StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Biocentric Egalitarianism and Land Ethic - Term Paper Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
Biocentric Egalitarianism and Land Ethic

Biocentric egalitarianism advocates for the respect of non-human beings based on moral principles and values. These views reflect similar arguments that humans depend on nature to survive and thus the earth would be a better place without humans (Jonge 23). However, a critical analysis suggests that the moral duty to respect nature can conflict other moral duties. Kantian Moral Philosophy One example where duty to respect can conflict other moral duties is the application of Kant’s theory about animal rights. Kantian moral philosophy asserts that animals are mere instruments, which may be used for human purpose (Korsgaard 3). According Korsgaard, Kant’s point of view about legal rights is not to protect human interests, but to enable each citizen to act justly and for what is good. Kant’s moral philosophy underlines that non-rational animals lack the kind of freedom that rights protect. In particular, it is because human beings are rational beings that they are able to choose how they want to live (5). However, Kant’s philosophy extends the rights held by human beings to include property rights. According to Kant we have the moral obligation to claim property including animals, and the legal status of such animals is the direct correlate of their moral status as mere means (instruments) (5). Further, according to Kant, we have no moral duty to animals. In contrast, biocentrism upholds the need to make moral consideration towards non-human species. From this perspective, the conflict between Kant’s moral philosophy and the duty to respect nature as maintained by non-anthropocentric ethical position remains apparent with regard to animal rights. To resolve the conflict between Kant’s theory and biocentrism regarding animal rights, it is important to address the interpretation problems associated with the humanity formula. This is especially because faced with such a situation would require one to decide to follow the humanity formulary as applied by Kant or to stick with the rationality formulary defined in biocentrism. Libertarianism Another example of a conflict between non-anthropocentric ethical position about duty to respect nature and other moral duties is the issue of ‘forest justice’ as seen in the lenses of libertarianism. According to libertarianism, forests and indeed biodiversity, has value only to the extent that it contributes to the expansion of individual freedom (Holsinka 3). The ‘forest justice’ can be illustrated by attempts by governments to transfer property rights to local communities to enable them benefit from forest resources. In anthropocentric ethical philosophy, human beings are viewed as separate identities based on self-interest and altruistic humanism. According to Kopnina, anthropocentrism grants intrinsic value to human beings. On the other hand, biocentrism emphasizes on the intrinsic value for ecosystems including humans, plant and animal species. This disconnect represents a broader inconsistency within the fields of environmental conservation. The main concern is that support for environmental conservation appears to be motivated by utilitarian and instrumental ethics. Just like biodiversity, we place value on forests because we think we might need it, we like it or we ought to. Non-anthropocentric ethical position would emphasize on the instrumental value of forests-that ...Show more

Summary

Institution Date Biocentric Egalitarianism and Land Ethic Biocentrism holds that we recognize and value non-human beings in our moral considerations. One of the questions facing biocentric egalitarianism is whether we should uphold consideration of moral duty to respect nature or whether we should allow this consideration to be overridden when faced with unavoidable need to exploit nature…
Author : doylelilliana
Biocentric Egalitarianism and Land Ethic essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the term paper on your topic
"Biocentric Egalitarianism and Land Ethic"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

Eminent Domain and the Taking of Private Land by Governmental Entity
The frequent references to property rights in Florida’s constitutions indicates that property rights are among the “most strongly protected of all rights”. 1 To begin with the right to “acquire, possess and protect property” is an inalienable right.2 It was stated in Dade County v.
25 pages (6250 words) Term Paper
Ford or Apple Code of Ethics- Business ethic paper
Purpose: Apple Inc. Code of Ethics will; - Define acceptable behavior - Promote high standards of practice - Provide benchmarks for all members for their growth and development - Establish a framework for professional behavior and responsibilities - Serve as a vehicle for occupational identity - Serve as a grade for attaining occupational maturity (B Corporation) Apple Inc.
12 pages (3000 words) Term Paper
Compare and Contrast the Ethic of Care and the Ethic of Justice
However, before anything else, it is important to define ethics of care and ethics of justice. Ethics of care defined Society is always looking forward to emphasizing rules, justice and fairness, but there is another important issues and this particularly involve the ethics which engaged care.
12 pages (3000 words) Term Paper
Effect Of Women Serving In The Military On Mens Work Ethic
The fields of work life which require more physical exertions and body stability to perform the tasks were firstly not associated with women. Yet, if we look closely, the women's involvement in the military has long been established and different countries have accepted their role and success in military operations for about 5000 years now.
6 pages (1500 words) Term Paper
Case study-bp struggles to resolve sustainability disaster-Ethic paper
There was an unabated flow of crude for about three months in the Gulf of Mexico and daily over 53,000 barrels of oil polluted the Gulf of Mexico affecting the estuaries, beaches, wetlands and the habitat of the adjoining areas. Over 200 sq km area near the Deepwater Horizon oil rig where the disaster took place was declared ‘kill zone’ by the experts because it has damaged the ecosystem of the region and the death rate of the living species of the region multiplied several times.
6 pages (1500 words) Term Paper
Alexnder Nevsky: the defender of the Russian land
Alexander rose to prominence and fame mainly on account of his military savvy, the most famous being the battle on Ice on the frozen lake Peipus. He was also famous for controversially accepting to pay tribute to the Golden Horde (Life of St. Alexander Nevsky).
7 pages (1750 words) Term Paper
Assignment 1 week 2:A New Work Ethic
Money is their only goal. They do not foresee themselves working for the establishment for a long time and growing with it. There is no motivation to exert extra effort to get the job done well. These
3 pages (750 words) Term Paper
Case study-bp struggles to resolve sustainability disaster-Ethic paper
There was an unabated flow of crude for about three months in the Gulf of Mexico and daily over 53,000 barrels of oil polluted the Gulf of Mexico affecting the estuaries, beaches, wetlands and the habitat of
6 pages (1500 words) Term Paper
Ethic Diversity in China
It is true that the China’s neoliberal process poses political, social, and economic impacts on the ethnic minority groups in the country. The present paper aims at explaining the impacts of
7 pages (1750 words) Term Paper
A PROBLEM IN LAND-USE PLANNING ABOUT THE STRIP MINING AND POWER-RELATED USE OF LIGNITE
Environmentalists when viewing the mining sector, have a common worry of ‘acid mine drainage’; especially concerning strip mining. The aspect is informed by the
10 pages (2500 words) Term Paper
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation