StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Should the EU focus on acting as a civilian, normative or military power - Essay Example

Nobody downloaded yet

Extract of sample
Should the EU focus on acting as a civilian, normative or military power

Before answering the question whether the EU should focus on being a civilian, normative, or military power, it is important to establish how these different forms of power have historically manifested in the EU's policies and activities. Conceptualising the terms 'civilian', 'normative', and 'military' is important in any analysis where these terms are used to describe the activities of EU's. Maull's (1990) view of a civilian power includes the employment of "solidarity with other societies, and a sense of responsibility for the future of the world - and particularly the global environment". (p.106) It is important to note that Maull's analysis of the exercise of civilian power is quite restrictive as it relates to the state or the exercise of national civilian power. Thus using a 'statist' perspective of the exercise of civilian power in the context of a supranational EU, would have its possible limitations. Vital lessons can, however, be drawn from his analysis and can be transposed into the EU's experience. Manner's (2002) conception of the EU as a civilian power is interpreted primarily in economic terms. Simply put, civilian power can be said to be the exercise of non-military power and would include "economic, diplomatic and cultural policy instruments." (Smith, n.d. p.1) Smith's conception of civilian power would thus exclude any use of the military, even if the military were used in situations of peace-keeping, whether armed or unarmed. To Smith (n.d.) even though the military can be used in unarmed peace-keeping situations, they have also been trained to kill and thus such an activity cannot be said to be civilian. Smith (n.d.) further identifies four core elements in the exercise of civilian power - "means; ends; use of persuasion; and civilian control over foreign (and defence) policymaking". (p.2) Consequently, in employing civilian policies, the means and the ends of those policies must be non-military, with persuasion (and not coercion) being the main instruments of achieving policy objectives. Based on the above conception of civilian power, Smith (n.d.) has argued in relation to the EU that: " clinging to the notion of civilian power EU not only stretches the term 'civilian' past its breaking point, but also tends to induce excessively rosy-eyed views of the EU as an international actor. 'Civilian' often means 'good', and deploying the 'civilian power EU' argument can close down critical analysis of actual EU foreign policy activities". (p.1) With regards to concepts of normative power, Manners (2002) views the EU's normative power as its capacity to mould or influence notions of what constitutes 'normal' in politics at the international arena. This exercise of normative power is very evident in the EU's relationship with Africa. The Council of the European Union has for instance stated that "Europe has a strong interest in a peaceful, prosperous and democratic Africa. Our strategy is intended to help Africa achieve this."  ...Show more

Summary

This essay will attempt to address pertinent issues that flows from the EU’s burgeoning role in European and in international affairs. Is the leverage that the EU wields one of a civilian, normative, or military power? Should the EU focus on any particular one of these powers?…
Author : schinnerrachell
Should the EU focus on acting as a civilian, normative or military power essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Should the EU focus on acting as a civilian, normative or military power"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Check these samples - they also fit your topic

Diplomacy And the International System
The essay will explore issues of foreign policy related to the use of national armies in international peace, reconstruction, and conflict operations as an extension of EU policy within the context of political dissent. Finally, the essay will analyze the difference between qualified majority voting and universal consensus as it relates to Lisbon requirements on foreign policy decisions and the use of military force by the European Union.
15 pages (3750 words) Essay
How far has the EU been effective as an international actor
The EU has been of great importance in defining the direction taken by most of the world policies and decisions in the most effective way such that they always set precedence in their decisions. It has always worked as the political object in matters of international politics and largely affects the diplomacy in all corners of the globe.
14 pages (3500 words) Essay
The EU should have remained a civilian power. Discuss
The view of European Union (EU) being a civilian power has gained significant considerations and this has certainly led to animated deliberations since its inception, whereby often the concept of civilian power has been used to define and designate the role of EU as an actor in the international politics.
8 pages (2000 words) Essay
Principal challenges of EU enlargement. Case study of Turkey
However, its invasion of Cyprus in 1974 and a 1980 military coup d’etat made relations between Europe and Turkey less than cordial. Twenty years
12 pages (3000 words) Essay
To what extent has the development of the European Security and Defence Policy (ESDP) made the European Union (EU) a strategic actor
During the last fifty years a system of European security has been changed dramatically. The process of changes involved a participation of various
8 pages (2000 words) Essay
Diplomacy and the international system
ublic leadership positions that represent the EU officially, creating the possibility that the sectarian issues that have divided European politics traditionally could result in factionalism under the new structure. This essay will first look at the leadership of the EU that
14 pages (3500 words) Essay
Theoretical approaches and EU as an international actor
The subject matter of international relations is purely infinite, ranging from war, population change, global warming, the war on terror, unequal development, international organizations like the EU and the changes in power between china and the United States. The aspect of IR has become an aspect of political science.
8 pages (2000 words) Essay
EU as an International Actor
The aspect of IR has become an aspect of political science. The two world wars and the cold war resulted due to the existence of certain phenomena like war, diplomacy, the balance of power, the several implications of sovereignty, international law and strategy that were insufficiently treated elsewhere in the social sciences.
12 pages (3000 words) Essay
Which of the following theoretical approaches offers the most convincing account of the power of the EU as an international actor: Realism; Liberalism or Constructivism
The two world wars and the cold war resulted due to existence of certain phenomena like war, diplomacy, the balance of power, the several
10 pages (2500 words) Essay
A critical evaluation of normative power EU
For example, many researchers examined the EU as a “transformative” power (Leonard, 2005), a “post-modern power” (Cooper, 2003)¸ a “civilian power” (Telo, 2007), an “ethical power” (Aggestam 2008), a “soft power”
15 pages (3750 words) Essay
Hire a pro to write
a paper under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment
Contact Us