Should Trees Have Standing? - Essay Example

Only on StudentShare

Extract of sample
Should Trees Have Standing?

Taking trees for that matter, as they are living creatures with biological properties, the debate now arises whether or not they have legal or moral rights. In my view, trees do have a legal as well as a moral standing, and their due rights should be protected, however, if humans cut trees for sustenance and not for pleasure, such an act shouldn`t be challenged in any case, as giving the rights is one thing but sacrificing one`s own rights for the sake of nature is another. The presumption can be backed by the works of Stone and Schmitz, both being highly reputable professors of philosophy. Stone here regards that trees, like corporations, should be assigned their due rights. Though trees can`t speak for themselves, so can`t the corporations, thus by virtue of law, trees should be protected from abusive behavior. Similarly, Schmitz talks about social egalitarianism in this regard and argues that it is irrational to presume that all species have equal moral standing as that is to be judged by the self respect principal, i.e. though killing trees without a reason is highly immoral but killing trees for self-survival is completely understandable and doesn’t challenge the ethics and morality for that matter. ...Show more


Should Trees Have Standing? Gone are the days when there is any kind of debate on the issue whether or not all humans are equal or not. Yet so, it is quite shocking to believe that humans were once categorized on the basis of their race and color to decide whether or not they have a moral and a legal standing…
Author : zschmitt
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write a custom essay on your topic
"Should Trees Have Standing?"
with a personal 20% discount.
Find out more

Related Essays

From the Chipko movement case, which was a case involving the practice of North Indian villagers, especially the women, who pushed the government into revising logging policies. The locality of the movement was the vast central plain lands – to the Himalayan peaks – stretching into the Nepal and Tibet regions.
8 pages (2000 words) Essay
final environmental ethics
The scientific study of these relationships is commonly known as ecology. Environmental ethics entails the study of the ethical relationships between human beings and their surroundings, particularly in the regard of the respect that should be offered to the natural world.
15 pages (3750 words) Research Paper
Is political art possible? In your response, concentrate on three works with political claims and objectives.
Even when they seem to be simply presenting an image of a given time period, using as their subject some form of 'snapshot' image for example, the artist captures some element of the culture, politics and ideas that were dominant during the time period in which the artist lived and worked.
12 pages (3000 words) Essay
Moral Standing of Abortion
The heated debate on abortion is a result of this dilemma that morality is defined in different ways by different people. However, both sides of the spectrum advance extreme views to justify their arguments, thus ignoring the warrant i.e. the standing of the issue in the larger context.
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Kant's Political Writings
The highest authority has to be just in all manners, but originate from man himself. This is the sixth proposition according to Kant. He further explains that as people, we have a tendency to follow a leader in our pursuit for stability and normalcy in society.
7 pages (1750 words) Essay
what are the legal and the social standing of women in the early 1800s?
Status of Woman During 1800s Throughout the history of the world, women have been regarded as the weaker sex as compared to men, and they have suffered lower amount of rights and economic opportunities (WIC, 2012). During the 1800s women had to fiercely fight for their rights; to gain their rights they protested through the means of gathering and also published written work for their rights.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Aestheticism and Modernism
The modernist period lies from 1900-1950; a time of great progress in art, architecture, music and literature. Modernism, the genre that was associated with this period, featured radical aesthetics, technical experimentation, self-conscious reflexiveness and scepticism of the real world.
13 pages (3250 words) Book Report/Review
Descartes third meditation
Descartes takes into account the probability that he, being a thinking entity with a notion of God ‘in the capacity of’ absolutely faultless being, is caused by a thing different from himself. As Descartes states (Bonnen & Flage 1999, 73): In respect of this
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Epistemology: What is knowledge? How can it be distinguished from mere belief or opinion?
There is a correlation between knowledge and belief. According to Walker (2010), Thomas interlinks human behavior to scientific discoveries and knowledge of existence of God, the
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Find out how much would it cost
to get a custom paper written by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email