StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

How Architecture Transformed the Objectives of Edifices - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This paper compares three essays: Scientific Paragon to Hospital Mall; Cultural Infrastructure; The City as Moral Universe Yi-Fu Tuan. Each of them tackled how architecture transformed the objectives of edifices by driving the changes in the way people see and use them…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.7% of users find it useful
How Architecture Transformed the Objectives of Edifices
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "How Architecture Transformed the Objectives of Edifices"

How Architecture Transformed the Objectives of Edifices This paper will compare three essays: Scientific Paragon to Hospital Mall by David Sloane; Cultural Infrastructure by Robert Leighninger; and, The City as Moral Universe Yi-Fu Tuan. All of these papers talk about the architectural importance in the design of public spaces and their evolution – hospital, the city and the embodiment of the New Deal in designing infrastructure in public spaces. Each of them tackled how architecture transformed the objectives of edifices by driving the changes in the way people see and use them. Sloane’s piece explored the evolution of hospitals from an institution that only for the caring of the poor to one that eventually catered to everyone, including the privileged who have preferred to take medications and treatment at home ever since. The main idea of the essay is found on the third paragraph after a considerable discourse on the background of hospitals and medical treatments from the 1900s. To quote: “In a quirky continuation of past thinking about the need for a civic image for the hospital, designers and administrators began emulating community center, the shopping mall. As a result, hospitals entrances became more welcoming, waiting rooms more inviting, facilities reintegrated more fully into daily urban life, and patients (or even better clients) treated more as guests or consumers.” (p. 82) The argument is that by adopting an environment of domesticity and emulating community-center, hospitals were able to change the old negative perception into something pleasant even without any significant alteration to the patient-doctor relationship. From cold, clinical and drab institution into a welcoming public space, Sloane successfully depicted how hospitals were effective in taking control of their development and their future by using architectural design in their strategy to adopt. Meanwhile, Cultural Infrastructure investigated the influence of Franklin Roosevelt’s New Deal on the modern design of American public space. It immediately opined that such “brief and rich period of commitment to public building produced many of the works that define the public space we now use”. (p. 226) It was cited that Roosevelt Administration resulted in the widest public building program ever that left a lasting mark on what Leighninger called as cultural infrastructure – roads, bridges, schools, courthouses and other public facilities such as parks, museums, gardens, civic centers and city halls, among others. The paper is well researched and has outlined impressive figures and data to support arguments made. For example, a list of new and modified infrastructures and edifices were provided, showing the number of constructed buildings ranging from schools to rodeo grounds. An important claim made by the author was the fact that the flurry of construction completed during the period was driven by the need to address the unemployment and economic stagnation of the Great Depression. The reference to this variable allowed Leighninger to explore the distinct contribution of the New Deal to the way public spaces were designed. A case in point was the suggestion that public spaces were designed in such a way that they might discourage dissent. This is supposedly demonstrated in the way the construction of large spaces was avoided and instead more neutral and distracting ones were erected such as zoos and gardens. While there are evidences of large public spaces constructed such as the Orange Bowl and Cow Palace, Leighninger maintained that there was, indeed, the presence of bias in favor of smaller spaces that constrained politically charged atmosphere. (p. 230) A more important claim, however, was made when the author discussed how public space – as approached by the New Deal architects and urban designers – is not all about the economic consideration. Given the fact that the main driver of the construction boom was to address economic problems, the design and construction of buildings and facilities were not primarily undertaken for purposes of profit and popularity. According to Leighninger, “in both calculable and incalculable ways, public facilities have an impact on the quality of life” positively affecting the health, well-being and security of the citizens. (p. 230) Finally, Tuan’s discourse revolved around the city and its design. The subject is quite complex, prompting the author to devote a significant part of the paper to history and to explaining several pertinent concepts such as how “universal brotherhood”, the “physical city”, among others. However, Tuan specified the topic by adopting the moral bent to his discourse – that the city embodies a type of moral document wherein “wealth and poverty, dullness and imagination, care and indifference, justice and injustice” can be discerned. His main argument is that everything that is found in the city – from streets, bus shelters, to parks – each has its moral-ethical intent. (p. 316) Tuan is of the opinion that the moral reading of the cityscape is the only approach by which all of us can comprehend the city. The idea is that through this perspective, all the dynamics and variables that characterize the urban environment, including the contrasting ones, would be sufficiently covered. For example, through this perspective, it is easy to understand how the city can cause guilt and depression, generate both modesty and pride, contain good and evil, depict beauty and ugliness, and so forth. This is quite interesting because the train of thought logically commenced in the distinct position that there are many infrastructures, buildings and facilities that are not being appreciated and that they deserved to be because the moral dimension to their design can be a source of pride, display the goodness of the human spirit, the consistent drive to hope, and so on. The three readings differ in style. For instance, Sloane wrote in a more scholarly manner, constantly citing historical data while Leighninger adopted a more investigated approach in presenting his points. This is not unlike how a reporter would write a documentary – objective and peppered with pertinent facts and figures. Tuan, for his part, opted to be more circumspect and proceeded on with an opinionated commentary about the what and whys in the cityscape or urban design. This is not to say that his discourse is biased but instead it is full of interesting personal insights based on learned argumentation as supported by authoritative claims and evidences. Each of these papers presented and argued their cases effectively. In some instances, the impassioned claim of an author could trump up the cold presentation of evidence of another while in some, the statistics or historical data presented by one of the authors could effectively persuade the reader rather than the deep personal insights posited by the other. However the case is, in this aspect, all the three readings are successful in what they wanted to achieve. They were educational and well-written pieces. Subtle differences are also present, technically. For example, there was the way the authors diverged in presenting their pieces. Tuan began with general concepts and winded them down into his specific topic. Leighninger is more straightforward, preferring to dispense with his discourse in a logical flow of ideas with seamless transitions of paragraphs. Sloane’s own strategy is more complicated but comprehensive. A claim or an argument would be preceded by background information making entire paper divisible into mini-stories that could stand almost independently, by themselves. Technically, the writing approaches of Sloane, Leighninger and Tuan may also differ in some respects but that they were similar in some as well. For example, all of them were not overly creative and informal as what is called for in academic writing. In addition, points were outlined in objective manner. But the bottom line is that each of these essays was an excellent resource for any researcher or student studying the subjects and themes that each has covered. Opinions may vary, depending on the reading preferences of the reader but, again, all the three texts are well-written, informative and persuasive materials. Works Cited Leighniinger, Robert. “Cultural Infrstructure: The Legacy of New Deal Public Space.” Journal of Architectural Education. 49.4 (1996): pp. 226-236. Sloane, David Charles. "Scientific Paragon to Hospital Mall: The Evolving Design of the Hospital, 1885-1994." Journal of Architectural Education (1984-). 48.2 (1994): pp. 82-98. Tuan, Yi-Fu. "The City as a Moral Universe." Geographical Review. 78.3 (1988): 316-324. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“How Architecture Transformed the Objectives of Edifices Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/education/1408145-analytical-essay-comparing-the-three-readings
(How Architecture Transformed the Objectives of Edifices Essay)
https://studentshare.org/education/1408145-analytical-essay-comparing-the-three-readings.
“How Architecture Transformed the Objectives of Edifices Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/education/1408145-analytical-essay-comparing-the-three-readings.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF How Architecture Transformed the Objectives of Edifices

Has The Architect Lost His Way

architecture has been regarded over time as the art and science of designing buildings and structures.... It holds within its wide scope the design of the total built environment - including town planning, urban design, and landscape architecture, and creating furniture.... … The term "architecture" is also used for the profession of providing architectural services.... architecture has come to denote the art and discipline of creating an actual, or inferring an implied or apparent plan of any complex object or system....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

The importance of listing and conserving historic buildings

However, certain historic buildings are unique deserving special importance both nationally and internationally.... This has led to the emergence of various heritage protection teams for identifying such special buildings for… The Architect's Journal reported the following in 1975: Architectural Conservation should be accorded the same consideration which is already being shown to the conservation of other resources for the same reasons....
40 Pages (10000 words) Essay

History on Film: Amadeus

Both Forman and Shaffer ensured that we, viewers, become a part of the excessive bacchanalian revelries of the aristocrats and people who matter in Austria; the pompous celebration of art, music and culture; that we view the ornate, majestic edifices of the 18th century Austria ruled by the Hapsburg royalty, which at this juncture in time was governed by the highly cultured Emperor Joseph II, the son of Empress Maria Theresa and Francis I and the brother of the ill-fated Marie Antoinette of France....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Title: Architectural Transformation

They oppose positively or negatively our massive industrial and commerce edifices with the remnants of the past such as cathedrals and palaces, or they attempt to understand the extent of achievement or collapse of different welfare states in the value of their housing and their educational institutions.... Architectural transformation is often unclear to some historians because of the many facets that have to be considered in order to make an accurate general history of the evolution of architecture....
44 Pages (11000 words) Essay

Christian Church Architecture

This essay analyzes that church architecture changed a lot from its early beginnings during Constantine's rule up to the eleventh century; however, at first glance the churches still appear to have many of the same elements.... It initially began as a basilica, and then turned into a domed basilica....
21 Pages (5250 words) Essay

How Emerging Technologies Can Affect an Industry

This case study "how Emerging Technologies Can Affect an Industry" seeks to explore the various factors affecting the spread of emerging technology-based firms within the current global economic climate.... Modern technological innovations have allowed firms to employ technology as their core competency that employs negligible traditional tangible merchandise....
10 Pages (2500 words) Case Study

The Comparing of the Three Readings

For example, a list of new and modified infrastructures and edifices were provided, showing the number of constructed buildings ranging from schools to rodeo grounds.... From cold, clinical and drab institutions into a welcoming public space, Sloane successfully depicted how hospitals effectively took control of their development and their future by using architectural design in their strategy to adopt....  This is supposedly demonstrated in how the construction of large areas was avoided, and instead, more neutral and distracting ones were erected, such as zoos and gardens....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

The New Couture Design

This research paper "The New Couture Design" addresses issues about the current architecture and fashion design that have been infiltrated and merged.... This same trend occurs in architecture.... he language used by experts in architecture and fashion is largely exchangeable.... architecture has a similar origin to fashion in terms of modern forms.... Despite the fact that architecture has existed for decades, it has diversified into a completely modernized discipline....
21 Pages (5250 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us