Corporate Manslaughter Law - Essay Example

Summary

account when they fail to identify hazards, assess risks and develop safe systems of work and thus put people at risk of death, debilitating illness or serious injury. The harsh indictment of TUC against UK's present laws on
Conditions likewise pointed out that under existing UK laws, a company can be convicted only if an individual who can be identified as the embodiment of the company itself is found guilty…

Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing

GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.1% of users find it useful

Read Text Preview

Subject: Sociology
Type: Essay
Level: Ph.D.
Pages: 4 (1000 words)
Downloads: 2
Author: crawford58

Extract of sample "Corporate Manslaughter Law"

Download file to see previous pages

guilty of gross negligence which is a difficult task. What happens in most cases is that those who get singled out for the offence are often the corporate directors or managers. Again, it must also be established in this case that there is sufficient evidence to convict. The UK government itself through the IBB Solicitors ("Corporations, Directors and Corporate Killing") admit that "corporations are notoriously difficult to prosecute under the current provisions (of the law)." In one case of workplace death involving a company called Herald of Free Enterprise, the IBB Solicitors noted the court's failure to identify the controlling mind although it was found that the said company was "infected from top to bottom with the disease of sloppiness" and "staggering complacency.

" The European Foundation for the Improvement of Living and Working Conditions likewise pointed out that under existing UK laws, a company can be convicted only if an individual who can be identified as the embodiment of the company itself is found guilty. This is a tall order. Because of the difficulty of identifying a senior manager as the controlling mind, the European foundation observed that "it is virtually impossible to successfully prosecute large companies." As a result, the UK courts have so far secured only a total of eight convictions for corporate killing, and all the cases involved directors of small companies at that.

The reason is that in small companies the bosses are few which make it relatively easier to pinpoint the controlling mind. In bigger companies, the lines of responsibility and management layers are complex, such that decisions related to workplace safety. This is a tall order. Because of the difficulty of identifying a senior manager as the controlling mind, the European foundation 1) Government to introduce corporate killing law. European Industrial Relations Observatory on-line.

European Foundation for the improvement of living and working conditions. Available from:

...Download file to see next pages Read More

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Corporate Manslaughter Law

Criminal Justice, Procedure, and Human Rights

The Homicide Act 1957 is the current law under which the two general forms of homicide fall - murder and manslaughter (Geary, 1998).... However, the second type of homicide, manslaughter under current law takes one of two forms: voluntary manslaughter, where there is intent to harm or kill but circumstances mitigate the offence to varying degrees depending upon the facts of the case and the defendant is "excused liability for murder because some mitigating factor may be present" (LAWCOM 237, 1996: p....

20 Pages (5000 words) Coursework

The Provisions of the Corporate Manslaughter and Corporate Homicide Act 2007

hellip; This provision will come in some time after the main enforcement date. The old Corporate Manslaughter Law was universally condemned as wholly inadequate.... After more than 10 years f delay, consultation and lobbying from campaigners, trade unions and industry, the corporate manslaughter and Corporate Homicide Act 2007 has finally entered the statute book.... Under the new law, which applies across the UK, an organisation will be guilty f corporate manslaughter (corporate homicide in Scotland) where a fatality was caused by a "gross breach" f a duty f care and the handling f the organisation's activities by senior management contributed substantially to the breach....

10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

The Corporate Manslaughter Reform

The proposed Corporate Manslaughter Law aims to tackle the identification principle by providing a new basis - a test that focuses on management failure at senior level within the organization instead of focusing on the negligent act of an individual employee.... This essay describes and discusses the crucial issues, that were involved in the corporate manslaughter, that is mentioned as the analysis of the Government's draft bill for reform.... The Problem of the Second Element of the Offence in Government's Proposed Draft Bill Reform on corporate manslaughter corporate manslaughter is a homicide for a corporation....

12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Corporate Manslaughter and Corporate Homicide Act 2007

Although it has been duly criminalized in many countries, the law used to prosecute the offense is often Thus, existing laws against corporate manslaughter are generally compared to a paper tiger.... Media likewise estimated that over 40,000 people in UK had been killed in commercially related circumstances between 1966 and 200610, but under the old common law of manslaughter, only 34 companies were prosecuted for homicide and only seven resulted in convictions....

9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Criminal Law involuntary manslaughter; corporate homicide

However, considering the widespread existence of incidences of corporate manslaughter there is an urgent need for law to implement policies and legal restrictions on corporate organizations that act as a deterrent and help in preventing and controlling such crimes to a significant extent.... This paper on Criminal law attempts to study, analyze, investigate and discuss various aspects related to corporate homicide and corporate manslaughter in reference to the recent corporate manslaughter and Corporate Homicide Act, 2007....

12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Constructive Manslaughter

nbsp; However, the second type of homicide, manslaughter under current law takes one of two forms: voluntary manslaughter, where there is intent to harm or kill but circumstances mitigate the offense to varying degrees depending upon the facts of the case.... Constructive manslaughter assigns guilt to the defendant even though they may not have intended the injury or death of the victim and a reasonable person may not have conceived that the death would result, but the responsibility for the death, none the less, is found in the commission of an illegal “quite unconnected and possibly minor unlawful act” (law COM 237, 1996: p....

22 Pages (5500 words) Term Paper

The Corporate Manslaughter and Corporate Homicide Act 2007

This essay "The corporate manslaughter and Corporate Homicide Act 2007" critically discusses why the corporate manslaughter and Corporate Homicide Act 2007 was felt to be necessary and how this legislation has been received by academic writers and other commentators.... hellip; The corporate manslaughter and Corporate Homicide Act 2007 was enacted to address the problem associated with the apportioning of corporate liability.... The law in relation to manslaughter places a requirement on the claimant to identify a specific person who can be held responsible for the offense....

9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Corporate Manslaughter and Homicide - Not Crimes

This research paper, corporate manslaughter and Homicide - Not Crimes, outlines that the corporate manslaughter and Corporate Homicide Act is a good step, but it is nothing like what needs to be instituted to deter widespread corporate manslaughter.... The new draft bill on corporate manslaughter is a ghost of what was once proposed.... Home Secretary claims that delays were due to the complexity of the law are belied by the rapidity which the Prevention of Terrorism Act was pushed through Parliament, which allows conviction prior to a fair trial....

14 Pages (3500 words) Research Paper