[Name of Student] [Name of Professor] [Course] [Date] Reading Response Would a U.S. war against Al-Qaeda in Yemen have been morally justified if Umar Farouk Abdulmutallab had successfully carried out his plot to blow up a passenger jet over Detroit on December 25, 2009?…
Since the war against terrorism has begun, the US has been targeting one country after another by claiming that Al-Qaeda has strong networks within these countries. Afghanistan was one such target. The US has waged a war against Afghanistan for years. This war continues to destroy the natural landscape of the country as the country is frequently bombed. This not only destroys the plants and animals residing in the area but also the innocent lives. According to Boyle, war on terrorism is justified on the grounds that terrorists have been killing innocent lives with their activities. Also these terrorists instigate fear among the people to such extent that they cannot resume their daily activities without fear for their lives or that of their children (Boyle, 156). If the US war against terrorism is justified on these grounds, then this raises a Catch-22. For the US to fight war in Afghanistan, it is committing also committing these activities. They have been killing innocent children and women on the same grounds. I do not argue here that Al-Qaeda has developed networks in that particular country. I only argue that US is committing acts that the country condemns internationally. In his article, Boyle brings forward three justified reasons for waging war. These principles have been developed by St. Augustine and elaborated further by St. Thomas Acquinas. These conditions include proper authority, just cause and right intention (Boyle, 155). The proper authority has been delegated on the US through two reasons. Firstly, it is the people of America that have been repeatedly been the target of such terrorists attacks, especially that of the 9/11 that killed millions of innocent lives and destroyed equal number of families directly or indirectly. The authority has also been provided to the US through international bodies such as the UN. While the agree that the people of US have been greatly harmed with terrorists attacks, I do not agree that UN has the authority to give America the power to invade other countries. This is because international organizations such as the UN have been found to favor the interest of their member countries such as US and Britain. When the US wanted permission to access Iran on the grounds of nuclear weapon concealment, UN granted this permission. Did the UN have the right to grant permission to the US which was already a nuclear power itself? The US has bombed Hiroshima and Nagaski and these areas are still impacted by the nuclear attack even after all this years. Therefore, it is ironic that US would be allowed to check for nuclear power possibilities in Iran. Here I bring to light the third condition presented by St. Augustine. This condition allowed for war on the basis of right intention. What is right intention, I would argue. Who decides what the right intention is? The US has always been concerned regarding the activities of foreign countries. They have involved themselves in the affairs of other countries to such an extent that their wars become our wars. What is the intention of the US in this case? Are they making sure that no other country gains the power that they currently enjoy? Since US is a country that is more concerned of its own security, economy and people, I do not think that it has great concerns of the security, economy and people of some other country. It is obvious in the way that they treated ...
Cite this document
(“Reading response Book Report/Review Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.net/philosophy/95151-reading-response
(Reading Response Book Report/Review Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
“Reading Response Book Report/Review Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.net/philosophy/95151-reading-response.
The other argument focuses on perception of essentialist and constructionist regarding sexuality. The article also explores a discussion of Bronislaw Malinowski regarding sexuality; in fact, this discussion focuses in the theoretical configuration of sexuality that is considered to be an intrinsic feature in human beings (Lofstrom, 3).
Being based on English history, the article provided a sound reflection of their impression the British rule laid on the cultural aspects of African and Asian nations. This particular line depicts the way
Both cases assessed by the Supreme Court were pertaining to the application of citizenship through neutralization. This article not only concentrates on the findings presented by the case but also largely assesses the arguments within the cases and connects the information
Barthe’s aims is to fabricate a completely customized framework; a framework that is quite different from the previous and already existing accounts of photos and their representation wherein the photography can be
He points out that increased regulation could affect both new and traditional media outlets for advertising. Moreover, the tendency of politicians and regulatory activist groups to attack advertisers has existed since the late 1970’s. The concerns of
Expansion of the music took place majorly in European cities of Paris, Vienna and London (Bashford, 01). Middle class members of the cities’ societies became fond of the musical style, and engaged in massive purchased of musical instruments for
A singular story ends up with so many twists that a reader is lost in another tale while still in the first tale. The complexity of the plots makes it difficult to make a thematic analysis. Even so, her psychological approach
2 Pages(500 words)Book Report/Review
GOT A TRICKY QUESTION? RECEIVE AN ANSWER FROM STUDENTS LIKE YOU!
Let us find you another Book Report/Review on topic Reading response for FREE!