StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

The Constitution - Thesis Example

Nobody downloaded yet

Extract of sample
The Constitution

He further contends that many were disenfranchised and discriminated by the common law and thus were not represented in the Convention during its drafting which included countless adult males. In addition, most of the states at that time imposed property qualifications on the voters and consequently barred non-taxpayers. As most of the members of the conventions were lawyers and representatives of personalty, these individuals were 1'directly and personally interested in the outcome of their labors' and would economically benefit from the passage of the Constitution (Beard 59). Furthermore, Beard asserts that since these men were mostly merchants, shippers, bankers, speculators, and private and public securities holders, the Constitution was not crafted by 'the whole people.'
Beard's assertions remained undisputed until 1956 when Robert Brown's critique titled Charles Beard and the Constitution: A Critical Analysis of An Economic Interpretation of the Constitution dispels and attacks Beard's thesis and conclusions for their lack of merit. Brown, attacking Beard's objectivity, argues that Beard failed to collect compelling data and evidence to support his contentions. In his critique, Brown scrutinizes the support for the Constitution among diverse economic and social divisions, the democratic character of the country, and the franchise within the states in eighteenth-century America. He holds that Beard was misguided and further added that, eighteenth-century America was democratic, the franchise was common, and there was extensive backing for the Constitution, alleging that his evidence contradicts Beard's arguments about the lack of democracy and the insubstantial support for the Constitution. According to Brown, since the Founding Fathers upheld the Federal voting system done by indirect representation, the ratification of the Constitution was a democratic process and everyone's interests were aptly represented. Brown further argues that the constitution was not merely an economic document in which property was protected but it also stressed safeguards to life and liberty. This protection of property, Brown adds, is also essential to the protection of the individual and liberty.
A close scrutiny of the US Constitution is necessary in order to resolve this conflict as the issue has its precedence in the Constitution itself. The textbook, 'We The People,' states that the charter 2'attempts to create a government that would be strong to protect commerce and property rights yet weak enough to threaten individual liberty.' The statement strengthens Brown's contentions that the provisions governing the protection of property are significant parts of the constitution. The Constitution also emphasizes that that the framers, 3'feared the call of equality' which could result to equal allotment of property, and consequently violate the freedom of property owners. Although Beard is right with his assertions that the economic interests of the framers and those who represented the public were given utmost importance, the focus on economic interests and rights to property as well as protection of those rights fortified individual freedom. It is also important to note that these economic interpretations of the ...Show more

Summary

The argument that the creation of the Constitution was a conflict founded on competing economic and financial interests by two groups of individuals - those who expected to gain benefits from its approval and those who oppose its ill-effects - was pioneered by Charles A…
Author : ottis25
The Constitution essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the thesis on your topic
"The Constitution"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Check these samples - they also fit your topic

Martin Luther King: How he Changed Politics in America
Words spoken by King have become quotes in the elementary and secondary schools and various lectures. Surveys made in 2004-2005 have revealed that King was the only most famous of the “famous Americans” not president.
16 pages (4000 words) Thesis
Psychological Factors of Crime and Constitutional Criminal Procedure
The paper will discuss the means and efforts taken up by individuals in the society to inflict pain on the people.The first part of the paper which talks about the psychological factors affecting crime. The objective understand the causes which lead to the commitment of crime in the society.
20 pages (5000 words) Thesis
Eighth amendment of the US constitution
The research will attempt to address the primary question framed as follows: Does eighth amendment of the US constitution prohibit the death penalty altogether even on committing atrocious crimes or there exists any validity of the imposition of the same for killing, abusing, raping or doing any type of a heinous crime against the other individual(s) deliberately?
3 pages (750 words) Thesis
Gun control does not reduce violence
Indeed violence is a social malady that needs to be eradicated. It is a mark of barbarism and modern society should strive to remove it from its practice and consciousness to become truly civilized. Violence takes many forms from assault to life and property, to simple bullying that uses brute force to assert its will over another. s.
15 pages (3750 words) Thesis
Constitution
citizen certain fundamental liberties and rights. With regard to criminal procedures, the foremost of these rights is the assumption of innocence. Though not explicitly written into the Constitution, this presumption has been interpreted by several court rulings as implied in the Eighth and Fifth Amendments.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
What China Can Learn from Switzerland
The Chinese government has come a long way from its darker days in the eighties where the country had been grappling with an oppressive regime. Switzerland may not be perfect in this but China could emulate the Swiss government’s commitment to fighting corruption. Switzerland was ranked as one of the most accountable countries around the globe.
12 pages (3000 words) Thesis
Those who would give up freedoms for temporary security deserve neither, civil right violations
The civil rights movement in 1948 when president Truman signed Executive Order 9981 that provide equal treatment to all soldiers serving in the military represents the most
4 pages (1000 words) Thesis
Prejudice against Muslims students in their schools,colleges and universities that effects their grades.The thesis would involve the various factors and the ways in which the students are being troubled and how it forces them to rethink their education in
In this regard, both American Muslims and Muslim international students have had their share of prejudice in the past, with the extent of such prejudices depending on the state, the level of education, and the diversity of the
4 pages (1000 words) Thesis
Come up with a research topic
e is a trend towards local laws and practice that encourages harassment directed at a certain class of migrants who come to the United States, particularly migrants from Latin America (Segura and Zavella 3; Garcia 94). These are directly linked to the anti-immigration laws that
2 pages (500 words) Thesis
Immigration: 1900- Dream Act
The legislation was frequently executed and implemented at federal and state levels in the wake of the consecutive flow of immigration witnessed by the populations belonging to diverse geographical zones and regions of the globe to the Unites States of America
50 pages (12500 words) Thesis
Hire a pro to write
a paper under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment