StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Comparative Approach in the Study of Politics - Essay Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
Comparative Approach in the Study of Politics

The linkage between constitutionalism and political culture is not always directed, fixed, or clear, however it depends upon which method of comparison is adopted. While studying comparative approach the unubiquitous issue present now a days is the political comparison of umpteen countries, which most closely approximates the experimental method of science. This comparison is particularly suited to quantitative analysis through measurement and analysis of aggregate data collected on many countries (Lijphart 1971). Although there are examples of qualitative comparisons of such countries, like Huntington's (1996) The Clash of Civilizations and Finer's (1997) History of Government, the majority of studies that compare many countries simultaneously use quantitative methods. This method of comparison requires a higher level of abstraction in its specification of concepts in order to include as many countries as possible. (Landman, 2003) Its main advantages include statistical control to rule out rival explanations, extensive coverage of countries along with its political circumstances, the ability to make strong inferences, and the identification of 'deviant' countries or 'outliers'.
Comparing many countries is referred to as 'variable-oriented', since its primary focus is on general dimensions of macro-social variation (Ragin, 1994) and the relationship between variables at a global level of analysis. The extensive coverage of countries allows for stronger inferences and theory building, since a given relationship can be demonstrated to exist with a greater degree of certainty. For example, Gurr (1968) demonstrates that levels of civil conflicts across 114 countries are positively related to the presence of economic, political, short-term, and long-term deprivation. His analysis also explains that this relationship holds for roughly 65 per cent of the countries. More recently, Helliwell (1994) has shown that for 125 countries from 1960-1985 there is a positive relationship between per capita levels of income and democracy. After controlling for the differences between OECD countries, Middle Eastern oil-producing countries, Africa, and Latin America, this relationship is demonstrated to hold for about 60 per cent of the countries.
A second advantage of comparing many countries lies in the ability to identify so-called 'deviant' countries. These are countries whose values on the dependent variable are different than expected, given the values on the independent variables (levels of deprivation or per capita income). In testing for the positive relationship between income inequality and political violence in sixty countries, Muller and Seligson (1987) use a simple scatter plot to identify which countries fit their theory and which do not. For example, Brazil, Panama, and Gabon were found to have a lower level of political violence than was expected for the relatively high level of income inequality. On the other hand, the UK was found to have a particularly high level of political violence given its relatively low level of income inequality. By identifying these 'outliers', scholars can look for other explanations that account for their deviance, and they can remove them from their analysis to make more accurate predictions for the remaining countries. (Landman, 2003) ...Show more

Summary

A comparative approach enables us to think towards the circumstances where there is an absence of a favorable political environment. In such conditions any institutional design is inadequate for the development of the constitutional state as well as other democratic institutions…
Author : devenbradtke
Comparative Approach in the Study of Politics essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Comparative Approach in the Study of Politics"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

Comparative Politics - Essay 1
But the way that these two governments go about is completely different. Although both countries follow a pattern of democracy but both patterns are majorly unrelated and in few respects opposite from each other. Whatever one may say about the imperfections in the democratic systems of these nations but people from both nations have their own wishes, inclinations and interest which dictates their style of government; a fact that one cannot change.
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Comparative Politics
Political scientists consider it as the domination of few people on the economic resources of the country. This situation is workable in those countries where majority do not have an interest to participate in the democratic process of the country. There are many examples of elitist theory which can be discussed.
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Comparative Politics
Political scientists consider it as the domination of few people on the economic resources of the country. This situation is workable in those countries where majority do not have an interest to participate in the democratic process of the country. There are many examples of elitist theory which can be discussed.
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Behavioralism in Comparative Politics
It can be studies on the basis of Marxism or Socialism, historical approach or Legalistic one. The understanding of political phenomenon depends on the set of interrelated concepts to interpret the world. These concepts are not objective realities but analytical tools.
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Comparative Politics
Comparative politics is the way of comparing various forms of governments, administrations, states and ideologies that support them. There are several approaches that are useful in Comparative Politics and the major ones amongst them are the Normative Approach and the Empirical Approach.
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Behavioralism in Comparative Politics
According to the report the understanding of political phenomenon depends on the set of interrelated concepts to interpret the world. These concepts are not objective realities but analytical tools. That is why researchers give a great attention to the assumptions that underlie their approach to the subjects.
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Politics
It is an observation that in the past years, most of the scholars and experts (Hyneman, pp. 11-12, 2003) have focused on the matter of politics, rather than the methodology of its study that plays a crucial role in acquiring quality matter on
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Comparative Politics Midterm Essay
As Mark Kesselman and other authors observe, “....political science is particularly concerned with the study of power: how it is gained, lost, used, abused, organized, distributed, and
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Modern Classics of Comparative Politics (SEE INSTRUCTIONS)
The kind of political system or structure that a particular government adopts depends on very many factors that are present in that particular nation. For instance, demographic, environmental and even cultural factors influence,
12 pages (3000 words) Essay
RESPONSE PAPER for Comparative Politics class
In regard to what has been learnt in class and the news article, state-society relations show that the nature of political settlement in a country can have a great impact upon state-society relations as will be discussed in this paper. State-society relation is
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation