StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Hart-Devlin Debate - Term Paper Example

Extract of sample
Hart-Devlin Debate

They often defined right or wrong in the society, and people often stand to those principles. The law is not enacted when one is not moral or does not act in a certain moral way. The reparations of not being moral are often individual. Morality and laws often contradict in their formation and implementation. Moralities develop after a while, are not easy to alter, and are often a mindset that people have. Laws on the other hand, are easily amended and do not require a lot of time. The well-known debate between hart and Devlin addressed the relationship between law and principles. The debate sought to address several issues in criminal law. The issues at hand are mainly how homosexuality was a part of criminal law (Curzon pg 36). Laws and morality have been debated on for many years. The line between the two is often thin, and some morals turn out to be ethical issues. Laws are often enforced by the administration of a country. Morals on the other hand, are often supported by the administration but by the society at large. In 1957, the Wolfenden commission met to discuss a few issues. The committee aimed at decriminalization homosexual activities of men who acted in private. The debate questioned the relations that existed between morality and the law. The commission members questioned the extent to which criminal law was limited immensely. They did not understand how morality and criminal law intertwined. The commission had an extremely weighty argument that formed the basis of the debate to date (Lee pg 160). Devlin’s view The commission felt that if the actions of an individual did not harm the society then the offence was not significant. They felt the law would be justified to allow liberty of preferences even though the actions were considered immoral by the society. According to the committee, the role of the legal system consisted of defending the members of the society. The court was to protect the rights of the public from unpleasant and harmful acts. The court has no right to enforce any form of moral decision on an individual (Lee pg 161).What an individual does is purely personal, and no one has the right to interfere. There are various categories of harm in the society. It is not a criminal offence to hurt a person’s feeling. Devlin did not agree with this report and published an article to disclaim this. He argued that the law was not only meant for persons but for the public at large. The society has a lot of people, and it needs protection. The needs of an individual are less than society’s. The society morals cannot be compromised because of the rights of one individual in society. He argued that morality should come on its own. Devlin asserted that principles ought to stem from a sober mind what should be done to improve the society at large (Curzon pg 43). The society has the biggest role to play in the governing of the country. One individual’s actions affect the society at large. The actions of such individuals should therefore, be taken into account and in protecting the rights of one individual, lawmakers risk tarnishing the reputation of the society. In Devlin’s view, lawmakers have to consider a person’s liberty. They also have to take into account the fact that the society is constantly changing. The way the public views social customs and the liberty of an individual to act in private is also changing. Not everyone accepted the thought that Devlin had and one person in particular sought to challenge the thought. The man who challenged this thought went by the name Hart. He did not agree with what Devlin had said and responded through a radio broadcasting. He later published an article in the magazine in contradiction to Devlin’ ...Show more

Summary

Introduction Laws are necessary for the survivor of any society. Rules are broken and an offence is often committed. Laws consist of a group of rules forced by the authority and defying them often results to punishments. Morals are often personal. …
Author : teagan30
Hart-Devlin Debate essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the term paper on your topic
"Hart-Devlin Debate"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

Company Sales Management Plan (Hart Hospital Equipment, Inc)
The success of an organization typically depends on the performance of its sales force. Sales forces not only generate sales for a company, but also represent the products of a company towards the customers. Effective sales persons perform several activities and therefore need to be managed carefully by the sales managers.
14 pages (3500 words) Term Paper
Debate on Health Care Management
The current health care delivery system in the country is summarized by emphasizing on the plight of the uninsured, particularly the broadening disparities in racial and ethnic access to health care. These effects are as a result of the government interventions and the market mixes in health care policies.
10 pages (2500 words) Term Paper
Democratic Theory Debate
Tom Aquinas: The pictures of city, democracy and citizenship are not just symbols but organizations on the way to which we moreover adjust (or else are continually aggravated to adjustment) our judgments and performances concerning the political system. The query of what it entails to be political is forever sloping in the direction of these descriptions that have been composed as not purely factual or fake other than as incontrovertible situations of being political.
8 pages (2000 words) Term Paper
Debate Between the Needs of Homeland Security and Individual-Privacy Expectations
The major objective of the department of homeland security is to fight terrorist attacks within the United States. Homeland Security works closely with other government departments to prevent domestic terrorism. This paper seeks to explore the debate surrounding the needs of homeland security and individual privacy expectations.
6 pages (1500 words) Term Paper
Interpretation & evaluation of one theory belonging to H.L.A. Hart in book 'Concept of Law'
H. L. A. Hart had several proposals to convey throughout his period. However, the creme of his work may be described to be contained in his book, the concept of law. This work contains a series of argument that are fetched from a wide perception cultivated from various angles of law and philosophy.
7 pages (1750 words) Term Paper
Pornography Addiction and the Effects on Relationships Inside and Outside of Family
The primary reason behind discovering the same includes the tremendous increase in pornography addiction among the individuals belonging to different ethno-racial backgrounds, nationalities, occupations, educational levels, age-groups, sexual orientations and both the genders as well predominantly in the present era.
12 pages (3000 words) Term Paper
Assisted Suicide or Euthanasia
In the modern context Euthanasia has gradually been adopted and is currently used to refer to the inducement of an essentially painless death for individuals. This paper seeks to establish what exactly are the contemporary views relating to euthanasia, the impact of euthanasia on society as well as establish its general legal status in a number of countries including also in the United States.
4 pages (1000 words) Term Paper
Debate Between The Epicureans And The Stoics
Understanding ten debates between the Epicureans and the Stoics and determine which of the two arguments is plausible in the understating philosophy of life, it is vital the each of these philosophical aspects are understood well and their applications determined.
5 pages (1250 words) Term Paper
Debate: Why should we against to lower drinking age
However, there is far more evidence that reducing the drinking age to 18 would have significant health-related consequences and would likely provide increases
2 pages (500 words) Term Paper
Current Macroeconomic Topic in US
It is the belief of countless people that the legalization of certain drugs can have more benefits as compared to the criminalization of its sale and use (Husak and Marneffe 172). Marijuana is just an
4 pages (1000 words) Term Paper
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation