He argues that homosexual people are equally capable of demonstrating such commitment as heterosexual people. Hence, the state should not discriminate between the two by failing to legalize gay marriage. I agree with the opinions of the author because his argument promotes the equality of all citizens and opens the doors to a healthier emotional, social and psychological life for homosexuals. Sullivan argues that in addition to a private agreement, marriage confers a special social status and recognition on the married couple, which entitles them to certain social privileges and respect. No citizen who can commit to a lifelong emotional, sexual and psychological relationship with another should be denied this social acceptance because of his or her sexuality. The notion that marriage is an institution for childbearing is no longer valid. Homosexual people are capable of being committed and responsible towards their partners. Hence, their relationships should not be denied the social and legal recognition awarded to similar relationships between heterosexuals. Conservatives should support gay marriage because the alternative would be more disastrous to the institution of marriage and family. Domestic partnerships, recognized in several states, would make it much easier for individuals to enjoy the benefits and privileges of marriage without entering being married to each other. Liberals should support gay marriage because it would encourage equality in society. Recognizing gay marriage would also help gay people, children and their families lead well-rounded public and family lives. They would learn to see themselves beyond their sexuality and develop as individuals with healthy personalities. The scope of the article is limited to the role of the state; hence, many of the arguments made in that regard are logical. However, it appears that the article oversimplifies the values and principles of liberals and conservatives. Sullivan assumes that all liberals blindly advocate equal opportunities for all citizens (Sullivan, 407) while other factors such as social norms and religious values may also influence their decisions. Similarly, the conservative view is presented as a stereotyped fear of social change. Given the assumptions, the arguments are made logically and are thus sound. The author does not remain fair to the conservatives, for example, when he assumes that they only have two alternatives to gay marriage open to them (Sullivan, 406). The parallel drawn between the opportunities for homosexuals in the military and in the institution of marriage (Sullivan, 405) is also weak because the two institutions operate in very different environments. I agree with the author on the importance of recognizing gay marriage legally. The most striking arguments are those made with respect to the impact of such legal recognition on the emotional and psychological well-being of homosexual people. The anxiety about the future of homosexual relationships will be reduced to a great extent when these relationships are given a legal and social status. Instead of adversely affecting the institution of heterosexual marriage, recognizing homosexual marriage will encourage long-term relationships. It will also be beneficial for the socialization and adjustment of gay children and young adults. It will give them the confidence to
Cite this document
(“Critique the article of Gay Marrige-by Sullivan Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.net/sociology/104066-critique-the-article-of-gay-marrige-by-sullivan
(Critique the Article of Gay Marrige-by Sullivan Essay)
“Critique the Article of Gay Marrige-by Sullivan Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.net/sociology/104066-critique-the-article-of-gay-marrige-by-sullivan.
Cited: 0 times
Name of of Professor Subject 3 September 2013 Critique of For Gay Marriage The article For Gay Marriage by Andrew Sullivan is an extract from his book Virtually Normal: An Argument about Homosexuality, published in 1995 by Picador Publishing. The book describes how homosexuality is perceived by Conservatives, Liberals, Prohibitionists, and Liberationists…
It is widely recognized that the front office plays a very important role in establishing the school's approachability and in working with the parents, but the researchers point out that there has not been a great deal of research in this area and they attempt to address this lack.
This statement is true for both parties in his estimation. The school district lacks the time to enact a well-developed public relations plan, and the public has apathy toward education that prevents them from becoming involved. After spending one of his five pages introducing the topic, Vollmer finally addresses the topic of his article’s title, the Great Conversation.
This article looks into the optimism of single mothers to determine how influential the optimism is in not only raising their children, but in the outcome of the life of the child. Article summary Purpose of research This article serves a great purpose, allowing researchers and single mother families to gain insight into the positivity that can be found in situations such as single mother-headed households.
A study on non verbal communication across different cultures by Zhaleh Semnani-Azad and Wendi Adair expounds on the manner in which different cultural clues influence the communication processes used by human beings when undertaking their negotiations, resolving conflicts and making serious decision in their daily activities.
The author argues that the electronic media or, more specifically, the digital revolution, did not replace or eliminate traditional forms of written communication; in fact, digital media has helped improve the durability and ubiquitousness of disposable literature, comprised of flyers, leaflets, fly-post, brochures, and pamphlets.
On June 06, 2013, Heghnar Watenpaugh published the article on Huffington Blog Post. The author starts the article with rhetoric question; why did a peaceful sit-in protest of a group of youth against uprooting trees from Gezi Park turn into massive demonstrations in many cities of Turkey, as well as in the other parts of the world.
It is a different story altogether in Asian countries. The Asian culture has a conservative outlook to gay relationships. Gay sex is often categorized along with drug addictions and sexual promiscuity- something to be shunned. It is looked upon as an unnatural tendency and associated with shame and guilt.
gays and lesbians; they emphasize that “gays and lesbians have ample political power, with key politicians backing their goals, including same sex marriage” (Sage). Sage also emphasizes in her article that for opponents of Proposition 8, they question whether or not the US
Change of the title from “Are adolescents with…” to “Are adolescent students with…” would make it more suitable for this research. The research has more studied the college-related factors that affect an early adult’s tendency to consume alcohol and illicit