Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you! Try us!

Assessment of Plato's two arguments about knowledge in the Meno and the Phaedo - Term Paper Example

Undergraduate
Author : nicolaselsie
Term Paper
Philosophy
Pages 5 (1255 words)
Download 2

Summary

Name Instructor Course no. Date Deliberating on knowledge according to Plato’s Phaedo and Meno, respectively, the term “knowledge” lacks the one definition that encompasses in totality what knowledge is and what it entails. Philosophers have, for a long time, been at task to find the one definition that would cover knowledge completely, but that definition is still elusive…

Extract of sample
Assessment of Plato's two arguments about knowledge in the Meno and the Phaedo

In both Meno and Phaedo, knowledge and learning are viewed as a recollection of what someone already knows. However, in Meno, Plato writes that knowledge is concerned with the recollection of necessary truths. In Phaedo, on the other hand, knowledge, according to Plato, is concerned with the acquisition of concepts, which are not necessarily truths (102b-c). In essence, Phaedo tries to imply that a person can gain knowledge simply by learning new concepts based on their individual opinions. The subject of debate in this essay is whether either form of knowledge can be independent of the other. Can a person claim to have knowledge about a subject by simply recalling some prior truths, or can a person learn new concepts based on a recollection of prior opinions? The idea of recollection or anamnesis, according to Plato, holds that if at all a person remembers something, they must have had prior knowledge of the subject (73c). Plato, in Phaedo writes that the fact that a person can hear or see something and recognize it, and even think of something alike, is all based on anamnesis (74c). In Phaedo, Plato gives an example of knowledge through recognition by stating that a person may see a lyre that reminds them of their lover (73c-e). ...
Download paper

Related Essays

Discuss the role of wisdom in true virtue according to Meno and the Phaedo
In Phaedo, it is contended that when alive, the soul should try to control pleasures related with the sense organs and body in which it is rebuked to be animate and from which it seeks to liberate itself.Phaedo makes distinction between souls that are not liberated. Some who are used to ‘violence’ and ‘extreme sensuality’ takes the form of likes of an ‘ass’ or’ wolf.’ However, for someone seeking liberation, even such gentle forms making eligible for some earthly happiness is not acceptable.A unique concept of good and evil is put forward in Phaedo. The author discounts…
3 pages (753 words)
Plato's Meno Research Paper
One very significant part of the Meno is that which demonstrates the Theory of Recollection, or the idea that “what appears to be learning something new is really recollecting something already known” (Cohen, University of Washington), or what is known as the doctrine of anamnesis, which means that “all learning is [merely] recollection” (Samet, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy). This theory is what Socrates exactly proves to Meno when the latter asks, “…on what lines will you look, Socrates, for a thing of whose nature you know nothing at all?” (Plato, Meno, 80d2). The…
6 pages (1506 words)
Explain Plato's Method of Finding True Knowledge in Meno
His metaphysics speaks about his insight on theory of knowledge. He says that there are two worlds namely a world of opinion and world of permanence also called a world of true knowledge. He says that knowledge is possible through reason. True knowledge means reason elevated to the level of consciousness. Plato argues in the Meno that knowledge is innate. An illiterate slave-person is able to demonstrate knowledge of geometry and arithmetic. What is latent is simply invoked by teaching. Answer 2. Descartes methods of finding true knowledge stress emphasis on creating methodological doubt and…
3 pages (753 words)
Reality and Knowledge in Plato's Myth of the Cave
Therefore, analyzing philosophic ideas of the rationalists and empiricists, dualists and monists, idealists, materialists and pragmatists begins with perception or rejection of Plato’s ideas of reality and knowledge. The expression that philosophy is a footnote to Plato does not necessarily mean that the philosophers continue Platonic traditions or agree with Plato’s ideas. However, in my opinion, it is Plato who we think of first when we start dealing with philosophic issues. The tendency to incline to the ideas regarding the nature of knowledge and reality can be found in thinking of…
6 pages (1506 words)
Plato's Meno and Thomas Aquinas on "Justice" in the text Four Cardinal Virtues
In light of the above, Plato pointed to virtue as being a benefit to the social order and helpful to both the individual and the society (Rist 89). On the other hand, Socrates had the view that every individual has the rationality of doing right and no one can harm another while in his or her right mind. Moreover, Aquinas text on justice in the Four Cardinal Virtues point to justice as being a component of virtue. Justice aims at correcting the wrong doers in the society in a bid to make the societal order friendlier for human inhabitance. The process of applying justice involves forms of…
3 pages (753 words)
The arguments that Socrates provides of the immortality of the soul in the book "Phaedo" by Plato
Introduction: An expository claim of immortality of the soul upon death 3. Arguments in support of the claim; A. The opposite argument B. The “theoretic argument of recollection” C. The “affinity argument” D. The argument is that relating to “form of life.” 4. Conclusion. Abstract The purpose of this paper is to provide readers with a critical thinking about Socrates’ presupposition of the “morality of the soul.” The paper is premised on the claim that human soul is separated from the body by death and this separation is affected by a philosopher’s practice of death. In…
8 pages (2008 words)
The Phaedo
Those enemies would be a life wasted on the pursuit of pleasure at the expense of pain (pleasure withdrawn). This very duality of life, according to Socrates, is the bane of existence for all of mankind.…
4 pages (1004 words)