StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Philosophy of Law - Essay Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
Philosophy of Law

In this context, principles can be interpreted differently, under the influence of the personal perceptions of the individual involved, while no such option is available in the case of rules (Raitio 294). The differentiation between rules and principles is made clear when referring to their use by judges. Indeed, in such case, as Dworkin states, rules apply ‘in all or nothing fashion’ (Culver 144), meaning that a rule can either be applied in a specific case or not, there is no intermediate status (Culver 144). On the contrary, principles, even if judges use them, do not oblige the judge involved to take a specific decision. For this reason, Dworkin notes that principles only ‘contribute in judges’ decision’ (Culver 144); principles cannot define the content of a court decision just to influence the reasoning of the judge in regard to the case involved (Culver 144); also, the judge decides whether he will use a principle, and at what level, when developing a decision. Peczenik (2009) refers to another differentiation of rules and principles, as described by Dworkin. Rules and principles are based on different criteria of validity. ...
This means that principles cannot introduce ideas or set obligations, which are differentiated to the beliefs of individuals, at an average level, in regard to law and ethics. Also, principles cannot introduce ideas, which are in opposition with the statutes or the case law, as developed in the country involved (Peczenik 246). In legal rules, the existence of the above conditions is not examined. It is sufficient for a legal rule to have been verified by a competent institution, as explained above, in order to be considered as valid. The above terms of differentiation between rules and principles have been introduced by Dworkin and are valuable for understanding the conditions under which rules and principles are used in practice. The potential use of the view of Dworkin on rules and principles for explaining the decision of the court in the case Riggs v Palmer is examined in the study of Siltala (2000). According to the above researcher, the case Riggs v Palmer sets a critical dilemma: when, in the context of a case, a conflict is developed between a rule and a principle, which should be the decision of judge? He should uphold the rule or use the principle for developing a decision in regard to the specific case? In such cases, Dworkin ‘used to redefine the normative conflict’ (Siltala 46); in this way, ‘the weight of the two principles’ (Siltala 46) should be taken into consideration for deciding which of these principles should be preferred. The differences between legal rules and principles, as Dworkin has highlighted these differences, are clear in the case of Riggs v Palmer (1889). More specifically: in the above case, the following dilemma appears: ...Show more


Philosophy of Law 1.) Dworkin used the example of Riggs v. Palmer to demonstrate the differences between rules and principles. Discuss these differences and how they were on display in Riggs v. Palmer. Dworkin has tried to identify the criteria on which laws and court decisions are based…
Author : predovicgeorge
Philosophy of Law Essay essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Philosophy of Law Essay"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

Philosophy Essay
He is of the view that the lower or poor stratum of the advanced nations, including pensioners and workers, observes the problem of limited income, which cannot be compared with the thick magnitude of poverty prevailing in the third world, which deprives the overwhelming proportion of the entire population of even the very basic necessities of life, including clean drinking water, sufficient food, proper education and sports facilities and much more; consequently, millions of the children born in the third world, die of starvation and absence of medical facilities as well before reaching their fifth birthday.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Opinion essay on In Why Liberals Should Hate 'Hate Crime Legislation', Law and Philosophy, vol. 20 (2001), pp. 215-232
While trying to understand Hurd’s arguments that increased penalties for hate crimes are unjustifiable in liberal societies, there is a need to assess the plausibility of three different views regarding high penalties for hate crimes. Increased penalties for hate crimes are, in fact, justifiable.
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Philosophy of Life Essay
My own philosophical approach is that everyone is born with the ability to succeed in some field or the other, it is up to him or her to look for it, find it, and then work hard at achieving the best in that area. Through dedication and hard work, each person can find fulfillment in life, because he or she will be working in the field of choice, which provides best opportunities of enjoyment and good performance.
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Political Philosophy Essay
In this way, many of us tend to become ignorant of the fact that the modern Western societies rest on the rich heritage of philosophers and thinkers who in the course of the several last centuries have laid the ground for modern democratic institutions and practices.
22 pages (5500 words) Essay
Philosophy of Law
The analysis after that establishment will use mainly contract, trust, wills, and probate law as examples of the necessity and practical value for a philosophy of law. "The term philosophy derives from a combination of the Greek words philos meaning love and sophia meaning wisdom.
13 pages (3250 words) Essay
Philosophy short essay
This ensures regulation of people’s selfish interests towards personal ambitions in the society and therefore fosters law and order. Assumed equality among all members of the society and
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Philosophy Essay
There are various challenges and complexities, which are associated with the moral and ethical dimensions of warfare, and they can be traced back to ancient times. Similarly, the complexities that are associated
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Philosophy Essay
For instance, Hobbes and Bacon contributed a lot in the field of philosophy. Using their knowledge, they managed to pull off a momentous “reconstruction of all knowledge,” and that is why up to this moment, people can comfortably enjoy the presence of
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation