StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Psicoanalisis - Book Report/Review Example

Nobody downloaded yet
As with Wilson's landmark account, Stanley Renner's identification of female sexual hysteria to explain both the supernatural aspect to the story and the governess's subsequent behaviour (176) would appear to bear out Peter Barry's claim in Beginning Theory that psychoanalytic critics privilege "the individual 'psycho-drama' above the 'social drama' of class conflict" (105).
Certainly, Renner makes no reference to class conflict in this essay. Much less does he see it as a mere "ghost story"; rather, it is to him very much a projection of internal fears and anxieties - its "dramatization of a woman's psychosexual problem and the damage it does to the children in her charge" is, he confidently states, "the true - and clearly the richer - story [...] (175).
Nevertheless, the supernatural aspects of the story cannot be dismissed out of hand, as Renner notes - indeed, his particular reading of the story arises in response to one of the strongest arguments against a purely naturalistic interpretation: how did the governess manage to give a detailed description of a man she had never seen, unless she had genuinely seen a ghost (175)
Renner's analysis of the governess's spectral visions centres on two propositions: first, that she is a casebook sexual hysteric, and second, that her uncannily detailed description is based not on a personal encounter with a ghost as she believes, but is instead the imaginary product of what he argues was a significant cultural theory in nineteenth century Europe. This is physiognomy, a pseudo-science which held that a person's character could be inferred from their physical features.
"Not only is it reasonably certain that James knew about physiognomical theories and the use of such devices by novelists familiar to him," writes Renner, "but he also creates in his governess a character who fits the profile of the typical sexual hysteric, who has hysterical hallucinations, and whose mind projects her sexual fear in a form that draws on the very religious and physiognomical stereotypes with which a mind such as hers would logically be furnished." (187)
With this device, Renner seeks to situate his Freudian underpinnings within a broader (non-Freudian) social context that draws upon two other (arguably rival) forms of interpretation that were commonplace in the culture of the time, physiognomy and religiosity. With the exception of a reference to the Oedipal implications of Miles and Flora's burgeoning sexuality (194), Renner's reliance on standard Freudian categories - the "classic psychoanalytic symptoms, conditions or phases, such as the oral, anal, and phallic stages" (Barry, 105) - is minimal.
The central interpretation preferred by Renner is still centred on Freudian theories of repressed female sexuality and hysteria. However, this manifests itself by the governess conjuring up, as it were, a stereotypical representation of a "redheaded sex ...Show more


How does Stanley Renner address the problem of psychoanalytic critics tending to privilege the individual "psycho-drama" of the author or characters over analysis of the novel's cultural context and dramatization of social conflict in his essay
Although the interpretative value of psychoanalytic criticism is highly contestable among literary and cultural theorists (Barry, 101-105, 130-133), it is, I believe, reasonable to argue that its use as an interpretative tool has greater legitimacy when considering a work such as Henry James' The Turn of the Screw, which is widely acknowledged by critics to be a portrait of abnormal psychology as well as being a "ghost story".
Author : shaniamorar
Psicoanalisis essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the book report/review on your topic
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Check these samples - they also fit your topic

How do the qualities of reading practices outlined in McKenzie and Grafton and Jardine's texts enable imperialism How did rea
Two of the most significant readings on the qualities of reading practices are Bibliography and the Sociology of Texts by D.F. McKenzie and “Studied for Action: How Gabriel Harvey Read His Livy” by Lisa Jardine and Anthony Grafton. Both these texts provide vital insights on how the qualities of reading practices enable imperialism and affect political change.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Management Development
29-46), which has lead to much more attention transferring on international human resource management (IHRM). This indicates the growing realization that international companies should manage their international human resources skillfully, since they have a large bearing on the success of such companies.
9 pages (2250 words) Essay
Undertake a review of the current literature to identify the key determinants of capital structure since the global financial crisis
It reveals the magnitude, nature along with the distribution on the basis of which financial funds are allocated in a particular organisation. The notion of capital structure signifies the assets and the liabilities of an organisation. In this regard, every organisation possesses a capital structure in accordance with which income along with expenses is determined.
5 pages (1250 words) Literature review
Can theories of management apply to media manager, organisations and /or activities or are such theoretical applications redundant
There are some special traits in the realm of media environments that should be taken into consideration at the time of applying the different standard management theories. Media people are most of the time free spirits. They tend to be very liberal and their behaviours are not so standard.
10 pages (2500 words) Essay
Social psychology
The social psychologist who attempts to do such experimentation, however, is faced with a number of difficult decisions which he must make. He must ask, first: do I know enough about the area I am investigating so that I may be confident that I will be dealing with important factors Second, do I know enough about these important factors so that I can adequately measure, control, and manipulate them in the laboratory And third, is my theoretical understanding sufficiently well advanced so that I can state specific hypotheses in a form amenable to precise scientific answer Thinking through the answers to these questions on a specific problem makes it clear that before we can begin to use the p
8 pages (2000 words) Essay
Direct Marketing
In contemporary business context, the wide spread use of bar codes for most commercial products, the computerisation of many business and government transactions, and the advances in data collection tools have provided us with huge amounts of data at unprecedented rates.
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Business and Employment Law
This was subsequently ratified by the Treaty of Amsterdam (the Treaty). Whilst the original purpose of the EU was “to create political unity within Europe and prevent another world
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Dualism and the Inconsistent Triad
It goes against holding the interactionist version of dualism and the physical law closure if taken together. The difficulty raised by the inconsistency triad is a genuine commonsensical problem from both the sides (Jacobsen, 68). We cannot
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Conflicts between perspectives and points of view
That was tiring and I always felt that I did not remember whatever I studied into the night. Still, I continued the practice but always found that I got some
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Profile of a Health Care Manager
The key element that makes a health care manager good is the possession of knowledge and skills required of the role and responsibilities that need to be undertaken within the health care environment. This includes ability to apply leadership styles that
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Hire a pro to write
a paper under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment