Plato and Rousseaus Commentary on Constitutional Breakdown - Essay Example

Only on StudentShare

Extract of sample
Plato and Rousseaus Commentary on Constitutional Breakdown

Plato thus emphasized that democracy, just like oligarchy, draws a rift between the rich and the poor (Rosen, 2008). With the perceiving the rich as plotting against them, they seek protection through rallying their support behind a champion. With the increasing support of the mob, such a champion is likely to turn into a tyrant. For Plato, the law ought to be a defining factor for all the actions of individuals within a certain jurisdiction and that people have to lose their freedom for the sake of gaining peace and harmony. To prevent degeneration of the constitution, Plato postulates that the law has to become the master of the government and the government to be its slave, so that every person is answerable to the law. In addition, Plato suggests that for a constitution to be effective then the government should be run by the best (aristocratic), so that the leaders are highly wise and that they receive proper training concerning how a state should be run.
Contrary to Plato’s view, Rousseau believes that constitutions that fail to recognize the individual moral responsibility of the citizens is bound to degenerate with time. As such, for any constitutional coercions to be justified, they must be based on certain general agreements among the citizens. Rousseau observed that constitutional governments were driven by an assumption that citizens within a given state, regardless of their divisions in terms of personal opinions, remain firmly in agreement concerning the desire to share the same political existence. ...
Download paper


The paper "Plato and Rousseau’s Commentary on Constitutional Breakdown" explains that for Plato, an excessive increase in something would cause reactions directed in the opposite direction.Case in point, excess liberty, brought about by democracy, is highly likely to lead to excess slavery. …
Author : pollichdario

Related Essays

Majority decision in a democracy
10 pages (2510 words) Research Paper
Politics of Japans Constitutional Reform
8 pages (2008 words) Essay
Democratic Theory
8 pages (2008 words) Essay
Constitutional Law
4 pages (1004 words) Essay
Origins of neo-conservatism
10 pages (2510 words) Essay
European Treaties
6 pages (1506 words) Case Study
Constitutional principles of political power
6 pages (1506 words) Essay
Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you! Try us!