How Dretske responds to Chisholm's claim that intentionality cannot be naturalized - Essay Example

Only on StudentShare

Extract of sample
How Dretske responds to Chisholm's claim that intentionality cannot be naturalized

Chisholm argued that intentionality cannot be naturalized because of the numerous influencing factors that surround us. According to Locke Chisholm argued that for every decision we make there must be a factor that influences or alters a person’s needs or will. He further argued that every decision we make is based on the fact that we must take the path to be comfortable. According to Chisholm factors affecting a person’s intent may also be psychological. This also denies the possibility that intentionality can be natural. To naturalize intentionality Chisholm argued that there must be absolutely free will in an action. In his argument need and wants of the people does not allow what individuals do to be natural. For instance, a person’s need for food, shelter and clothing makes ones intention to acquire the commodities an artificial intent. In this scenario, the intent can only be natural if one could survive without food and still have the intent and urge to acquire the commodity. ...
Download paper

Summary

Intentionality is defined as the ability of an individual to have a free will to make their own decisions and indulge in activities at their own consent. Intentionality is viewed as the personal democracy where an individual reacts or thinks depending on their views and preferences…
Author : nschaden

Related Essays

The Question of Clones Term Paper
The author of the essay "The Question of Clones" defines human cloning is the concept of creating genetically identical copies of a human being through artificial means. Although the idea had been a serious area of discussion for scientists since the 1960s, it was not until 1997 that the debate truly took off with the birth of Dolly, the world’s first successfully cloned sheep and proof that recreating an entire creature from a piece of tissue was possible. Dolly’s successful birth fuelled intense debate as it became clear that clones were no longer restricted to the realm of science...
10 pages (2510 words) Term Paper
Discussion about the human life
Destruction of human life is a consequence of reckless and irresponsible driving amongst many drivers. When people get deployed, sacked or fail to pass their final exams, we get irritated but at least our lives are not endangered. When we are on the road, however, irresponsible motor vehicle drivers are more than irritating: They put our lives at risk and many of us have witnessed careless, reckless, incompetent drivers exchanging lanes, not observing road signs and traffic lights. For example nearly or hitting down pedestrians in a pedestrian crossing. A number of bills to regulate proper use...
3 pages (753 words) Essay
Kant essay
Time was of the essence as the woman’s condition continued to deteriorate despite the application of certain remedial measures. According to standard practice, the doctors required the assent of the next of kin in order to perform the dangerous experiment. After several futile attempts to contact the family members, the doctors decided to proceed with the abortion with the intention of rescuing the life of the mother. The operation went on successfully as the fetus was aborted. However, both the woman and her family members expressed their disappointment in the loss of the child and vowed to...
4 pages (1004 words) Essay
The Question of God
Lewis, on the other hand, was an atheist for the first couple of years of his life. Lewis wrote he was so angry with God for failing to exist in this world. I was also equally angry with Him for creating a world in which creatures have a burden of existence imposed on them without their consent. Freud and Lewis were both haunted during all their lives by a strong yearning with no easily familiar object. Freud referred to the transcendent longing as Sehnsucht and Lewis called his Joy. Freud, however, was an atheist, he saw in human existence a desire for projection and illusion, while Lewis on...
4 pages (1004 words) Research Paper
three short essay questions
In such a state, government has no rights to deny its citizens the rights to do anything. Citizens are free to do anything and at any time. They are allowed to access any material and use any property so long as it does not affect anyone. The government in such a state has no rights to tax its citizens and to restrict its citizens from doing any form of business or activity. Nozick advocates for such a state and says it has respects for a person's moral rights (Wolterstorff & Cuneo 89). The next state is the welfare state where citizens are the source of the political will, and they are given...
3 pages (753 words) Essay
three question
To protect their property and themselves, individuals may assent to a contractual affiliation whereby they unite themselves in an alliance for the good of all. Through channels of this pledged relationship, persons concur to accept different duties or responsibilities in return for the gains provided by communal cooperation. A democracy may be started on the base of a mutual pledge between community, and each person, in which society has a responsibility to every person and each person has a responsibility to society. For Locke, the natural justice will set the restrictions and provide the way...
4 pages (1004 words) Essay
Why is Locke concerned with the question whether our terms for substances are terms for items with a real essence
Subsequently, he pragmatically thought over the concept of knowledge and language formulation, the core of which shall be discussed hereunder.
...
6 pages (1506 words) Essay
Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you! Try us!