Defining Rule utilitarianism - Essay Example

Only on StudentShare

Extract of sample
Defining Rule utilitarianism

Finally, Hospers brings up the last example when people vote. Thus, on an election day people may or may not be willing to go and vote. The first example might be considered to be an objection to act utilitarianism since according to it killing the fat man would be quite useful for the group of people, but the majority of people would agree on the fact that killing is wrong. The second example also shows that act utilitarianism might be regarded as a false approach: it is true that sometimes for a particular individual lying might bring considerable more benefits that tell the truth; however, the society condemns lying. Finally, the third example may also be regarded as a valid claim that rebuts act utilitarianism. According to the latter, it would be more ethical not to vote for a person, but it is quite obvious that such approach would ruin the legal system.
Rule utilitarianism would provide a different solution for this problem. In case of the fat man, it would encourage people to let that man live. The reason for this is quite simple: it is generally accepted that killing other people is not an ethical action. That is why killing the person in question will violate the general rule which contributed to the security in the society. In the second example about lying, rule utilitarianism would urge a person to tell a truth even though it might be some problems. The logic behind it is rather simple: the social life is being productive and stable because people generally do not lie to each other. That is why if people chose to make an exception from that rule, they might undermine the very foundation of the society. Finally, in the example of voting, rule utilitarianism would encourage people to go and vote in spite of the fact that they may not be willing as if all the other people chose not to vote this is likely to break the democratic system and result in the collapse of the government.
In my opinion rule ...Show more

Summary

Rule utilitarianism is a kind of utilitarianism which defines if an action should be considered to be ethical or not based on the idea of rule that the majority of the people has been following (Smart, 1973, 9). Hospers presents three examples of ethical dilemma. The first of…
Author : xhirthe
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write a custom essay on your topic
"Defining Rule utilitarianism"
with a personal 20% discount.
Find out more

Related Essays

Utilitarianism
It appears that although both sides of the issue cam be highly criticized, it is also possible to find justification for tortures when applying the principle of Utilitarianism. As one of the most persuasive and influential
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Utilitarianism view on a dilemma
The basic relationship, which can be explained by the term, is between the happiness and the consequences. We can say that the philosophy says that the decision of any moral and ethical action may depend upon the resultant
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Utilitarianism
To end the ambiguity, it is prudent to understand that the two objectives complement each other. It is rather absurd to think that generating the greatest
1 pages (250 words) Coursework
How should one decide what is wrong and what is right? Compare and contrast the views of either Plato or Aristotle with either Kant or the utilitarians. Which view do you prefer? Why?
Being ethical requires making a moral judgment that is something not easy. The moral behavior takes courage and needs practice. Therefore, ethics has to do with the feelings that tell one what is right and what is wrong. The ethical
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
John Stuart Mills Utilitarianism
Individuals who employ higher faculties often get less contented even though their pleasure is of higher character than of an animal. This paper is a discussion of the mills statement that “it is better to be a human being dissatisfied than a pig
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Are all pressure ulcers avoidable
However, there are cases wherein nurses could face some ethical dilemma during practice. For instance, when handling a patient who is a minor or one that has severe dementia, some nurses may find it difficult to
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Find out how much would it cost
to get a custom paper written by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT