Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you! Try us!

The Speluncean Explorer's case - Term Paper Example

Only on StudentShare
Author : oconnellleo

Summary

THE CASE OF THE SPELUNCEAN EXPLORERS (A hypothetical legal case study) Name of Student (author) Name of University Introduction This paper examines the relevant issues in a hypothetical legal case which had involved five members of the Speluncean Society (an explorers club) which forced all the members of the judiciary trying the case, to take a hard look again at the case facts because of the unusual nature of cannibalism among the survivors who were trapped inside a cave they were exploring from an unexpected landslide, which closed their only exit point from the cave…

Extract of sample
The Speluncean Explorer's case

In essence, what this case showed is an apparent conflict between law and justice, when there is an exigency, and whether the law as written, still applies due to the highly unusual circumstances obtaining in this case, or to allow some exceptions to the rule of law, which might undermine the structure of an orderly society. Discussion Five members of the explorer society went inside a limestone cavern but soon found out they were involuntarily imprisoned due to a landslide which blocked the only known opening of the cave, and hence, blocked their exit for escape as well. It took some time for the rescue party to finally gain access to the trapped explorers which entailed great effort and expense. When they were finally rescued, after repeated landslides which killed ten rescuers, on the thirty-second day of their imprisonment, sordid details of their enforced stay inside the cave came to light. It soon was revealed the four survivors engaged in cannibalism by eating one explorer, which was Roger Whetmore, in order to survive their confinement, as they had brought along only scant food. ...
Download paper

Related Essays

Ethics Case Study
Appeals are usually made to evidence as offering a logical reason for the adoption of particular laws of morality and living1. Key Ideas for support There are three strategies to the issue of moral decision making, imperative, subjective and objective. The objective strategy is erroneous in that it fails to offer an explicit method by which agreement may be reached as regards the allocation of values. A good example of this is the moral claim it is good which is very different to an empirical description such as it is raining. It is self evident that it would be illogical to make an assessment…
Ethical Case Study
Utilitarian ethics provides a fairly straightforward means of deciding a course of action for a particular matter. Using the utilitarian theory of ethics, first all possible alternative courses of actions have to be identified which are then evaluated for their potential merits and demerits for all the concerned parties (Andre and Velasquez, n.d.). Finally, the course of action whose benefits are maximal is selected. In light of the utilitarian theory of ethics, Paige should have evaluated all courses of actions that could be adopted. There were potentially three courses of actions that she…
3 pages (753 words)
Undocumented nurse medical errors
The researcher starts with description of his first day at his first job. His nurse trainer was evidently flustered with her numerous tasks in the hospital. The researcher followed her to a patient’s room, where she administered medication. The patient was recovering from a car accident, where he suffered from some chest and abdominal trauma, as well as a badly-broken leg. The researcher was confused, because the name on the door was not the same in the med chart. He returned to the nursing station, where she documented the medication. After opening the patient’s chart, she was distressed…
14 pages (3514 words)
ETHICS in PRACTICE- CASE STUDY
More importantly, the reporter’ friend’s Jane Ryan who is publishing this article is aware of the fact that he had access to those photos since he was added as a friend of one of those teachers on facebook. All expect one of the photos were accessible to other but only to a few friends. The paper is an attempt to get into the shoes of that reporter and help solve the ethical dilemma. Discussion The point, which is important here to note is that by not allowing that article to the published, one, would be upholding the principles of “liberty” and “freedom”. Analysis has indicated…
8 pages (2008 words)
Racial Profiling: Trayyvon Martins Case
This paper will try to show that the motives behind Zimmerman’s shooting of Martin was racially motivated and that the stand your own ground rule in Florida has been used to defend a racial injustice of the highest order. The death of Martin Trayvon, a seventeen-year-old boy, took place on 26th February, 2012. The boy was shot by George Zimmerman, a neighborhood watch volunteer who was not happy at Trayvon and his friends for being unable to stop the burglaries in their neighborhood. Zimmerman spotted the teen walk past the rain in a grey hooded sweater and alerted the police on 911. He…
3 pages (753 words)
faith healing case
He provided the boy’s parents with information regarding the treatment that is available, and then explained to them the procedures that would have to be undertaken. The parents discussed the matter between themselves for two hours, and then told the physician that they had reached the decision to take their son to a faith healing service instead of seeking medical intervention. The physician tried to convince them of the futility of this action but to no avail. The parents left with their son after the physician gave them a return appointment, but they did not honor it. II. Ethical Question…
3 pages (753 words)
Ethics Case Study
Jerry’s training within the medical field surrounds him to not be in a position from where he can prescribe anyone a medicine. This makes him disqualified to resolve an issue at hand, which in this case has happened when Dr. Williams was not present on his seat. There is a possibility that Dr. Williams has essentially forbidden dosage of Valium to a certain patient, and in this case if Jerry McCall prescribes usage of Valium just on the basis of being Dr. Williams’ friend, then this shall become an ethical issue all the same. Hence it would be fitting enough for Jerry McCall to keep…
4 pages (1004 words)