Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you! Try us!

On Consciousness: Understanding John Searle's Basic Teachings - Essay Example

Only on StudentShare
Author : rjones

Summary

On Consciousness: Understanding John Searle’s Basic Teachings Name Year Level – Section Subject Professor May 8, 2012 On Consciousness by John Searle 1. In the Electronic Reserve Reading “Consciousness,” John Searle poses some basic questions regarding the subjectivity of consciousness and whether this is strictly a biological process…

Extract of sample
On Consciousness: Understanding John Searle's Basic Teachings

However, Searle points out that consciousness differs from other biological phenomena since it has a subjective or first-person ontology. With this, Searle asserts that a conscious state is not a separate entity from a physical state, but rather a state where the brain is in. Through this reasoning Searle is able to deny the concepts of duality (separation of soul from the body) and materialism (no material but only spiritual). Jean Searle’s concept of biological naturalism is unique in a sense that it marries physicality and spirituality in defining the nature of consciousness. This is tightly linked with his definition of the human brain, that which sustains human subjectivity. For this matter, I strongly believe that Jean Searle’s notion is conceptually problematic in a number of ways. Firstly, Searle is misled by the concepts of human brain and human intellect. While it is true that psychological activities are and should be within the boundaries of the physical body, this does not directly mean that all activities are contained within a specific section of the human brain. This is the reason why it will be difficult and almost impossible to embark on an experiment that specifically tackles consciousness because this is spiritual in nature. ...
Download paper

Related Essays

Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit
The book “Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit” analyses history and evolution of human consciousness not in a systematic chronological order but through exploring selected phases and moments from it. Drawing from Budhha, Hegel has attempted to delineate the step by step evolution of human mind as a growth from a lower state to a higher one. In the preface, it is stated that “the self-conscious spirit”, in other words, human self-awareness that is pregnant with the awareness about the world, has never been static and that it has evolved a path in which it shed its substantial life behind…
22 pages (5522 words)
Is consciousness a strongly emergent property?
The emergentist theories on consciousness are based upon the idea that the whole of consciousness is far greater than that of the parts from which it is composed. The reductionist theories suggest that there cannot be a system in which the parts do not exist and therefore cannot be reduced from that system. In discussing the idea of the consciousness, the idea of an emergent system from which something more is created that is beyond that of the definable parts suggests that the idea of consciousness is an emergent system. The concept of consciousness is a difficult place to locate in…
5 pages (1255 words)
Gottfried Leibniz - Consciousness and Unconsciousness
Instead, they make difference between unconsciousness and dreamless sleeps, where the latter is aptly declared as the dark episodes of mind, which rarely leave any trace behind them (Hill, 1). The present paper looks for discussing the same with special reference to the contributions made by French philosopher Rene Descartes and eminent eighteenth century German thinker Gottfried Leibniz while elaborating the same. Leibniz is of the opinion that there are infinite minds existing in the form of folds, to which he frequently calls as pleats. He also views matter as the product of mind, and thus…
10 pages (2510 words)
Hegel's "Phenomenology of Spirit" - Unhappy Consciousness
Finally, I will evaluate what Hegel used in order to give out a clear description of his plot since he associated this human stage with the early Christian era where people used to turn away from the upheavals of the world’s common life and concentrated on ascetic and monastic lives coupled with prayers. According to Hegel, people heading an ascetic life nurtured unhappy consciousness until they attained the will of truth. To begin with, unhappy consciousness is an instance of self-consciousness because, it arises out of human beings when it is fighting or struggling to attain recognition…
5 pages (1255 words)
Mind and Consciousness Questions
John Searle defines consciousness to consist of inner, qualitative, subjective states and processes of sentience or awareness. The subjectivity of consciousness is one of the issues that John Searle seeks to clarify. He argues out that consciousness is subject to some human or animal. All conscious states according to him have first person ontology and not third person ontology therefore they can only exist when experienced by some human or animal agent and it is therefore subject to the existence of a human or animal. I.e. it is dependent on the existence of an agent (human or animal)…
5 pages (1255 words)
Searle's Theory
This action occurs in a perfect manner such that the people outside the room begin to believe that actually the person understands Chinese. The same experiment is performed by a computer that applies syntax program to manipulate Chinese Language despite the fact that the computer may not comprehend the language. The Theory in regard to Syntax Manipulation To begin with, Searle does not show anywhere in his theory that Syntax manipulation does not involve any form of thinking nor does he suggest anywhere that Syntax manipulation entails thinking. However, a clear conclusion that can be derived…
3 pages (753 words)
Sartre's view on Consciousness
Articles about him ranged from speculations about the trauma which led to his philosophies in later life to what some refer to as his "God problem." His importance lies, however, in his defense of his stand on the absolute right of humans to freedom and responsibility. (O'Donohoe, 2005)…
8 pages (2008 words)