StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Philosophical Thoughts on the Nature of Dogs - Essay Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
Philosophical Thoughts on the Nature of Dogs

The fundamental question of an issue like this rests on the fact that it is impossible to communicate with these animals – you cannot ask a dog what it thinks or how it would like to be treated, and so we form (often incorrect and anthropomorphic) assumptions of their wants and desires, as exemplified by widespread and ridiculous practices such as leaving a television on for a bet for “company” while its owners are away, as if a flashing screen and random noises would provide comfort to an animal that primarily identifies its comrades by smell and shape. Our lack of ability to communicate directly with animals has led to a vicious debate about the ownership of pets, whether this constitutes animal cruelty, and especially whether treating animals differently than humans (such as allowing for their ownership and control) is a kind of discrimination that is analogous to sexism and racism – acceptable now because of ignorance and social mores, but morally reprehensible when examined critically or through a lens of time. There are many arguments both for and against the ownership of pets being considered a form of discrimination, but I believe that a thorough understanding of the issues involved, along with a reference to The Fundamentals of the Metaphysic of Morals by Emmanuel Kant can demonstrate that pet ownership is not morally reprehensible. There are ample arguments to be made that the way humans currently treat animals is inhumane (well, it is certainly inhumane under a literal definition – we treat them differently than we treat humans) and that this is morally reprehensible. One of the fundamental philosophical arguments is that humans are animals, and that by drawing an arbitrary line we make an artificial distinction where there is none, such as was made during the years of scientific racism (Dawkins 34). Furthermore, a though experiment can help develop this theme further: what if the intermediate species between humans and other apes, such as Australopithecus Aphaeresis, did not die, but were still alive today? Would we feel comfortable vivisecting them for medical research, as is currently done on chimpanzees (Nibert 7)? The answer is probably not, because they are so human like (). But then, we admit that the line is somewhat arbitrary – that at some point we decide that something is far enough “below” humans that their worth is fundamentally lessened, but above that point it is not? This is certainly an untenable position philosophically speaking, because there is very little that categorically separates humans from other animals – many other animals use tools, have some form of verbal communication (it has even been argued that Orcas have a form of symbolic language), can solve puzzles, do simple math and so on. Furthermore, humans have a fundamental inability to understand what is actually going on in an animal’s head – we can only surmise based on our own assumptions of their cognitive abilities. Yet this should make humans think that they must be exceedingly cautious in the dealing with Animals, to ensure that we are not accidentally committing slaver, oppression or genocide (Barilan 22). The analogous situation would be to imagine a species of aliens observing earth that have a completely different form of communication and cognition. They might not be able to imagine our communication or actions as intelligence or ...Show more

Summary

Your Name Prof’s Name Date Philosophical Thoughts on the Nature of Dogs We see animals all around us, but rarely do we actually take time to think about exactly what their nature is, and what our role in interacting with them can be. This might be especially true of the animals we tend to take the most notice of – pets such as cats and dogs…
Author : mike91
Philosophical Thoughts on the Nature of Dogs essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Philosophical Thoughts on the Nature of Dogs"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

Reservior Dogs
They thus produced excellent performances. The movie casts six criminals who are unfamiliar with each other and are employed by a master planner Joe Cabot to execute a diamond robbery (Berardinelli, "Reservoir Dogs"). They are nicknamed form the onset of the movie with the intention of having them concentrate on their appointment rather than getting to know each other.
7 pages (1750 words) Essay
Compare philosophical Daoist notions of nature with the emerging discourses in the West of Spiritual Ecology
Whereas the west’s ‘spiritual ecology’ calls for “a spiritual response to the ecological crisis”, Daoist approach, to nature, itself responds to this demand to a large extent. Western discourses on ‘spiritual ecology’ primarily connect the spiritual awareness of the sanctity of nature and natural orders with environmentalism and ecology.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Philosophical Thoughts and Issues
Development of a person’s philosophy is a remarkably rewarding experience in anyone’s life. Personal philosophy helps people to understand who they really are. My personal philosophy guides me to make the right choices in life.
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Describe Plato's philosophical analysis of the nature of knowledge, and explain what conclusions Plato drew for the methodolog
He argues that this doctrine is one that is characterized by one major enduring within the possession of humanity (Cooper 1). According to his findings, the horizon of life is bound by things that human beings see, touchy and handle. In addition, this horizon becomes indefinitely enlarged through the addition of a different type of human being, the type of timeliness, and abstract reality.
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Thoughts
This is because most of the American citizens are not enjoying their lives to the fullness as they are subjected to an environment that makes them unsafe. With the current definition of search and its consequences, it is clear that it needs some changes. This is because the police officers and other security personnel have tampered a lot with the people’s privacy in the name of searching for relevant security information.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Domestic Dogs
In 1993, dogs were reclassified as a subspecies of the Gray Wolf, Canis lupus. 'Dog' is sometimes used to refer collectively to any mammal belonging to the family Canidae, such as wolves, foxes, and coyotes. The domestic dog is a genetically diverse species that originated from wolf populations existing in different places and at different times.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Philosophical JournalDiary reflecting one's own thoughts and opinions upon several topics. Details below
Their views differ in claims and rights of the patient. The pro choice group insists on the autonomy that gives a right to refuse life support treatment in case of painful living. The opposite group talks about the choice of decision maker who can offer necessary pain relief treatment even in the context of shortening of life.
16 pages (4000 words) Essay
Dogs and their Intelligence
In defending this argument, Socrates introduced the “noble dog psychology”, where Socrates argued that a dog that is considered by
8 pages (2000 words) Essay
Compare and contrast between the philosophical thoughts of Booker T. Washington and W. E. B. Dubois
Washington and Du Bois endered to end racial injustices and class problem between the black community (Booker T. Washington vs. W.E.B DuBois). Washington was an educator and a moderate preacher of self-reliance, accommodation and class
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Compare and contrast between the philosophical thoughts of Booker T. Washington and W. E. B. Dubois
Booker T. Washington and W.E. DuBois held different approaches to improving the black community (Karenga 152). Washington felt that the African American people should use formalized
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation