Both Jack and Ralph have been thrust into the survivor’s head because of the dire need for a leader figure. Both are also reluctant leaders at first who later got the feel of how things are done until it becomes almost second nature for them to lead. Third, both characters saw and realized the need for a leader in their respective locations. On the other hand, while the boys elected Ralph in a formal meeting duly conducted for that purpose, their adult versions did not see such need. Instead, the series opened with the survivors in chaos and Jack Shephard was directing him into leadership.
The second pair of characters for comparison is made up of Roger from the novel and Sawyer from the TV series. Both depict evil in its purest and most basic form. They serve as reminders about man’s human nature and how easily they can succumb to doing evil especially when emotion has overruled reason and logic. Moreover, both characters have no qualm about killing another person. Both have a history of killing another with their own hands. On the one hand, Roger killed Henry and other “enemies” of the tribe while sawyer killed the person whom he thinks is responsible for what happened to his parents.
Finally, the characters up for comparison are Piggy from the novel The Lord of the Flies and Hurley from the TV Series Lost. Admittedly, for this third pair, there are more differences than there are similarities. Although both characters are big and fat, they have a totally different ways of contacting and connecting with others. While Piggy is rather aloof and kept mostly to himself, Hurley was the life of the party. If Hurley is not amusing people with his remarkable stories, Hurley is out distributing food and just keeping the others alive and well.
Finally, both The Lord of the Flies and Lost share the same element of mystery in it. In the former, it is a mystery how the boys survived the crash and how they