StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

In this paper, I argue that our government ought not redistribute wealth - Essay Example

Nobody downloaded yet

Extract of sample
In this paper, I argue that our government ought not redistribute wealth

Governments will normally utilize two types of methods to redistribute wealth. These are the use of vouchers, for instance, food stamps, and the use of subsidies (Hochschild 13). These programs that aim at transfering payment can be funded through such initiatives such as general taxation, which has a disproportionate benefit for those in poverty and others who are expected to pay fewer taxes. Persons who benefit from these programs sometimes prefer to be given money directly, although, some more palatable forms of redistribution may be put, in place, to control the expenditure from these funds. In this paper, I intend to use Nozick’s argument to argue that the governmnent ought not to redistribute wealth. In his article, Anarchy, State, and Utopia, Robert Nozick builds his argument against John Rawl’s argument in his article A Theory of Justice, going on to reject what he refers to as liberal egalitarianism and instead plumping for pure libertarianism. He derives his ideas from the ideology of Lockean that places emphasis on one’s natural rights to property, liberty, and life (Nozick 45). There is now logical manner in which these rights are liable to revocation. In this sense, any constraints or violations on the individual’s rights and liberty are immoral, especially if done without consent. Only those acts that come about through voluntary means by every party involved without infringing on the natural rights of other parties are just. In addition, those governments that aid poor citizens in wealth redistribution from those who are wealthier do so via unjust means. Indeed, these governments are upsetting the very course of action they are attempting to put in place. Wealth redistribution by the government is not a voluntary process and, as such, is not just and, therefore, must not be allowed (Nozick 50). Nozick’s ideas on libertarianism are reflective of the idea that human beings, as rational beings, should practice self-ownership. Borrowing from Immanuel Kant’s work from his article Groundwork for the Metaphysics of Morals, Nozick presents one imperative that makes necessary the idea that individuals should respect their rational nature and that of the other people. Using man as a way of satisfying the desires of other people, as well as those of oneself, is a violation of the rational nature present in humans (Nozick 71). This nature gives an individual inherent dignity, which could undergo forfeiture if this person’s only use is as a means to an end. Rational beings are able to enjoy self-ownership inclusive of their labor, abilities, abilities, talents, and body, as well as that existing as a direct result of their labor, abilities, and talents. Wealth results from the labor of an individual in accordance to the thesis of self-ownership with a person entitled to wealth for which they have labored. Wealth redistribution causes people to renounce whatever rights they held over their wealth (Nozick 72). Nozick’s entitlement theory, more specifically, argues against wealth redistribution by the government. It establishes that a person can legitimately attain ownership of property through three ways that are just. These are legitimate holdings transferred legitimately and through voluntary consent, acquiring holdings that had previous ownership, as ...Show more


Name: Instructor: Course: Date: Our Government Ought Not To Redistribute Wealth Wealth redistribution can be defined as the transfer of property or income from one set of individuals to another. The cause of this distribution is by social mechanisms that range from tort law, divorce, charity, or, in this case, welfare, monetary policies, and taxation…
Author : kenna44
In this paper, I argue that our government ought not redistribute wealth essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"In this paper, I argue that our government ought not redistribute wealth"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Check these samples - they also fit your topic

Branches of Government Paper
It was intended to prevent one person from gaining too much power which can lead to graft, corruption, abuses, nepotism and despotism (Northrup, 2003, p. 44); framers of the American Constitution were so obsessed with preventing this from happening after experiencing cruelty by absolutism under the British monarchy before gaining their independence.
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Government (social contract theory and redistribution of wealth). Chose one of them
On a larger scale, Hobbes also argue that states are also by nature guided by self-interest and destructive, thus, the necessity of a leader; the idea which I do not agree with. I did not agree with Hobbes’ argument about individuals being chaotic and miserable by default and that the basis of government is to put order upon this chaos.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Research and argue a problem/ solution or cause/effect paper
Workplace culture and alcohol availability are the greatest factors in the workplace that affect alcoholism in the workplace. Every one of us is very well acquainted with the hazardous effects of alcoholism. Job related hazards lead to poor performance at work, which may lead to poor career profile.
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
United States Historians Typically Argue that our National Experience is Defined by Either Conflict or Consensus
For democracy is nothing, but an inbuilt ability within the political setup of a nation to accommodate and assimilate varied and diverse viewpoints and aspirations.
2 pages (500 words) Essay
The current level of government regulation of business is detrimental to our economy(the first paper you wrote that was unusable)
The tools that eventually comprised this neo-liberal economic agenda included “liberalization of cross-border transactions, deregulation of market dynamics, and privatization of both asset ownership and the provision
15 pages (3750 words) Essay
Our town paper review
The story of the play is introduced through the narration of the Stage Manager, who appears off and on the play bearing a decisive role in the plot of the story. The play brings to the audience the activities of a typical American day tinted with the pantomime of the
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Government (social contract theory and redistribution of wealth). Chose one of them
I did not agree with Hobbes argument about individuals being chaotic and miserable by default and that the basis of government is to put
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
American government paper
Since the great depression African American women in the United States have struggled to earn their constitutional rights. The African Americans faced a lot of prejudice and discrimination
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Issue Paper: Our Shrinking World
Whether it is through technological advancements or people that are used to bridge the geographical gaps and ease the movements of goods and services with
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
I Was There Paper
First of all, my society’s history during the fore pointed time period can be divided into: I Dynasty (established under the king known as Scorpion II) and II Dynasty (established under the king known as Hotepsekhemui). Besides, our I Dynasty originated
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Hire a pro to write
a paper under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment