The False Memory Illusion - Essay Example

Only on StudentShare

Extract of sample
The False Memory Illusion

the lists are a product of free recall. Semantic associations must not be applied in reverse because they are generated using free recall and their only possible scientific application is semantically probabilistic.
Brainerd & Wright mistakenly interpret their higher FAS result scores as a result of suppressive processes used inappropriately "to reject studied items that preserve the gist of experience." (Brainerd & Wright 2005) This mistake has nothing to do with suppressive processes; in fact the rejection of these items is because their semantic association with the previously listed word is weaker and the probability of semantically associating from the first word to the second word should already have been known from the probability score, or the free recall. The priority of words is itself an illusion, not a false memory illusion; for example, each list must start with a word and it must end with another word. It is nonsense to suggest that the word following the first word might in some way be illusory. The semantic association that leads to the last word must take priority over any associative strength, whether forwards or backwards, because the lists are not illusory.
In a free recall exercise, as shown by Deese in his original paper, the first word is given to the subject who produces a second word. ...
Download paper


In the Brainerd & Wright model of verbal recall illusion semantic differences are arbitrary and corrupt. Forward and backward association of words is dependent upon semantics and not, as claimed, on any genuinely memorable association. Their results, used to argue the illusory nature of false memory, are unreliable because of a false premise: the Deese-Roediger-McDermott false memory illusion…
Author : gonzalo62

Related Essays

Autobiographical Memory
It has been researched that the people are more inclined toward remembering only the information which fits their image about themselves (Braisby & Gellafy, 2005; Eysenck & Keane, 2010). I would critically analyze this assumption in the light of the research journals and literature about autobiographical memory. The studies have been collected on various area of autobiographical memory which discusses several aspects of this memory system analytically. In this paper, I would also shed light on my own personal experiences and how I critically view them. Main Body Most people tend to confuse the...
6 pages (1506 words) Essay
Literature Review on False Memory
Generally, the false memory that is produced often has a very close relation with the stimulus that is presented. For instance a person who is trying to have memories of a monkey is likely to think of a chimpanzee as the element in question because among the clues there is a monkey and a monkey is generally more related to chimpanzee than say a cock is. When this happens, the monkey that caused the person to have a wrong memory of a chimpanzee is said to be the stimulus. Research Question How does delay versus instant recall and visual versus aural affect the false memory effect? Previous...
6 pages (1506 words) Literature review
Lab Report on false memory
False memory in the DRM paradigm Introduction Memory plays a critical role in our daily lives. This is particularly because our decisions, course of actions and interactions with situations or people are often based on our memory of the past experiences. It is, however, worth noticing that memory sometimes fails and individuals may often remember events either differently from what actually took place or events that never happened (Thapar and McDermott, 2001, 424). Many experimental researches have revealed that it is easy to implant or induce false memory in individuals, particularly through...
8 pages (2008 words) Essay
Human Memory
Human memory plays the most important role in advertising and marketing. Marketers have found that autobiographical memories may be spontaneously activated within the context of an advertising message (Baumgartner, Sujan, &Bettman, 1992; Krugman, 1967). Advertising and Marketing industries spend great amounts of resources to study and understand human mind. The consumers’ mental activities, especially, the memory are the key to victory in these businesses. Memory greatly influences the customer’s decision makings, thus knowing how and when to trigger and affect a customer’s mind means...
6 pages (1506 words) Research Proposal
Memory Strategies
The researcher hopes that the reader can come to a more full and complete understanding of the means by which certain memory strategies, although presented in an academic way within the text, can ultimately be utilized as a means of improving the daily life and experience of the individual user. As can be seen from the essay, the utilization of strategy with regards to memory is something they can ultimately be changed. Rather than viewing the individual as something of a sponge the merely walks through life and absorbs all information that it interacts, the process of classification,...
4 pages (1004 words) Essay
Imperfect Memory
Roediger & McDermott's (1995) had Rice University undergraduate students review six lists. The lists were drawn from listed in Deese's 1959 article. After the students reviewed the list, they were presented with another list of words. They were asked to identify the words that were on the first word list. Of the 42 words, 12 were from the original list and 30 were word lures. The 30 word lures fell into three categories: 6 words that inspired the original word lists, 12 words unrelated to the earlier list and 12 words slightly related to the list. The Roediger & McDermott experiment focused on...
6 pages (1506 words) Essay
false memory
ce that is mistakenly taken to be a veridical representation of an event from one’s personal past and they [false memories] arise from the same processes as do true memories and hence their study reveals basic mechanisms of memory (Bartholomew). This proposes the fact that a grave study is essential on this subject as it is exploring inner layers of the mind....
3 pages (753 words) Research Paper
Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you! Try us!