Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you! Try us!

Gettier's Problem - Essay Example

Free
Ph.D.
Essay
Philosophy
Pages 3 (753 words)
Download 0

Summary

In this 3-paged paper Gettier challenged the classic theory of knowledge which defines knowledge as ‘justified true belief’. Gettier presented two cases in which subjects achieve the justified true belief, but fail to recognize it, proving that knowledge varies from justified true belief. …

Extract of sample
Gettier's Problem

Since the late 1960s, many theories and solutions have been proposed by philosophers and experts in the field of epistemology, but none of them could provide flawless solution. According to the Gilbert Harman’s solution, interpretation from the false belief leads to the preclusion of knowledge to Getter’s subjects. In the Gettier’s Ford case, the reasoning about someone’s ownership of Ford in the office proceeds through a false belief that Jones owns the car. So according to Harman’s solution, knowledge is justified true belief where the interpretation of belief doesn’t proceed through false step. But, suppose Jones was cleaning a Ford and whistling the Ford advertising jingle. Based on it, Smith concluded that someone in the office was waxing a Ford and whistling the Ford jingle. This belief was true. Further, on the basis of justified belief, Smith concluded that someone in the office owned a Ford which is true as Sam, a new employer, owned that car. Though here belief didn’t proceed through any false steps, it failed to consider as knowledge. Similar to Harman, various other solutions such as, Zagzebski’s solution, Greco’s solution, Sosa’s solution, infallibilism, and contextualism tried to respond to the problem by presenting their own theories, modifying the present conditions, replacing or adding new conditions in it. ...
Download paper
Not exactly what you need?

Related Essays

The Gettier Problem
Gettier’s argument says that it is possible that a person believes in something that is justified as well as wrong at the same time. One flaw is that Gettier’s argument can lead us to cynicism because it is evident from our everyday lives that it is hardly the case when something is justified by satisfactory evidence that fulfills all philosophical rules of relevant evidence. …
7 pages (1757 words)
The Mind/Body Problem
One research line states that some mind-body problems come from artificial intelligence research. One such problem can be solved by the clear knowledge hardware and software interaction and relationship. The other line of research shows that mind-body relation might be illuminated by the study of emergence in the biological systems. Mind-body dualism or dualism is a theory that holds that minds and brains both exist, and neither the mind nor the brain is part of each other. Both Hinduism and non-Advaitic Vedanta agree with mind-body dualism as when the soul moves through different…
3 pages (753 words)
The problem of evil
A number of intellectual opinions have explained impossibility of existence of both God and His powers, and evil and its associated powers and suffering. Two sets of elements, three about God’s power and one about evil illustrates mutual exclusivity between the power of God over evil and the persistent existence of evil to develop the controversy. God is, for example, believed to be super powerful, present at all places and at all times and knows everything that happens on earth and in heaven. This means that evil occurs in God’s presence, against his powers, and with His knowledge.…
3 pages (753 words)
The problem of evil
This is not however the case and the controversy induces dilemma on both believers and non-believers. This paper explores the concept of the problem of evil. Concepts of the problem of evil The problem of evil arises from the scope of nature that identifies conflicts in theories in existence of evil and God’s characteristics. This is because a consideration of the nature of God and His power should not allow evil to prevail, or should at least be able to eliminate evil. A number of intellectual opinions have explained impossibility of existence of both God and His powers, and evil and its…
3 pages (753 words)
The Problem of Evil
There are people with numerous doubts, but others hold on to their faith in God. The paper establishes a discussion of the topic though a description, analysis and evaluation of arguments by various philosophers, and it will also establish the stance of the paper concerning the topic. Emmanuel Levinas is one of the philosophers who asserts that evil influences people into doing the wrong things; thus, he seeks to develop a discussion that accounts for evil. In fact, his argument is based on the role of rationality through the propagation of evil, which seems to be underestimated (Katz, 2005).…
7 pages (1757 words)
The Problem of Evil
Emmanuel Levinas is one of the philosophers who asserts that evil influences people into doing the wrong things; thus, he seeks to develop a discussion that accounts for evil. In fact, his argument is based on the role of rationality through the propagation of evil, which seems to be underestimated (Katz, 2005). Moreover, he argues that evil is infused in everyday transformation of temptations that are forbidden concerning impulse of good. Furthermore, his approach to the problem of evil is based on the discount of the conventional perception of theodicy that is considered a justification or…
7 pages (1757 words)