StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

God's Omniscience and Human Free Will - Contradiction - Essay Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
God's Omniscience and Human Free Will - Contradiction

Most of the solutions or arguments are aimed at working around the problem rather than resolving it. I believe that there is no way to solve this conflict without denying either God’s omniscience or the existence of free will. In this essay I argue and attempt to prove that God’s omniscience and human free will are not compatible with each other. Omniscience in the simplest form is defined as the knowledge of everything, infinite or complete knowledge. That is, an omniscient God knows and has knowledge of everything, including what is going to happen in the future1. Human free will on the other hand is defined as the ability, power or force of a person to choose what or what not to do. In a more religious sense it is the ability or power to choose or turn away from good or evil2. Hence, definition of omniscient God implies an all knowing God meaning that God knows what is going to happen in the future. If God already knows what we are going to do in the future, it means that our actions are already predetermined and we have no control over the actions that we are going to take in the future. ...
God is omniscient or humans have free will, both cannot be possible. Now let’s consider some of the solutions offered to solve the above conflict and see if it actually attempts to prove the compatibility of the two ideas or not. One of the major arguments made by those supporting omniscient God and human free will is that God’s foreknowledge in no way restricts human free will. That is, foreknowledge does not imply causality. Following analogy is used to support the claim: Sun rises tomorrow and knowing this does not cause the sun to rise. Knowing ahead of time does not restrict or cause an event to occur. Similarly, God’s foreknowledge of what we are going to do does not affect our free will to choose what we are going to do. It just means that God happens to know ahead of time what we are going to choose freely. God does not affect our freedom to choose but he simply knows ahead of time that what we are going to choose3. For this argument to work the concept of time as we know it must be discarded. God is not restricted by the concept of time as we do. To God past, present and future exists at once, i.e, God exists outside of time. The above argument does not make logical sense and can be termed invalid. Let’s assume that humans have free will and are free to choose what they want to do. If an option A is chosen then by the earlier argument God would have known that option A would be chosen ahead of time. If instead of option A, due to free will, option B is chosen then the argument would be that this is what would have been known4. So either way the conclusion that can be drawn is that the future is determined. Irrespective of causing the event to occur or not, the future remains determined in the analogy used. Knowing that the sun ...Show more

Summary

(Professor) (Subject) God’s Omniscience and Human Free Will - Contradiction One of the most intriguing and most debated contradictions in philosophy is the contradiction of the presence of an omniscient God and human free will. That is, God’s foreknowledge of what is going to happen and our free will to choose whatever we want to…
Author : cheyenne26
Gods Omniscience and Human Free Will - Contradiction essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"God's Omniscience and Human Free Will - Contradiction"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

Questions on Philosophy
Prolegomena contains the summary of the Critique of Pure Reason’s conclusions through arguments that were not used in the latter. He wanted to show an approach to metaphysics in a scientific way without any given standards (SparkNotes Editors). 2. Who does Kant think he is writing this for?
12 pages (3000 words) Essay
Law of Non Contradiction
There are varied ways to state the law of non contradiction. A thing cannot be X and not X at one and the same time and in the same sense. The other way to state this practically irrefutable law is that a specific thing cannot exist and at the same time not exist, at the same time and in the same sense.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
God's grandeur
Hence, it would seem natural in that regard to come up with such composition where the narrator appears awestruck with the ‘grandness’ of God that Hopkins necessitates to write “God’s Grandeur” in the structure of an Italian sonnet in which he incorporates a unique style of ‘sprung rhythm’ with which he has been widely identified.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
God's excistance
John Stuart Mill is an English philosopher who did not agree with the traditional religious view that God was an all-powerful and benevolent being that was entirely omniscient. Though he was a theist, Mill had his belief in God’s existence. He argued that the nature of the world we live in was a point of contention on the traditional religious belief on the nature of God1.
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Human Evil is the Inevitable Result of Human Disobedience, Not of God's Malice or Neglect
It does seem that the following can be said, truly, about action: Actions-cutting, burning, weaving-have an independent nature of their own. If we wish to succeed, they cannot be performed in just any way the whims and desires of particular actors may dictate.
13 pages (3250 words) Essay
Complexity and Contradiction in Architecture
This text has the equal significance for Post-Modernism as Le Corbusier's Vers une Architecture, published in 1923, did for Modernism. It is, in other words, one of the pivots of modern architectural history. We know that the three basic laws of logic: (1) necessary polysemy of terms (ambiguity as minimum), (2) necessary contradiction, and (3) instead of "either-or" - "both-and".
2 pages (500 words) Essay
How can omniscience and free will be recociled
God is defined as being omniscient. This is based on studies by theologians that God knows everything in this world. He is the one who created it and therefore knows how it functions. He knows what happened in the past and in the present and thus has the ability to shape the outcomes of the future in respect to human beings' lives.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
God's grandeur
Hence, it would seem natural in that regard to come up with such composition where the narrator appears awestruck with the ‘grandness’ of God that Hopkins necessitates to write “God’s Grandeur” in the structure of an
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
God's excistance
argued that the nature of the world we live in was a point of contention on the traditional religious belief on the nature of God1. The world as we know is full of evils which are rampant and this could not have come from the God
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
God's Existence
For instance, it is believed that there is air around us even though we cannot actually see it. We only know there is air because we see the leaves on the trees
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation