StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Rousseau, Marx, and the Critique of Classical Liberalism - Essay Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
Rousseau, Marx, and the Critique of Classical Liberalism

This name reflects the fact that it comes from the integrity of the people (nation, class), the presence of single will before the act of its public expression, and identity of the will and actions of the authorities. Jean-Jacques Rousseau and Karl Marx are the most prominent representatives of this theory of democracy. Rousseau’s Political Philosophy Idealizing the natural state, a kind of “golden age,” Rousseau believed that the civil state must guarantee the recovery of natural equality of man in the form established by the contract freedoms. Rousseau is considered the father of the classical theory of democracy, since he introduced the idea of popular sovereignty. By creating a state, people do not put themselves under the authority of the sovereign, but become the bearers of the supreme power. Considering the sovereignty of the people as indivisible, he opposed the division of sovereignty between any of the bodies. The legislature cannot be transferred to parliament, and must be carried out directly by the people. All laws are created by the common will of the people. Rousseau’s criticism of liberalism manifested itself most profoundly in the interpretation of the equality problem. Rousseau distinguishes between legal equality—or formal equality—and de facto equality. ...
And it would be unfair, according to ideologues of liberalism, if a fool and a wise man were equal. Rousseau, for all his “naturalism”, argues differently. By nature, he says, all people are equal. This does not mean that the strong and the weak are equal in strength. In physical strength they are not equal. But they are equal in the right to live. And if this equality is recognized, the strong will help the weak to survive. And then the weak will feel equally strong. But the strong can hurt the weak. And he can take advantage of the weakness of another person in order to subjugate him, to make him work in order to get rich, etc. Similarly, a stupid person can be treated in different ways: one can sympathize with his stupidity, but one can take advantage of his stupidity to deceive him for one’s own selfish purposes. According to Rousseau, natural inequality is compounded by the inequality in the social conditions of life. And the actual inequality of men is manifested primarily in the inequality of social conditions. That is why humanism in modern society should create equal conditions for healthy people and the most hopeless people with disabilities. Though it could be possible, with reference to their “inferiority”, simply to reject physically defective people, or enclose them in special reservations. Modern society has become so rich that it can afford to be humane. At the time of Rousseau, it was not so rich. Rousseau proclaimed the need for the actual equality of all people in the society, which was still very far from the economic state when equality could be achieved. Rousseau can be accused of utopianism. But without such utopians ...Show more

Summary

Rousseau, Marx, and the Critique of Classical Liberalism Introduction Many thinkers tried to overcome the shortcomings of the liberal state and to implement a genuine democracy, in other words, the concept of collectivist democracy. This type of democracy in theory was designed in sufficient detail…
Author : xbecker
Rousseau, Marx, and the Critique of Classical Liberalism essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Rousseau, Marx, and the Critique of Classical Liberalism"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

Rousseau, Marx and the Critique of Classical Liberalism
They also emphasize on the rule of law, private ownership of property and freedom of religion (Epstein, 2). The role of government as envisaged by classical liberalists is to protect the rights of the individuals. However, this is only applicable in theory as the rule only applies to the bourgeoisie class at the expense of the proletariat (Fremont-Barnes, 225).
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Comparative Evaluation of Classical Realism and Classical Liberalism
Classical liberalism is another concept of the political thought that involves focusing on the freedom that an individual needs to receive more importantly than the powers of the concerned state to which the individual belongs to. The current study focuses on a comparative learning on the concepts of classical realism and classical liberalism as well as has an understanding on the influences that these concepts have on the world and its politics internationally.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Nietzsches Critique of Liberalism
Liberalism is a political ideology that recognizes the rights of people, personal property and a free for all economy (Owen,1995). In addition to this, it also recognizes governments that protect the liberty of each citizen and a constitution which also protects the autonomy of its people from the powers of the state.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Liberal Ideology and Classical Liberalism

The author first defines the terms of liberalism associated with this essay. Liberalism as a whole can be defined, as “ believing in the inherent and essential goodness of humans, a political philosophy based on affirmation, protection and right to exercise with freedom; the political ,economic and social views in a society by an individual”.

4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Rousseau And Marx Can Be Seen As Critics Of The Disenchantment Of The World. How Would They Propose To Re-Enchant The World
The new society replaced the long-established social order in Europe, the ancient regime, and, the conflict between ancients and moderns being a long tradition was called "modern." The nature of contemporary society and the conditions of shift to modernity have been at the core of concerns that preoccupied sociology since its earliest days.
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Rousseau and Marx can be seen as critics of the disenchantment of the world. How would they propose to re-enchant the world What would Kant say about this Arca
social reality, heralded by the French Revolution and accompanied by the Industrial one, which both encouraged and made possible the reassessment of society as such. The new society replaced the long-established social order in Europe, the ancient regime, and, the conflict
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Classical Liberalism
To this end, its proponents recommended the establishment of an area where there would be no action by the state. This private sphere was proximate to the systems of free markets and private property, and was the designated place for exercising individual freedom. Such
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Classical Social Theory - Karl Marx

According to the paper, Marx’s understandings into actors and organizations must be understood in the setting of his assessments on human nature, which is the source for his critical study of the inconsistencies of capitalism. In his opinion, an illogicality exists concerning our human nature and efforts in the capitalist organization.

3 pages (750 words) Essay
Analyse and assess Rousseau, Marx OR Nietzsches critique of Hobbes and/or Locke
Moreover, access to nutritious food, clean water, decent clothing and safety shelters remain a core projects in many nations. Thomas Hobbes believed that, in the society, no one is supposed
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Classical Realism, Neo Liberalism and Constructivism
The theory of international relations entails a course of varied lines of thought explaining the context and processes in which international systems work. The course of each of the theories is evidently backed with evidence accordingly. In this evaluation, the desertion evaluates the theories of classical realism, neoliberalism and constructivism.
8 pages (2000 words) Essay
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation