StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Utilitarian vs. Deontological Perspectives: Human Cloning - Assignment Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
Utilitarian vs. Deontological Perspectives: Human Cloning

Yet, human beings have found that there may be potential benefits in creating human clones for a number of different reasons. The debate on this subject has been going on for decades and will likely continue to do so for some time. There are many different philosophical perspectives that one could apply to the issue of human cloning; it is the utilitarian and deontological perspective that offer two interesting comparative views. Human cloning has dominated science fiction for decades with scenarios revealing how the practice could go terribly wrong. Ethical debates have proposed many other unique issues with cloning; everything from the development of unforeseen genetic flaws, to the devaluation of life, to whether, or not, a cloned being will have rights and even a soul. However, it is the incredible potential of medical “miracles” that cloning might allow, in all its forms, which includes, ending infertility, eradicating genetic diseases, curing illnesses, replacing damaged organs, and last but not least, the ability to create life as they see fit, that continues to lure supporters.The philosophy cares less about how you accomplish something as long as the overall outcome leads to the greatest amount of overall good and happiness, while deontology considers less the outcomes and more about the intention behind doing it. The moral intent is more important in deciding whether something is good or bad, or right or wrong, has greater than the outcomes and results. The ideology embraces the “Categorical Imperatives,” which include a "universality" within the principles, all humans are rational agents, and must be treated as such. That said, given the topic of human cloning, it is, very likely, that on face value, utilitarian’s would support the implementation of the practices. The positive outcomes could be perceived as one of the greatest benefits and overall good. People would be happier if less threatened by diseases, trauma, and sicknesses via the development of clones for medical purposes. The Greatest Happiness principle is geared toward finding that ultimate happiness in the great end, based on making decisions that lead to greater good not greater pains (Mill 577). However, deontologists would very likely take an opposing position. It is probable that they would reflect upon the intentions of the science. For deontologists hold firm that there is no other qualifier of whether something is “good” is based on the will behind it (Kant 582). According to the three “Categorical Principles” embraced by deontologists, human cloning might raise some philosophical principles that they cannot ignore. They would question the intentions of such sciences and the applications that it may lend to, in order to determine the good or bad of the endeavor. Firstly, in order for human cloning to be acceptably practiced it must be accepted as “universalized” rule, which would inevitably limit some of the different types of human cloning, while potentially allowing others. If it cannot be universalized, however, then it likely would never be practiced. Secondly, the idea that every individual is a “rational agents,” is threatened by the fact human cloning would require the control over or manipulation of some people over others. This would contradict the deontological perspective. They, might, also, question how human clones, in whatever form, would be treated within ...Show more


Yet, human beings have found that there may be potential benefits in creating human clones for a number of different reasons. The debate on this subject has been going on for decades and will likely continue to do so for some time…
Author : branson58
Utilitarian vs. Deontological Perspectives: Human Cloning essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the assignment on your topic
"Utilitarian vs. Deontological Perspectives: Human Cloning"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

Methods which are being used in gene therapy to achieve the objectives are to use vectors or genes. Retrovirus is a type of vectors which is introduced in the human body through helper cells so
3 pages (750 words) Assignment
Major Theoretical Perspectives
This in sociological terms is known as the structuralist approach. Structuralists analyze the sociological phenomenon through a macro approach looking at the structures of institutions and how do they influence
5 pages (1250 words) Assignment
2.Human Cell ResearchSkloots book is also a history of cell research, its achievements and its disturbing side. Does Skloot gain or lose credibility by including the horror stories of cloning, the immortal chicken heart, some unscrupulous scientis
The Death and Life of Cell Culture is an important chapter in the book, detailing how important the cells of HeLa were to many scientists because they provided
3 pages (750 words) Assignment
Stem Cells, IVF, and Cloning: Five Ethical Questions
lls: A fetus, which is a developing baby after 10 weeks of pregnancy, contains many such tissues that contain stem cells responsible for rapid development of organs. They are important for producing mature cells in the tissue. iii) Cord blood stem cells: These are the stem
3 pages (750 words) Assignment
Utilitarianism and Deontology
Yet, human beings have found that there may be potential benefits in creating human clones for a number of different reasons. The debate on this subject has been going on for decades and will likely continue to do so for some time.
3 pages (750 words) Assignment
Cloning of Animals
She was made known to the world in 1997. This is a picture of a cloned pig in Denmark in 2009. Cloned animals are normally produced using SCNT or somatic cell nuclear transfer. The process needs a somatic cell, which
4 pages (1000 words) Assignment
Justice Studies Perspectives
In other words, it can be said that not all laws are created to meet a respective aim. By natural instinct, people assume that law is created to achieve moral aims. In contradiction to such a belief, it has been noted that the law creators are not moral
4 pages (1000 words) Assignment
Distinguishing Marks and Flowering Design: Baltimores Utilitarian Stoneware Industry
The scope of the study is to gain an understanding of the utility and limitations of “Baltimore stoneware maker’s marks, characteristic types of decoration, functional aspects of utilitarian wares,
2 pages (500 words) Assignment
Perspectives Assignment
This range involves the employee, employer, and the trade unions as well. Marxist approach encompasses a broader realm and bases its
3 pages (750 words) Assignment
Psychological perspectives
It is in this stage when children learn about their bodies by gratifying physical curiosity as they explore and undress each other. During this stage of development, a child has various demands and needs including the need of an infant to nurse among
1 pages (250 words) Assignment
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation