metaphysics; realism, pragmatism, idealism and existentialism (Hay 15). I am an...
6 pages (1506 words) Essay
Philosophical Conceptions of Justice.
However, justice, in a universal definition, entails the knowledge of doing right from wrong and making sure people live in the right way together. It is this ‘right’ way of living that brings controversies in describing social justice among nations. This paper discusses a variety of philosophical conceptions of justice with regard to famous philosophers in their definitions of social justice (Ackerman, 1980). John Locke and Thomas Jefferson John Locke lived in the mid seventeenth century as an English Enlightenment philosopher. He argued that our ancestors once lived in a state of nature...
5 pages (1255 words) Essay
Philosophical Ethics Final Project
However, the current society has witnessed high levels of abortion because moral standards have gone down. Additionally, laws that permit abortion have been enacted in several countries especially when the mother’s life is threatened. Abortion in ancient history In the ancient era, abortion practices were tolerable in Greece and Rome. Safeguarding of the unborn life was a matter of consideration only if the father was interested in the child. Children conceived outside wedlock, or bore to prostitutes or with other men other than their husbands were killed pre and post birth. Several western...
5 pages (1255 words) Research Paper
philosophical issus
s is mainly because one belongs in, a family may have high standards of behavior code where the members are trained to act and behave in a certain manner which may be very different from others. Additionally, community based behavioral system where they have established rules and regulation on behavior, for example, in some African communities it is wrong foe a young person to salute the elders with their hands instead the young person beds and the elder touched the forehead of the young person as a sign of respect (James and Stuart 100-187)....
1 pages (251 words) Essay
Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you! Try us!