A Critique on What Determines Humanity and Right to Life

A Critique on What Determines Humanity and Right to Life Essay example
Undergraduate
Essay
Philosophy
Pages 3 (753 words)
Download 0
The author of this article supports abortion and bases the argument on the characterization of a person as human or not on the moral sense.I disagree with the author’s perspective.The author does not acknowledge the role of genetic humanity …

Introduction

To start with, the author does not acknowledge the role of genetic humanity in determining moral humanity. Trying to eliminate the genetic component in determining moral humanity appear illogical and ridiculous to me. The genetic component and the moral aspect of a human are inseparable, a person only retain the traits distinguishing them as morally human only if the genetic composition is normal or not distorted. Altering the genetic component of a human being such as the nucleic acids can utterly deny personhood traits such as rationality, reasoning, consciousness, independence, and communicative ability hence humanity in the moral sense. Trying to detach the two facets makes the definition of moral humanity invalid. What is a human without the genes or even nucleotides? According to the author, an infant is accorded full human just because it can be adopted, this argument is void since the possibility of adoption does not make the infants morally human than an eight month old fetus. The infant should not be considered more human just because it does not fully limit the rights of the mother. This paper is a critique of the article on the moral and legal status of abortion and seeks to establish the invalidity of the traits that determine if any entity is human or not. ...
Download paper
Not exactly what you need?

Related papers

The Growth of Technology and Humanity
For instance, when placed in juxtaposition with Ong’s consideration of writing as technology (p. 21), it could be considered in a sense that indeed, technology exceeds our humanity. Printed materials portray differing ideas of educated people which would be much appreciated have they been healthy but the sad thing is, papers also serve as battle fields. Words are exchanged in papers that…
In What Way, According to Rousseau, is Humanity Perverse?
This essay has examined Jean-Jacques Rousseau’s conception of human perversity. It has further considered the extent that Rousseau’s perspective on human perversity is inconsistent with Kant’s celebration of the Enlightenment. In these contexts of understanding, it’s argued that the main inconsistency between the perspectives is in terms of micro and macro-scales of thought. On an…
Has Humanity Progressed?
Leviathan by Thomas Hobbes Leviathan is a sea monster which has been referred to as the gatekeeper of hell and has been mentioned in the Bible. Hobbes introduced his Leviathan philosophy and this was one of the most important philosophies using the principle of social contract. In his theory, Hobbes discussed that the best way to reach social unity is by the establishment of a social contract…
The Morality, Humanity, and Legality
Pain management is, simply, no longer working and, as hard as it is to admit, she is clearly slowly dying. You stop and ask yourself, “ Would she want her suffering to end? You ask yourself, “Would it be wrong to want her suffering to end?” The answer to these questions are comntroversial ones. If Susie were a pet then we would not question the honorable decision of ending her pain and…
Humanity 5 short essay questions
Certainly among the Aeneid and Homer's poems there are similarities among many: but there are significant differences. Some are of the general differences that distinguish the popular epic and educated: • At present many features of Homer oral, oral traits are popular, absent from the epic educated or gifted in it otherwise. • Typical elements (ornamental epithets patterns or scenes) when they…
Oh the Humanity
For example, in his book The End of Science, John Horgan gloomily predicts “an impending dissolution of science, that the great era of scientific discovery is over or very nearly so. the great discoveries and revelations that have made up the history of science as now yielding to incremental, diminishing returns.” (Horgan, as quoted in Bauer, 1997) While this kind of doomsday pessimism might…
Kant's Theory
In order to act rationally, one must be guided by a supreme law of morality which determines right or wrong in our moral duties. Kant referred to the rule as the Categorical Imperative, which means a command with no other option or alternative. Morality is based on this rule since it is a command that applies to every human being. He says that people should be treated as an end, and not as a…