StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Ethics - Assignment Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
Ethics

He further argues that all animals posses sentience, and therefore animals should be treated the same way as humans regarding any morally relevant interest. Singer equates treating animals lesser than human beings to other forms of discrimination like racism and ethnicity. Furthermore, Singer equates animals with human beings who have irreversible brain damage. The utilitarian views of Singer are opposed and refuted by Cohen. Cohen argues that rights can only be restricted to moral agents. To refute Singer’s argument that animals have equal rights to humans, Cohen proposes a definition of rights as claims. A right according to Cohen is a claim made against somebody else. Cohen further argues that an obligation to ensure animal welfare cannot constitute a right. To prove this Cohen clearly shows that rights entail obligation but obligation cannot entail rights. However, Cohen’s fails to show how humans without the ability to claim their rights can enjoy rights. These groups of humans include human infants and mentally handicapped persons. Cohen’s speciesist theory failure to explain how humans without the capacity to claim rights can enjoy moral rights assists Utilitarianism answer his criticism for their explanation of animal rights. Prompt 2 The starting point for answering the question “Is there such thing as a moral saint?” always starts with an attempt to define the term. This is occasioned by the fact that any author who attempts to tackle the controversial question must have a standard of morality that the supposed “moral saint” satisfies. This approach is reflected in Wolf who starts his work by giving a brief description of what the moral saint is supposed to be. Wolf defines a moral saint as a person who strives to be as good as possible everyday and in every situation. Similarly, Carbonell in his work article Moral Saint Reconsidered also starts his exploration of the issue with a description of the term moral saint. According to Carbonell, moral saints are individuals whose conduct goes beyond the obligation of morality. She also describes moral saints as resolute and tenacious people, who are ready to make great human sacrifice. Carbonell concentrates on supererogatory actions that are beyond the call of morality as the main conduct that qualifies a person to be defined as a moral saint. Dr. Paul Farmer would not qualify as a moral saint under the standard set by Wolf in his definition of a Moral saint. According to Wolf a moral saint ignores common non-moral activities and takes a resigned and pessimistic attitude of vices and flaws in morality. In contrast, Dr. Paul Farmer is not moral in all situations as exemplified by his conduct of stealing drugs from an American hospital to aid in the treatment of diarrhea stricken Haitians. The fact that Paul Farmer cannot be considered a moral saint under Wolf’s definition points to the difficult those authors face in defining the term moral saint. Thus, it cannot be taken as a weakness in Wolf’s argument in trying to answer the question “Is there such thing as a moral saint?” Prompt 3 Moral luck can be defined as a situation whereby moral responsibility is assigned to a moral agent for action or consequence that they do not have full control over. According to Williams, luck influences the life of humans in countless way. Luck determines whether a person will be happy or successful in life. However, luck should not play any role in the moral responsibil ...Show more

Summary

Part A. 1. TRUE 2. TRUE 3. TRUE 4. TRUE 5. TRUE 6. TRUE Part B Prompt 1 Singer argues that animals have equal rights with men as they are a species that has life. According to Singer there should be some concern for the wellbeing of animals in a moral society…
Author : jaleelboehm
Ethics Assignment essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the assignment on your topic
"Ethics Assignment"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

Assignment on Ethics
As indicated, “when the major engineering compartments begin to fill up with water, the large water-tight hatch must be closed quickly or the ship will sink with all hands aboard”.
10 pages (2500 words) Assignment
Ethics Assignment
First Dworkin admits the dependence of a person on psychoactive drugs is to protect and shield oneself from the imponderable and unpredictability. He asserts that if happiness is serotonin and serotonin is happiness then it is true to say that these drugs guarantee happiness because one can take psychopathic drugs for many years.
4 pages (1000 words) Assignment
Marketing Ethics Assignment
In today's world, when globalization has taken the entire world by storm, one can witness numerous corporations having global presence in a number of regions and countries. As a result of this widespread access, these companies have been able to create products and services which have been created exclusively for these regions keeping in mind the different external factors in mind such as the cultural, economic etc.
6 pages (1500 words) Assignment
Ethics Assignment
The Planned Parenthood website is easily accessible and their page design contains comprehensive amount of information on the organization, on various health related services including abortion, birth control, sex and sexuality,
1 pages (250 words) Assignment
Ethics Assignment
Singer argues that all “animals are equal” and humans are not superior to other animal species. He further argues that all animals posses sentience, and therefore animals
4 pages (1000 words) Assignment
LEGAL ISSUES FOR MANAGERS - Ethics Assignment
As pertains to every company’s conduct no employee is by any means authorized to disclose any confidential information they come across. Thus, Brad would stand
2 pages (500 words) Assignment
Ethics assignment
The second possible action to take in this dilemma is to follow the advice of the instructor, but go ahead to inform the human subjects about the negative results that some sample of the data had showed. The third possible cause of action in this ethical dilemma would be to
2 pages (500 words) Assignment
Business Ethics Assignment 8_08
Traditional utilitarianism is one of the major theories in normative ethics. This theory focuses on the proper course of action which can be taken by any organization for future benefits. Again this theory helps to maximize utility and
4 pages (1000 words) Assignment
Ethics Assignment
Phil had other intentions of defrauding the insurance company. His fraudulent actions requiring Kevin to dig up nearly all the underground
5 pages (1250 words) Assignment
(Course: Ethics, Decision Making, and Communications.) Code of Ethics Assignment: The Ethical Code Letter
That is why I decided to use this opportunity in order to write a letter that will contain some provisions that will later be adopted in the Code of Ethics that we all adhere to. It is quite obvious that
4 pages (1000 words) Assignment
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation