The need for ART in Australia is rising over the years. In Australia and New Zeeland in 2008 there were 61929 assisted reproductive cycles which is 9% incensement from 2007 and 47% increase from 2004 (Yueping et al. 2010). As we can see, the trends of these procedures rise over the years which in the same time are a source of a debate over the public expends over these procedures. This is actually the source of the initiative to restrict the access for ART for women above the age of 40 years along with some other criteria. This however produces many ethical and social questions and some of them we will try to explore in this text. First topic In a study conducted by Georgina et al. 2005 it was found that average costs of chosen assisted reproductive technique for a live birth of a baby in Australia was 32 903 dollars, however these number are much different when compared within age groups. They found that in women below age of 30 years ART costs for a live birth event was approximately 24809 dollars and in the same time ART costs for live birth event in women above age of 40 was 97884 dollars. As we can see the differences are significant. The fact that ART services in year 2004 costs around 79 million dollars (less than 1% of total health expenses), however the constant rise of the trends for using of ART raised questions about ways to reduce the costs for these procedures. As we can see from the above example ART in women above the age of 40 at average costs significantly more when compared in women below the age of 30 years. In the same time the efficacy of ART in women above the age of 40 years is significantly smaller when compared with younger women. Only 6 percents of ART in women above 40 years old result in live birth compared to above 25 percents in women below the age of 30 years. In the same time pregnancies in women above age of 40 years are more prone to complications and risks for the mother and the health if the child as well. (Gilbert et al. 1999) (Bryant et al. 2005). This is why there are initiatives to limit the availability of ART procedures to women below the age of 40 years old. As we can see from above, finances and risk of complications are the main reasons for the initiative for restriction of ART in women above 40 years. There are several principles in the theory of ethics that are affected by the restriction of ART to women older than 40 years. One of them is the principle of beneficence which in the ethics is defined as a priority of “good” (Tassano 1999). At a first glance we can conclude that this restriction will deprive the younger patients from ART treatment by spending money and resources that can be used by the younger women. However as we have seen the expenses are small and doesn’t affect the quality of ART service for younger women, nor the quality of general health services in Australia. So in essence this restriction will not cause significant benefit for younger women or the general population. However it will reduce the grow-rate in Australia, which is already one of the lowest in the world. We can conclude therefore that this decision in essence is “bad” and in direct opposition with the principle of beneficence. From the standpoint of the individual women the above restriction is a restriction of their right as individuals to choose to have a child. In the same time by denying this right the above restric
Cite this document
(“Women Restrictions in accessing Assisted Reproductive Technologies Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.net/sociology/48408-women-restrictions-in-accessing-assisted-reproductive-technologies-arts
(Women Restrictions in Accessing Assisted Reproductive Technologies Essay)
“Women Restrictions in Accessing Assisted Reproductive Technologies Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.net/sociology/48408-women-restrictions-in-accessing-assisted-reproductive-technologies-arts.
Cited: 0 times
Assisted reproductive technologies (ART) are a group of medical processes that are used in order to assist a woman to get pregnant. There are many procedures used today like in vitro fertilization, gamete intra-fallopian transfer, artificial insemination, reproductive surgery and others, but most commonly assisted reproductive technology is associated with in vitro fertilization…
Here, it will be attempted to: identify and evaluate the ethical principles used in resolving ethical dilemmas—taking into account the identification and discussion of applicable state and federal laws or regulations as well as ethical theories and principles; apply the principles to specific ethical issues that may have professional, sociological, economic, legal, or political implications; and, with a focus on the “implications” stated above, discuss conditions under which it is ethical for physicians to perform abortions.
Dear Congressman, From the time that slavery was abolished, the United States has consistently expanded upon the freedoms of its people. With freedom to vote, to own land, to marry, and so on, one group after another has gained rights. Somehow, that trend seems to not only have slowed down, but to have reversed itself.
Women and their Rights to Sexual and Reproductive Health Outline Introduction Literature Review Argument Presentation Discussion Conclusion Most societies in the world, including the society in which we live in, have seen and considered the male gender role as the main authority who owns the power, control and influence in every social organization.
Parallel problem relationship patterns with peers and family unit often require involvement. This paper will research through an interview on the middle childhood stage. The interview and observation is carried on a young girl suffering from Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder.
Other damage, including physical abnormalities, developmental delays and fetal growth retardation are known as Fetal Alcohol Effects (FAE).
All research journal discussed similar issue of 'FAS' that is based on extrapolation from epidemiological studies of pregnant women.
This paper analyzes impact of photography on the visual arts in the 19th century. Since the photographic process is similar to cinematography, the technologies intertwine. The same movements affecting photography and other visual art impacted cinematography as well. Later in the 20th century photo –realism became a big hit.
In the U.S., one ground being analyzed for utilizing diversion is the quest for a solution on easing burdened courts off overcrowded detentions. This is meant to be sustained by case management whereby files of a
In men, uncomplicated gonorrheal infection manifests as urinary complaints of burning sensation on urination and purulent urethral discharge. Only a small number of infected men are asymptomatic. However, they are important reservoir for the