Counterargument to refute the first argument: the claim that death penalty deters crime is a mere presumption, with no scientific proof. A number of studies have shown that death penalty does not deter crime. Hence, the first argument is incorrect. Counterargument in refutation of the second argument: death penalty does not ensure justice for the offended party because by killing the offender, the offended party does not get back what they were deprived of. Again, death penalty may be not the gravest form of punishment. Third argument by the proponents of my view: death penalty is an effective form of punishment because it prevents overpopulation of prisons; death penalty also prevents the criminals of grave crimes from committing crimes while in prison, or breaking from the prison to commit crimes outside the prison. Counterargument to refute the third argument: although jailing of criminals guilty of grave crimes may provide the criminals with some possibilities of committing more crimes in future, with proper preventive measures in place, however, the possibilities of committing more crimes by the prisoners will be quite minimal. Death penalty is undoubtedly one of the oldest and most common forms of punishment meted out against heinous and grave crimes in many cultures and world civilizations. In USA, for instance, according to the Bureau of Justice Statistics, in the year 2009 alone, 52 inmates were executed. The advocates of death punishment also contend that death punishment is the most effective form.
Cite this document
(“The Death Penalty is not an Effective Punishment Essay - 9”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.net/social-science/726876-argumentative-essay
(The Death Penalty Is Not an Effective Punishment Essay - 9)
“The Death Penalty Is Not an Effective Punishment Essay - 9”, n.d. https://studentshare.net/social-science/726876-argumentative-essay.
Cited: 0 times
In this paper “The Death Penalty is not an Effective Punishment” the author argues that death penalty is an ineffective form of punishment. The effectiveness of death penalty indeed is a debatable issue that has elicited a lot of debate in many fields of study…
They continuously base their arguments for maintaining it on punishment, deterrence and as opposed to life imprisonment, its cost-efficiency (it is less expensive). This paper discusses the death penalty as a form of punishment and seeks to find its efficiency, worth and acceptability.
According to Marshal, the knowledge on the death penalty would however make very little difference in the belief in the death penalty for those who are in support of the death penalty for retributive purposes. The Marshal Hypothesis came about in reference to Justice Thurgood Marshal who relied on what he termed as democratic principles in his support of the abolition of the death penalty (Walker 351).
Its controversial intensity can be predicted by the fact that whenever the words “death-penalty” rises, two different groups of people start debating between themselves. Extremism is observed in the views of both the groups. One group says determent, dissuasion, obviation and preclusion while other group says desertion ad surrender.
This paper concerns capital punishment which is known as the legitimate way of taking life by the state for capital crimes.The author provides examples of capital punishment such as an electric chair, hanging and lethal injections -- some of the methods that are currently being used by countries practicing capital punishments.
One instance where the right-to-life can be deprived justly is when an individual is given the death penalty. This issue raises many questions and emotions on morality with some individuals insisting that it is morally justified while others deny. Others people base the need for the death penalty on welfare considerations, which many seem to agree on (McMahan 7).
Indeed, the likelihood is great that the punishment is tolerated only because of its disuse." Provide an analysis of how issues of public opinion indicate support or rejection of Brennan's reasoning. What is the Marshall hypothesis and what role does it play in the support or rejection of Brennan's argument Include both national and international examples in your response.
The man’s torso heaves in pain. After two hours of struggling with collapsed veins the team gives up. This is the true account of the botched execution of Romell Broom in Ohio State Prison on 15 September, 2009.
At present, the Federal Government and 38 States still
The author discusses that article, entitled “America’s Retreat From the Death Penalty”. It was revealed that more criminal justice practitioners and scholars have expressed increasing opposing arguments in terms of the effectiveness of capital punishment in servicing the paramount purpose for its imposition: deterrence and retribution.