Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you! Try us!

Choices We Make - Essay Example

Only on StudentShare
Author : doylelilliana


The notion that self should be associated with choice appeals to me for the reason that 'self' is never alone. One of the possible answers to the need of question of self lies in manifestations of identity. …

Extract of sample
Choices We Make

Chapter 4 of the book by Solomon, Higgins, and Martin (2011) begins with the quote from Alice in Wonderland where the Caterpillar questions the very importance of self (p. 285). In Carroll's (1996) text, neither the caterpillar nor actually Alice care too much about their identities. They choose the selves they want to be, as if they were Sartrians, but in much more playful manner. Yet in one of the responses to the caterpillar Alice remarks: “Oh, I'm not particular as to size, only one doesn't like changing so often, you know” (Carroll, 1996). That means that there are still limits to human will as Alice’s will is overcome by her perceived irritation by the repeated change. In this paper, I will be arguing for the contradictory nature of self-identity that establishes itself through choice, as Existentialists assert (Solomon, Higgins and Martin, 2011, p. 303), but necessarily encounters the opposition to its choice from the parts of the larger context (“Others”). I believe that the working momentary compromise between the assertions of human will (internal factors) and such external factors as natural circumstances, or the will of other(s), is a possible solution of the problem of self-identity.
Such thinkers as Locke and Sartre strictly associated self with consciousness: Locke believed this because he relied on the separation of mind and substance (Solomon, Higgins and Martin, 2011, p. 291) while Sartre emphasized such act of consciousness as choice. This notion is very controversial for a number of reasons. Firstly, there are states of brain in which the presence of self is either not registered or not controlled by 'consciousness', the ones that are conceptualized as different brain waves in contemporary neurology (Hall, 1998). ...
Download paper

Related Essays

Strawson-Free Will Essay
The unpleasantness of the choice does not nullify the presence of the choice or the fact that we always have the option to choose either the pleasant or more tolerable route over the unpleasant option and vice versa. Part II: Present the argument According to Strawson’s analysis, humans lack the capacity to make free choices. The influences of society, parents, friends, teachers, and all of the contributory factors that shape each of us into the unique individuals we are countermand our ability to freely make decisions. Since we do not control who we are and who we are determines the…
4 pages (1004 words)
Obligations to Future Generations
This is not to suggest that the conveniences and luxury are evenly distributed around the globe or even within nations and communities. There is a vast difference between the wealth of nations in the developing world and that of a superpower such as the United States or the European Union. What is undeniable is that all of humanity have benefited directly or indirectly through improvements in transportation and technology. The advancements in technology are truly marvelous, but they are not without drawbacks. There is a real cost attached to every advancement made in transportation and…
8 pages (2008 words)
Philosophy Essay: Kant
It is believed to be the base of understanding knowledge. Descartes statement indicates that he believes in the notion of consciousness and the self. When one thinks about himself, that is proof enough that there is a consciousness as he is able to think. And with that, he proves to himself that his self is in fact existing as he is able to prove his own consciousness by thinking. His proposition, I think therefore I am, is based on clarity and self-evidence of the statement. It is not based on inference, assumption or abstract thought. His statement in itself proves his point that since he is…
4 pages (1004 words)
Are We Free to Choose? Or, Are Our Actions Determined by Outside Forces?
It is very clear from the experiences of Emily and Kenneth that the two were psychologically unfit to make a decision out of free will. Part Two: Argument analysis. Most of the time people make decisions and later regret why they make such moves. In decisions made out of free will, people do not regret on the consequences of their actions. Emily and Kenneth regretted on their actions because they suffered. Since individual choices come with responsibility, we need to have the right kind control over our will and desire in the appropriate way. Although determinism may present an upfront…
3 pages (753 words)
Hume's analysis of the process by which we make causal judgments
In other words, Hume distinguishes between the relationship of ideas and facts. This paper is going to discuss Hume’s analysis of the process by which we make causal judgments. Definition of causality Causality can be defined as the relationship between an object and a fact; it is among the most recognized ideas that we have. Causality is involved in almost all undertakings or human way of thinking; it is assumed in every argument and sensible actions. It is considered a beneficial idea in all areas of philosophy including philosophy science from the time of ancient Greeks to present. Hume…
8 pages (2008 words)
In a society, this is applied to adopting policies which should serve the greatest number of people or the majority of the population and the course of action that would be untaken should have a net effect of increasing happiness.  Advocates of libertarian principles, by contrast generally criticize any distributive ideal that requires the pursuit of economic ‘patterns’, such as maximization or equality of welfare or of material goods. They argue that the pursuit of such patterns conflicts with the more important moral demands of liberty or self-ownership (Stanford Encyclopedia of…
4 pages (1004 words)
Critical analysis of the Titanic
Critical analysis of the Titanic …
5 pages (1255 words)