StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Property rights and genetic engineering - Essay Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
Property rights and genetic engineering

The idea of patenting by itself is reasonable, the main problem is in its awkward implementation, so the author states that current GES-patent policies have their drawbacks and then she tries to prove it by giving evidence from different sources and spheres of life. Firstly, current situation in the market of biotechnology is observed. Secondly, economic and ethical theories are involved to show the inconsistency of adherents of current GES-related policies. Finally, summing up all the key moments and objections, the author gives possible ways out of existing practice.
The main concern is that today genetically engineered products are exploited with an only purpose of making big money without thinking about possible consequences, which may become apparent already tomorrow. Biotech moguls argue that their products are not harmful at all, that GES seeds, for example, are identical with the natural. Sometimes they seem to forget about the ethical aspect of the issue and do not ask whether GES should be patented without consent of the state. The main idea sounds as follows: if there are no negative effects detected today, there are no such at all. Certainly, it is simplification, and in fact, effects could be found only many years later, when new technologies appear but then it could be already too late. ...
It should be especially mentioned that such technologies could destroy the rural economies of developing and third world countries also because unemployment and seed prices are increasing.
But these are not the only arguments of those who are against current GES-related patent system. John Locke's theory of property rights is applied here. In fact, these were GES-patenting followers who first started to justify their position by using this classic economic and ethical concept. But their interpretation show the best advantage of property owners because they give only superficial facts and pronounce only general statements. Their opponents raise an objection to it: biological resources cannot be owned, they should be shared, they say. And they find a lot of facts within the Locke's theory which confirm their objections.
Surely, Locke stated that people own the products of their labor the same way as they own their bodies. But the philosopher also added: there should be "enough and as good" common properties left for other people. And that is not the only limitation: there is also law of nature, labor theory and preservation theory. He mentioned that the life of another person could never be determined by the rights of property. All the property is given by God, it is common for all the people and though they are living in a society, they are governed by the law of nature and the law of peace and stability preservation.
Proponents of current GES policies draw attention to Locke's thought that only labor determines the difference of value. But there was no act of creation new seeds, scientists just purified or engineered them.
American biotech companies take out patents for ...Show more

Summary

Every day new technologies appear, but like any innovations, these have their positive and negative sides and that means, there are proponents and opponents of novelties. The issue of genetically engineered organisms gave rise to hot debate, this article concerns the problem of current GES-related policies…
Author : othompson
Property rights and genetic engineering essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Property rights and genetic engineering"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

Human Genetic Engineering
Other individual disciplines have come into existence, which were only desired about in the past; the concept of nanotechnology and other small features is an example of the extent to which science has made progress. Compared to the past centuries, the field of science and experimentation has provided us with a large number of elements and items.
16 pages (4000 words) Essay
Genetic Engineering
Beginning with the sampling of the DNA structure by Watson and Crick, scientists have reached the point where they are able to manipulate and replicate DNA. The effect in the research of genetics has had far reaching applications in the medical field. One of the most important types of gene sequencing and replication which is done on a daily basis is the creation of insulin.
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Human Gentic Engineering
The human society is, however, divided in their interpretation of the products of genetic engineering in general. While one faction demonstrates enthusiastic acceptance of what the influx of biotechnology has to offer, another faction takes offense on what they consider as an irreverent attack on nature and God’s creation.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Biology: Genetic Engineering
However what was remarkable about Dolly was that she was a clone of her six year old mother sheep. Dolly was the first successful experiment of a mammal being cloned. There had been various attempts made at cloning animals, however without success. The success of cloning Dolly therefore was a significant achievement for scientists as it showed the world that cloning of animals was no longer a dream but a reality (Spangenburg, Moser and Moser 7).
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Genetic Engineering
As an initial matter it is necessary to define what is meant by genetic engineering. This process is known by many terms, such as genetic engineering, genetic modification, and the splicing of genes. Generally speaking, genetic engineering is the manipulation of genes outside of the reproductive process.
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Genetic Engineering
According to the essay eugenic policies include compulsion through state legislation or persuasion through counseling, particularly for citizens with genetic defects. Laws are passed that limit the number of children a family can have, although in countries like China, it has something to do with controlling its population explosion.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Genetic Engineering
c engineering within the larger context of biology, examine the function and the significance of genetic engineering, and discuss the potential applied benefits in terms of agriculture, medicine, economics, and society. It will conclude with the author’s personal view of
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Genetic Engineering
Normal physical diseases can be treated or at least the symptoms controlled, with the help of pharmaceutical products but in case of a genetic diseases or disorder, medicines will do no good because medicines cannot
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Genetic Engineering
The author of the essay describes positive and negative sides of the genetic engineering technology. He describes such controversial themes as ethics in genetic engineering, human rights in regard of genetics, genetic engineering in the field of medicine, genetic modification of plants and bacteria etc.
9 pages (2250 words) Essay
Genetic Engineering
The author of this paper states that expansive and continued research and experimentation in the field of genetic engineering and the cloning of organisms will produce major breakthroughs in the science and engineering field about the knowledge of organism and especially human anatomy in the genetics topic.
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation