Plato and Rousseaus Commentary on Constitutional Breakdown - Essay Example

Only on StudentShare

Extract of sample
Plato and Rousseaus Commentary on Constitutional Breakdown

Plato thus emphasized that democracy, just like oligarchy, draws a rift between the rich and the poor (Rosen, 2008). With the perceiving the rich as plotting against them, they seek protection through rallying their support behind a champion. With the increasing support of the mob, such a champion is likely to turn into a tyrant. For Plato, the law ought to be a defining factor for all the actions of individuals within a certain jurisdiction and that people have to lose their freedom for the sake of gaining peace and harmony. To prevent degeneration of the constitution, Plato postulates that the law has to become the master of the government and the government to be its slave, so that every person is answerable to the law. In addition, Plato suggests that for a constitution to be effective then the government should be run by the best (aristocratic), so that the leaders are highly wise and that they receive proper training concerning how a state should be run.
Contrary to Plato’s view, Rousseau believes that constitutions that fail to recognize the individual moral responsibility of the citizens is bound to degenerate with time. As such, for any constitutional coercions to be justified, they must be based on certain general agreements among the citizens. Rousseau observed that constitutional governments were driven by an assumption that citizens within a given state, regardless of their divisions in terms of personal opinions, remain firmly in agreement concerning the desire to share the same political existence. ...Show more

Summary

The paper "Plato and Rousseau’s Commentary on Constitutional Breakdown" explains that for Plato, an excessive increase in something would cause reactions directed in the opposite direction.Case in point, excess liberty, brought about by democracy, is highly likely to lead to excess slavery. …
Author : pollichdario
Plato and Rousseaus Commentary on Constitutional Breakdown essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Plato and Rousseaus Commentary on Constitutional Breakdown"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

Plato
It does not appear from Plato's own writings that he was particularly intimate with Socrates, and he cannot have been more than twenty-nine years old when he saw the teacher for the last time.
13 pages (3250 words) Essay
Plato
The ideas spawned by him were given further life and shape by his bright pupil Plato, who also documented much of what Socrates orated to his audience. Although he was a prominent member of the Aristocratic class, his lack of deference to authority would ultimately lead to his tragic end.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Plato
Plato defines ‘able’ men in his Allegory of the Cave. A man who sees the light of knowledge and understands fully the truth (reality) is fit to rule people who are in living in darkness. This ruler, of Plato, will have seen the good and will be capable of ‘real’ good.
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Plato
(Plato,) His most famous work was named “The Republic” in which he describes that the ideal state of Good exists as an independent reality and that all human beings should aspire towards
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Plato
general definition, one might begin to understand the complexities involved in studying philosophy as it seems to encompass just about all knowledge pursuits. One of the earliest individuals to try to bring sharper definition to our deeper thoughts was Plato. It is through
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Plato
These include the schools, community and homes. For example, in American society, elementary schools relate to Plato’s cave because most of children from grade 1 to 6 lack information about life. They spend most of their time playing, acting crazy and they fail to
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Plato
The chapter equally describes the philosophical ideas Plato had in relation to the interdependency between an individual and the state on issues of what forms a republic and the worth of individuals being parts of a state, as well as
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Commentary
Briggs has very tactfully driven the reader back into history, making him go through phases of the development of media. He has exemplified how media flourished and took
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Commentary
Friedman raises the problem why marketization of modern times has become a nuisance. Habermas (20) argues that press became powerful during mercantilist phase of capitalism. Friedman (para.6)
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Commentary for Plato,s allegory of the cave
The tale of people trying to exit from the cave is a dramatic enlightenment and represents the source of true understanding about the world beyond their limited views. Platos tries to answer in a philosophical way some of the questions that many human beings ask
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT