Discuss and Compare two Care Philosophers - Essay Example

Only on StudentShare

Extract of sample
Discuss and Compare two Care Philosophers

It is thus prudent to take the level of affectedness and vulnerability of other interest before responding to a situation. Carol Gilligan and Joan Tronto are among the notable feminists who have contributed to the development of this theory. Joan Tronto borrows a lot from Carol Gilligan theory who he says is mentor. This paper discusses and compares the contribution of these two philosophers (Jagger et al, 42). The first part of the essay will discuss Carol Gilligan theory of different voices and the second portion will look at Joan Tronto rewriting of the ethic care theory into a postmodern theory. Carol Gilligan was a student of Kohlberg. However, she did not agree with the Kohlberg theories on moral development in humans. He saw Kohlberg theory as being gender biased since it showed that girls’ moral development was lower compared to that of boys and this was reflected in adult men and women. She asserted that this theory was biased in the sense that it only presented a male oriented perspective. This could also be contributed by the fact that Kohlberg subject were dominated by boys. She developed a theory that incorporated a female perspective on the subject. She said that men and women respond to moral dilemma differently (Held, 26). ...
Download paper

Summary

Name Institution Instructor Course Date Comparison of two Care Philosophers: Carol Gilligan and Joan Tronto Care ethics is a group of normative ethical theories developed by feminist that measure the morality of actions depending on the response. This is unlike the deontological and consequentiality theory whose main emphasis is on impartiality and universal standards…
Author : framimonroe

Related Essays

Eastern and Western Philosophers Comparison
Aristotle and Gautama Buddha are two of the greatest ancient philosophers that the world has known. The first was born in the West and the other in the East, but both were born in the period before the birth of Christ. Aristotle is known for his theoretical ideas on morality while Gautama Buddha is associated with practical religious ideas that are aimed at attaining the ultimate state of peace and happiness. This paper discusses two doctrines that were each developed by these philosophers because of their seeming similarity to each other: Aristotle’s Doctrine of the Mean, and; Gautama...
3 pages (753 words) Essay
Compare and Contrast Two Movies
She also manages to help the man retrieve a childhood box that was full of his memories. She manages to see how the man gets moved by her actions making him shed tears. The movies are the same in the way they bring out the meaning of life. The films show us how the actors respond to whatever comes their way (Alan 15). According to Alan (15), it is true that men are fools who only realize the importance of life when faced with death. Ikiru is a story about a man, his life, family and work. Ikiru portrays the behaviors of a man that can have a positive impact and make his life till death...
3 pages (753 words) Essay
Philosophers Views on Abortion
Moreover, there should be an absolute priority to the unborn fetus' life over that of the mother. However, some people especially those who support abortion have for centuries argued that the life of a mother is superior to that of the unborn; therefore, any life that put the life of the mother at any risk should be eliminated and the mother let to live. Regardless of the counter argument on abortion, it is not right, at any point in time, to conduct abortion since it constitutes to terminate life; however, under well-argued and justified ground it may be an option to save the mother's life....
5 pages (1255 words) Case Study
two essay
Following these two arguments creates the basis of the divine command theory of morality, in which Plato argues against every other theory that beats the logic of God in that God can only condemn something because it is wrong and something is condemned by the gods because it is wrong. Plato goes disowns the theory by bringing out a logical argument based on what he believes to the truth, especially on the concept of right and wrong and their relationship with the gods. On this topic, he brings up the issue of morality and immorality and the views of the gods on it based on why an action can be...
7 pages (1757 words) Essay
Two Questions
One occasion in which Lincoln's "Gettysburg Address" reiterates this famous ruler is when he asserts, “our fathers brought forth on this continent, a new nation.” (Boritt 1). Similarly, Pericles started his speech in this way when he claimed, “I shall began by speaking about our ancestors.” (Halsall 34). Another instance is when Lincoln claims, “we cannot consecrate -we cannot hallow-this ground. The brave men, living and dead, who struggled here, have consecrated it.” (Boritt 1). This is also evident in Pericles speech when he argues that the people being honored have proved...
3 pages (753 words) Essay
Perfect City in Plato's view, with the philosophers and guardians and the working class and how they all work together.
It is far from monarchy which a child of king or queen automatically becomes a ruler by birth right. From this this philosophical thought comes the social and economic stratification which are meant to forge social solidarity in the ideal state (Silvermintz 762) In stratifying, Plato did not discriminate people by birth but by capability and will of who should rule and exercise political power over a state. , "philosophers [must] become kings…or those now called kings [must]…genuinely and adequately philosophize" (The Republic 5). Plato put so much emphasis on the philosopher king or the...
5 pages (1255 words) Research Paper
Comparing the differences of purpose of government according to Philosophers. (Plato, Aristotle, Hobbes, and Locke)
Some of the difficulties that society in the classical period faced are the same as what society experience today. For example, the question on whether to have a democratic, aristocratic, tyrannical or oligarchy was handled by in the classical period by Aristotle yet the same question still presents when discussing modern forms of governments. Thus, it is true to say that philosophers of classical period and modern philosophers are still faced with the same question on what is the purpose of the government and how does the government exercise its powers. According to Plato’s idea of an ideal...
5 pages (1255 words) Term Paper
Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you! Try us!