The two are great political philosophers and sociologists whose works have influenced a lot of people. The work of Adam Smith on The Wealth of Nations has made tremendous changes in economics, governments and other fields especially his concept of the ‘invisible hand’. Rousseau’s work on social contract is also of great influence. Both believe social development took place in stages but differ on what these stages comprised of and on the role of social contract among others. For Smith the progress of society occurs when individuals are left free to conduct their affairs but for Rousseau, progress occurs when people’s interests are safeguarded by a sovereign. They both agree that division of labor is important in order to make progress but it also results in inequalities in society. Since both give an account of historical development of society, how do they differ in their explanations and which of the two theories is better in explaining this account of social change? This is a question that will be delved into in this piece of work. I shall argue that Smith’s theory is more credible than Adams in explaining social changes as it gives a step by step approach of what occurred and it relates to the political system prevalent in many nations today where the free market forces guide the market and government intervention is limited. Adam Smith was born in 1723 in Scotland to a middle class family. He was a follower of Scottish enlightenment and much influenced by the work of Hume. His work is also inclined to that of Karl Marx and the Marxians’ since it is based much on evolution of societies from feudal to capitalism though for him, he used the term commercial societies rather than capitalism. He believed that society developed in four stages: Age of hunters, age of shepherds, age of agriculture and age of commerce (Smith 1978 p. 149). However, he did not explain how these evolved or whether one came after the other but he indicated that each stage is more advanced than the other. Rousseau on the other hand, was born 1712 in Geneva and bases his work much on the ideas of early philosophers such as Plato and Socrates in Greek and Athens. In the Discourse on the Origin and Basis of Inequality among Men, Rousseau gave an account of how society developed from the state of nature to civilization. Savages were in state of nature but with the discovery of iron they started agriculture and as art improved, it gave rise to poets and philosophers who were more civilized. Unlike Smith, he did not specify stages but attributed civilization to development of tools, agriculture and reasoning (Rousseau, Discourse p. 181). There is a difference on the accounts of social change given by the two theorists. For Smith, the society developed out of unintended actions of individuals but for Rousseau, the society development was not an accident. Smith thus indicates that society evolved from that of hunters to that of commercialists. The hunter-gatherers were savages who depended on wild fruits and wild animals (Smith 1978 p. 149). They extracted their source of livelihood from nature without having to till the land or keep animals. In the process of hunting they realized they can keep animals as source of food hence the
Cite this document
(“Can pick from 3 options given on the instruction document Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.net/sociology/109918-can-pick-from
(Can Pick from 3 Options Given on the Instruction Document Essay)
“Can Pick from 3 Options Given on the Instruction Document Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.net/sociology/109918-can-pick-from.
Cited: 0 times
Name of student: Topic: Lecturer: Date of Presentation: Introduction Modern societies are believed to have been the product of historical developments. Many theorists have over time tries to explain how societies developed from the primitive stage to be the civilized societies they are today and the consequences of such developments such as the establishment of different forms of governments, growth of the judicial system or laws and other institutions of society…
Theistic existentialists contend that God created the Cosmos as an open system in which actions and events are not preordained, not fated to unfold in a specific sequence or within a given time frame. Strict theism precludes the possibility that reason and self-determination can not only help explain the divine (or at least one’s understanding of it), but that it can also be a determining factor in charting one’s own spiritual destiny.
That attempt to depict her Tokyo stay as nothing of consequence was however punctuated by what Shields would call as an “encounter” on her last day in the city. Resigned to label the whole conference as a “lonely punishment,” she proceeds to her one last official dinner function at a famous hotel in Tokyo some fifteen minutes walk away from her lodging place.
In Chapter Three, Woolf narrates the life of William Shakespeare’s sister, Judith, who does not have the same access to social, political, economic, and academic opportunities as William. As a result, she does not become a successful playwright like her brother, even when she has the same passion and imagination for writing (Woolf 3).
However, nature controls things that surround it, and just as nature, Gould claims that AIDS spares some people to have continuity in generation.
In the article, Gould explains how the human brain together with growth in
It all started when I was in high school. I had recently come across individuals who looked superb in long hair. I thought that was in fashion at that time and hence it inspired me endlessly. I wanted to have the same for myself too. I developed or came
who were entangled between their past and present, between the culture they have received in legacy and adaptations in the ‘New World’ to which they are initiated and destined to spend their rest of the life.
‘A Real Durwan’ is a story of an old woman, ‘Boori- Ma’
, which has ‘fighting’ notes included in the lyrics, and they find an outlet to assuage the age-old feelings of psychological grudge against exploitation. The outline of this music form has become saturated with caricatures of African American gangsters, pimps and the
ns and informal warning have become inefficient in the deterrence of crime, responsibility of punishing individuals for criminal acts lies with the state. This formalization of crime deterrence involves such practices as the use of incarceration as well probation as a means
Responding to the transition in behaviour, investors have fully exploited the opportunity by opening up more fast food chains, which continue to register high profits despite public and media campaigns. Apparently, this is evident in various Junk food stores ranging
2 pages (500 words)Essay
Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you!Try us!
Let us find you another Essay on topic Can pick from 3 options given on the instruction document for FREE!