Paternalism - Essay Example

Only on StudentShare

Extract of sample

Some scholars contend that the context and nuances of 'harmful' and 'harmless' are too broad and must be properly defined. Still, questions remain with regards which acts the state should criminalise and acts which the state should consider private and harmless. This paper will maintain Mill's argument that acts which evidently harm others should be criminalised. It will further argue that consensual acts in which consent lacks validity should also fall under the scope of the law and the control of private and 'harmless' behaviours fall beyond the aforementioned categories and is none of the state's business. However, the criminalisation of these acts, as Mill had argued, should not be meant to unnecessarily augment the power of the state.
In his work 'On Liberty,' John Stuart Mill brought forth the most compelling clarification on the distinction between liberalism and paternalism. He argues that 'the only purpose for which power can be rightfully exercised' over citizens, against their volition 'is to prevent harm to others' adding that 'the individual is sovereign' over himself (Mill, 24 ). ...
Download paper


In a liberal democratic society, paternalism is often indispensable. Although many view paternalism as a curtailment of liberty, many also view it as a form of protection from the harms that human beings are capable of inflicting on another. John Stuart Mill, although opposes paternalism, argues that it is justifiable to limit liberty as long as these constraints aim at preventing harm to be inflicted on other people…
Author : lbalistreri

Related Essays

Death and Dying Issues
Under the direction of Mike Nichols, and teleplay by Emma Thompson and Nicholas, Wit Film shows death and life as part of human life (Nichols 2) which helps people to learn how to live with others. When Vivian is diagnosed with ovarian cancer, she knows she is dying and that doctors are just using her as a guinea pig, not a person to save. In the final stages of her life, she only receives one visitor in the hospital. It is then that she realizes that she has been insensitive and unkind to people. She regrets this life and wishes she had been kinder to as many people as possible. It is in her...
4 pages (1004 words) Essay
Slavery and Race in the USA
Since centuries, slavery has remained one of the major issues of countries and civilizations around the globe. Even in an educated and developed country such as the United States, slavery continued to affect millions of people legally for more than a century. Initially, the slavery began in Virginia when it was an English colony and then it spread to almost all the southern states of America. In particular, historians have indicated that Black people were mostly the victims of this social issue, whereas, White people enjoyed the dominance as masters during this period slavery. Besides,...
5 pages (1255 words) Essay
A written analysis of the ethical dilemma. You are required to write an essay, critically discussing the application of ethical
According to Harris (2001), health care ethics, or bioethics, is the most crucial ethics all over the world because it entails the lives of human beings. Medical ethic is a set of honourable principles, values and standards that give guidance to individuals in hours when choices or decisions have to be made about health care in medical facilities (Harris, 1985). It further incorporates the behaviour in line with the right ethics that govern a person’s behaviour particularly when it relates to the responsibility and individuals with a health care facility. Case Study However, these situations...
8 pages (2008 words) Essay
Discussion Questions
Q1 The legislative responded by putting some measures in place through the commonwealth to protect children in the aboriginal communities. They included: restrictions of alcohol, reforming how the cash flows into the region to control substance abuse and also ensure that money meant for children welfare is not misappropriated. Ensuring that children attend school by linking the parents’ income support and payments of family assistance to school attendance and also providing meals for the children in school at the parents’ expense. They also ensured that all children underwent compulsory...
4 pages (1004 words) Essay
National Health Service Essay
This indicates that there has been a change in the NHS since its inception, and it has been argued that pouring money into an unreformed, poorly managed system has inevitably created waste - and will continue to do so. There is an array of arguments regarding these changes in all spheres. However, there has also been considerable debate and counter-arguments and consequently a volume of literature, so that the pattern of changes and its consequences over time may be evident on a closer look. In other words, the historical development of the NHS and social care may represent structurally the...
13 pages (3263 words) Essay
Social pressure discouraged those women who wanted to do at least something different from others. All media which were ran by men promoted traditional gender roles which forced women to accept the idea of being a housewife as bliss.
3 pages (753 words) Essay
Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you! Try us!