StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Aristotle's Theory concerning Moral Responsibility - Essay Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
Aristotle's Theory concerning Moral Responsibility

Aristotle believes that every human being has a responsibility for his or her actions, something that makes others reasonably praise, blame or even punish him or her; he shows this by pointing out various conditions, which lessen or even cancel this responsibility. He converses force of occurrences, threats, along with coercion, bad character, ignorance and intoxication. Taken together, his version shows the basic concepts involved in being a person who ends up getting reasonably praised or blamed. The primary limitation concerning voluntary action is the force of circumstances. Aristotle gives an example about a ship caught in a storm; in this case, the sailors have to throw goods overboard to avoid the sinking of the ship. Here, the action is not entirely voluntary; therefore the sailors are not to blame for their actions. On the other hand, the storm is not to blame for the undesirable outcome, which is the loss of the goods, since it is a natural event that no one is responsible. Another example is the case whereby my friend accidentally pushes me as a result of getting pushed by a bully; here, she is not to blame considering that it was not here intention to push me, rather, she got pushed, and as a result, ended up pushing me. These cases are extreme instances of the force of necessity whereby we always live and always get forced into our actions by natural facts, though we only notice this when the force happens to be sudden or unexpected (Williams 25). In reality, the interference of other people is what causes us the most grief, which in turn causes problems when it comes to responsibility attributions. This interference tends to take many forms; however, its paradigmatic forms happen to be coercion and manipulation. Concerning coercion, the judgment by Aristotle get balanced since it is dependent on what act my coercer is demanding from me, as well as the threats he is making. On the other hand, there are some actions, which tend to be extremely heinous that we must be blamed for carrying them out, whatever a person gets threatened with, together with whatever blame also tends to be attached to the coercer; hence Aristotle dismisses the thought that a man may be compelled to killing his mother (Williams 45). Apparently, a central issue at stake when it comes to attributions of responsibility happens to be the expectations that people have each other. Although there are some kinds of coercion that we do not normally expect people to oppose, there are also some forms of action that people should never embark on, regardless of such features. In these cases praise, together with blame tends to work on clarifying and to reinforce these expectations through the provision of a form of moral education. What determines appropriate or immoral character happens to be the manner in which a person reacts when he discovers the truth or failing to regret their deeds, then they can be blamed, albeit the original choice being justifiable. According to Aristotle, our praise and blame is in most cases, not about an individual act; rather, it is about the character of the one who acted. Importantly, not every form of ignorance gets excused since moral knowledge happens to be extremely distinctive from factual knowledge (Echenique 49). However, if a person tends to be morally ignorant, he or she ends up being unable to choose well; here, Aristotle grants that the majority of people of settled villainous character, whether they are morally ignorant or otherwise, are ...Show more

Summary

Name Instructor Course Date Aristotle’s Theory concerning Moral Responsibility According to Aristotle’s theory concerning moral responsibility, there is neither hard nor fast rule for ascertaining whether a person who has acted due to coercion is blameworthy…
Author : zeldanicolas
Aristotles Theory concerning Moral Responsibility essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Aristotle's Theory concerning Moral Responsibility"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

Aristotle's ethics
Examples of moral virtues are humility, truthfulness, moderation, and generosity. On the other hand, intellectual virtues are those personality traits that are required for correct thinking and desired action. He classified intellectual virtues as productive such as craft knowledge, theoretical such as wisdom and mind and lastly practical such as practical prudence.
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Aristotle on Moral Responsibility
It is not possible to read an introduction of western philosophy without the mention of Aristotle. The discussion of moral responsibility composes a significant part of Aristotle’s philosophy. He discusses morality on the basis of voluntary and involuntary actions.
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Theory of Ethics Essay
Intellectual virtues are those personality traits that are required for correct thinking and desired action. Aristotle classified intellectual virtues as productive such as craft knowledge, theoretical such as wisdom and mind and lastly practical such as practical prudence.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Brecht's Theory and Practice to Aristotle's Theory
Epic theatre for Brecht was more of a didactic nature. It was focused on changing the social stereotypes within the society. There was a need for the society to change the concept of the epic drama and shift its accents to the modernity. Therefore, the problems and challenges of the modernity were mainly on behalf of the theatre and it was necessary to focus the attention of the modernity on the current processes of socialization.
8 pages (2000 words) Essay
Explain and assess the role that virtue plays in Aristotle's theory of justice
In his estimation, regulations inspire people to conduct themselves morally, therefore, the fair individual, whose character is legitimate, will essentially be honourable. He states that a desirable character who claims he/she acts according to the moral code of justice is not the same thing as justice itself because it is only concerned with an individual’s moral state, while fairness has to do with an individual’s associations with other people.
9 pages (2250 words) Essay
Moral Theory
These cases are examples of a social group or culture making a moral judgment on behavior. Morality seems to shift like quicksand as we travel from our inner social circles to larger cultural groups and the interacting people of the world. It is often on a continuum that has no set boundaries and no well defined rules.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Humes Moral Judgement Theory
Hume's argument involves the examination of practical reason. Reason is never, according to Hume, the sole motivation for the generation of action. Action is always motivated by personal desires and passions and reason is merely the instrument used to satisfy these feelings.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Aristotle on Moral Responsibility
He discusses morality on the basis of voluntary and involuntary actions. He also believes that virtues are of two kinds, intellectual and moral virtue. Apart from involuntary and voluntary criteria, there is another criterion that Aristotle
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Aristotle's Responsibility
(Höffe 97) Voluntary actions are those that are done out of free will while, involuntary actions are actions done out of ignorance or compulsion. To understand
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Immanuel Kant Moral Theory
Although deontological theories were in existence long before the Kant was born, he emerged as the most celebrated proponent of the theory. It is founded on the basis that human beings are rational and should, therefore, act in accordance with their moral duty.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation