StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

How have groups of scholars cited the Qur'an to support their different stances on prophetic immunity from sin - Research Paper Example

Nobody downloaded yet

Extract of sample
How have groups of scholars cited the Qur'an to support their different stances on prophetic immunity from sin

Controversies arise when the revelations of God (the power that is incomprehensible to mind) are interpreted and discussed by the mind-level scholars. This is true of scholars of any religion and Islam is no exception. No scholar can reach the divine heights of prophets and as such common agreement for their different stances is impossibility. The followers of Islam have their inspiration and guidance from twin sources. “The norms and assumptions that have characterized belief and action in Islam have their initial inspiration in two foundational sources. One is scriptural, embodying the message revealed by God to the Prophet Muhammad and recorded in the Qur’an. The second is the exemplification of that message in the perceived model pattern of the Prophet’s actions, sayings and norms, collectively called the sunna.” (Nanji, n.p.)) For Muslims Qur’an is the ultimate scripture, its revelations are inviolable; it contains direct communication from God. The contents of Qur’an are not debatable; as such there is no question of difference interpretations as for those revelations. Sunna comes next in the order of preference in the sense it contains historical, but divinely inspired contents as guided by “Prophet Muhammad, whom the Muslims believe that he is the last in the series of messengers from God.”(Nanji, n, p.) He is the final religious authority for the Muslims. “The late Fazlur Rahman, noted University of Chicago scholar of Islamic thought and modernist Muslim thinker, argued that in its initial phase Islam was moved by a deep rational and moral concern for reforming society and that this moral intentionality was conceived in ways that encouraged a deep commitment to reasoning and rational discourse.”(Nanji, n.p.) Qur’an is the revelation of God and it cannot be compared or estimated with the measuring scale of reasoning. Here is the origin of conflict between the scholars. Because most of the scholars speak and write from the mind-level and they are not connected to the divine source. When revelations are weighed in the scale of human reason, the results are not going to be divine. Rational understanding and divine understanding are poles apart. Human beings may explain about their connectivity, which is not there in real terms. “The relationship between the Qur’an and the life of the Prophet, as a model of behavior, was also elaborated to create a legal framework within which values and obligations could be determined.”(Nanji, n.p.) But when the scholars intervene, no two scholars have ever given identical opinions on any contentious issue. Every scholar cites Qur’an but interprets its revelation in the light of the reasoning that one visualizes. Different stances of the scholars regarding prophetic sins need to be understood in this context. Prophetic immunity from sin: Truth needs to be followed implicitly when it has been accepted as truth. Truth is complete and there is nothing like partial truth. When the implementing authorities of truth, the Prophets especially chosen for the assignment, there is no question of deviation from the path of truth. They are expected to dutifully deliver truth to humankind. God has chosen them with a purpose and he has the detailed backgrounder information about the ones he has chosen. “However, Jonah (pbuh), for instance, deliberately abandoned his divinely ordained ...Show more

Summary

Subject: Research Paper, Religion and Theology Date: Topic: How have groups of scholars cited the Qur'an to support their different stances on prophetic immunity from sin?" Foundational Values of Islam and backgrounder information The foundational values of Islam are beyond question and are not subject to arguments…
Author : huelsjannie
How have groups of scholars cited the Quran to support their different stances on prophetic immunity from sin essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the research paper on your topic
"How have groups of scholars cited the Qur'an to support their different stances on prophetic immunity from sin"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Check these samples - they also fit your topic

Mullins' Doctrine of Sin

In order to analyze Mullins’s doctrine of original sin, the author will provide a summary of Mullin’s overall argument. The summary will be followed by a critique of the premises upon which the overall argument is built. The components of the doctrine are found within his systematic theology in various places.

14 pages (3250 words) Research Paper
How Education Effects the Annual Earnings of Different Minority Groups
According to the paper higher education like colleges and universities are not available for women and they are prevented from getting specialized degrees. This occurs because of a bias prevalent in society, which states that education is not as essential for women as it is for men. Lack of resources is also another reason why some groups such as women are prevented from acquiring a standard education.
10 pages (2500 words) Research Paper
How Different Stakeholder Groups Build Brand Value
In this modern age of business, marketing plays an essential role towards the success of an organization. Nowadays, concepts such as branding have become essential for a company to get success in the marketplace.
36 pages (9000 words) Research Paper
Multi Marriage Issue in Islam 'polygamy'
Phenomenon of polygamy exists in various cultural and religious setups such as, among Assyrians, Hindus, Christians, Romans, Persians, Babylonians, Athenians, Hebrews, and Muslims. There is a specific type of consensus about the permission of polygamy in the religion of Islam followed by Muslims.
15 pages (3750 words) Research Paper
Virtual groups and how they effect group communication
At times such typical teams may incorporate members who are distant from each other but are able to meet face-to-face on a regular basis (Hamilton, Hodgkinson & Byatt, 2010). Virtual teams on the other hand can be separated across space and time peripheries and have a very low level if any, of face-to-face interaction.
8 pages (2000 words) Research Paper
Mullins' Doctrine of Sin

This paper tells that several factors weaken Mullins's discussion of the doctrine of original sin. First, because components of his doctrine are scattered throughout Christian Religion, the overall flow of his argument is difficult to trace. In fact, one first encounter his claim that the sinful tendencies inherited from Adam are worthy of condemnation in the final section of his chapter on sin.

13 pages (3250 words) Research Paper
Compare and contrast two different type of suras in the Qur'an
Apart from this basic difference, both the categories of Surahs are distinct in content. The Makkan Surahs primarily were aimed to strengthen the Faith of the believers in Makka, who were majorly poor and weak and were living under the persecution
6 pages (1500 words) Research Paper
Using at least eight primary sources from the web sites provided, write a FIVE-TO-SIX-PAGE PAPER explaining the different opinions/stances that existed on the colonization debates of the 1800s (
been pleasing to some of the colonial masters, however, this is not the usual case, there were several arguments that were made for and against the process. This means that those who fronted the idea faced certain resistances from other people, while the process had to stop in
5 pages (1250 words) Research Paper
The Qur'an
The entire community repented and believe in God, and God lifted the punishment. On the other hand as Jonah was in the ship, a storm came to the ship in the sea and people casted the lots every time Jonah
7 pages (1750 words) Research Paper
The Qur'an
The entire community repented and believe in God, and God lifted the punishment. On the other hand as Jonah was in the ship, a storm came to the ship in the sea and people casted the lots every time Jonah
7 pages (1750 words) Research Paper
Hire a pro to write
a paper under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment