Resolving dilemma by Applying Ethical Theories: The Case of Gina Kolata - Essay Example

Only on StudentShare

Extract of sample
Resolving dilemma by Applying Ethical Theories: The Case of Gina Kolata

Resolving dilemma by Applying Ethical Theories: The Case of Gina Kolata

There was no allowance for the doctor to disclose his results and thoughts to the person who had made a donation of the cells. The condition for the donation of the cells was that his name would be kept anonymous. The evolution of the world has been accompanied by various developments that have created the allowance for the doctors to use sophisticated tools and techniques in their practices, including in the studies of DNA. The eventuality is that doctors are finding the results that they do not need for their practice. However, these encompass the information that could make a lot of difference if disclosed to the anonymous donors. Then the crucial question pertains to the subject of whether the genetic results should ever be conveyed to the families of the donors. The question also pertains to how, as well as when, these could be effectively done. Doctor Francis Collin acknowledges criticality of the underlying dilemma, commending that the society is living in the era where information obtained from research is so controversial that those who obtain do not know how to use it. Such ethical dilemma persistently present itself year-after-year, as the time not only yield cheaper, but also relatively easy techniques of genome sequencing. Nevertheless, some research findings are often clear. For example, the colon cancer genes would increase the susceptibility of cancer infection for the subjects who inherit it. How significant the genetic changes occur is never clear. ...
Download paper


The article by Kolata features an ethical dilemma a pertaining to the experimental practices. Dr. Chinnaiayan looks at the gene sequence printout of a man with cancerous cells. This is the first subject of his studies. …
Author : aileen49

Related Essays

Mоvie Review on Stranger than Paradise
Mоvie Review on Stranger than Paradise ...
7 pages (1757 words) Essay
Introduction to Philosophy : What Should I Do?
Introduction to Philosophy : What Should I Do? ...
5 pages (1255 words) Essay
ethical dilemma, analysing the dilemma using different ethical theories (utilitarianizm, liberty, virtue)
According to Catherine Berglund (2007) ethics is “a process of reflection”. Reflecting on what is right and what seems to be wrong. Arguments are looked at and analysed in order to come to a conclusion. It is due to medical ethics, that the right to consent and confidentiality have been identified (Holland, 2007). Ethical decisions are made every day, by every person. Is it right to park on disabled parking space when you rushing your child to the hospital? Or, is it fair to lie to your partner even if you know that it would make him happy? This is just the tip of the moral dilemmas’...
5 pages (1255 words) Essay
Feeling Good: The New Mood Therapy
Feeling Good: The New Mood Therapy ...
4 pages (1004 words) Book Report/Review
Reflection on Beauvoir’s Becoming a Woman
The couple, Richard and Sheila Peterson, was both in their early thirties and had no kids though occasionally their nieces and nephews came over as they offered to babysit for their siblings when they were otherwise occupied. Because of them, I developed a somewhat cynic perspective on the institution of marriage. This perspective first took root when they had a barbeque and invited everyone within the neighborhood. At the time, Sheila was working as a nurse at a private clinic in town, twenty minutes away from the residence. Her profession could explain her warm, outwardly maternal nature...
3 pages (753 words) Essay
Preference to Normal over Disabled under QALY Based Allocation
Preference to Normal over Disabled under QALY Based Allocation ...
2 pages (502 words) Essay
Should Prostitution Be Prohibited?
Furthermore, it promotes the growth of an immorally-based community. Based on the above underpinning evidence, it is justifiable to strongly say that prostitution ought to be prohibited in our society. Prohibition of prostitution will reduce the high number of incidences of adultery. Prostitution gives men the opportunity to cheat on their girlfriends and wives in an easy. Therefore, if it is prohibited cheating men will suffer extremely consequences since the law will be on their toes. As a result, the number of men who take advantage of prostitutes, wives, or girlfriend will decrease...
4 pages (1004 words) Essay
Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you! Try us!